Breaking Deadlocks: Reward Probability and Spontaneous Preference Shape Voluntary Decisions and Electrophysiological Signals in Humans

Wojciech Kossut Zajkowski, Dominik Krzemiński, Jacopo Barone, Lisa H. Evans, Jiaxiang ZhangComputational 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Choosing between equally valued options is a common conundrum. Classical decision theories often predict prolonged response times (RT) in such cases, yet humans typically make these choices efficiently. This study investigates the neurocognitive processes underlying these "voluntary" decisions by integrating cognitive modeling (Linear Ballistic Accumulator) and EEG recordings. The findings reveal that reward probability and spontaneous internal preferences act as "deadlock breakers" by accelerating the rate of evidence accumulation, a process reflected in early electrophysiological signals.

The "Buridan’s Ass" Paradox

The classic paradox of Buridan’s ass describes a donkey situated between two identical piles of hay; unable to find a rational reason to choose one over the other, it starves to death. In human decision-making, models like the Drift Diffusion Model (DDM) suggest that when evidence for two options is equal, the net evidence is zero, theoretically leading to infinite response times. However, humans resolve these ties quickly. This research explores how the brain avoids such deadlocks.

Methods: Modeling the Decision Race

To understand the mechanics of these choices, researchers used the Linear Ballistic Accumulator (LBA) model. Unlike models that look at the difference in evidence, the LBA posits that each option has its own independent "accumulator" or race toward a decision threshold.

The Linear Ballistic Accumulator (LBA) model illustrates the independent 'race' between two evidence streams (e.g., pentagon vs. triangle) to reach a decision threshold.

The study involved 23 participants performing a binary choice task between cues with identical reward probabilities (ranging from 20% to 100%). By using hierarchical Bayesian parameter estimation, the authors could determine whether behavioral changes were due to faster sensory processing or faster internal evidence accumulation.

Key Insights: Breaking the Tie

The study identified two primary factors that "break" the deadlock:

  1. The Certainty Effect: Even when options were equal, higher overall reward probability (e.g., 100% vs. 100%) led to faster decisions than lower probability (20% vs. 20%). A "richer" environment primes the brain for faster action.
  2. Spontaneous Preference: Participants naturally developed a preference for one cue over its identical counterpart, choosing it more frequently and faster.

Crucially, modeling showed that these effects were driven by changes in the drift rate—the speed of evidence accumulation—rather than "non-decision time" (visual encoding or motor execution).

Neural Signatures of Evidence Accumulation

EEG recordings and Multi-Voxel Pattern Analysis (MVPA) revealed that the brain begins to represent reward certainty and preference as early as 120–150 ms post-stimulus. Furthermore, the researchers found that the slope of activity between the N100 (visual) and P300 (decision) ERP components predicted the drift rate on a trial-by-trial basis. A steeper neural "rise" corresponded to faster evidence accumulation.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that voluntary decisions are not truly random. Instead, the brain leverages environmental reward levels and internal biases to accelerate the decision-making process. By increasing the drift rate of evidence accumulation, these mechanisms prevent the "deadlock" predicted by classical theory, ensuring efficient behavior even in the face of indifference.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Choosing between equally valued options is a common conundrum, for which classical decision theories predicted a prolonged response time (RT). This contrasts with the notion that an optimal decision maker in a stable environment should make fast and random choices, as the outcomes are indifferent. Here, we characterize the neurocognitive processes underlying such voluntary decisions by integrating cognitive modelling of behavioral responses and EEG recordings in a probabilistic reward task. Human participants performed binary choices between pairs of unambiguous cues associated with identical reward probabilities at different levels. Higher reward probability accelerated RT, and participants chose one cue faster and more frequent over the other at each probability level. The behavioral effects on RT persisted in simple reactions to single cues. By using hierarchical Bayesian parameter estimation for an accumulator model, we showed that the probability and preference effects were independently associated with changes in the speed of evidence accumulation, but not with visual encoding or motor execution latencies. Time-resolved MVPA of EEG-evoked responses identified significant representations of reward certainty and preference as early as 120 ms after stimulus onset, with spatial relevance patterns maximal in middle central and parietal electrodes. Furthermore, EEG-informed computational modelling showed that the rate of change between N100 and P300 event-related potentials modulated accumulation rates on a trial-by-trial basis. Our findings suggest that reward probability and spontaneous preference collectively shape voluntary decisions between equal options, providing a mechanism to prevent indecision or random behavior.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zajkowski2020breaking,
  author = {Wojciech Kossut Zajkowski and Dominik Krzemiński and Jacopo Barone and Lisa H. Evans and Jiaxiang Zhang},
  title = {{Breaking Deadlocks: Reward Probability and Spontaneous Preference Shape Voluntary Decisions and Electrophysiological Signals in Humans}},
  booktitle = {Computational},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1007/s42113-020-00096-6},
}
Figure