Breakdown of the Stokes-Einstein relation in two, three, and four dimensions

S. Sengupta, Smarajit Karmakar, Chandan Dasgupta, Srikanth SastryThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2013 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have discovered that the "rules of the road" for molecules—the Stokes-Einstein relation—break down less severely as you move from two to four spatial dimensions. Surprisingly, while higher-dimensional liquids are more "fragile" (their viscosity skyrockets faster upon cooling), this doesn't perfectly align with standard measures of molecular "clumping" or dynamical heterogeneity, challenging long-held assumptions in glass physics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In a normal liquid, the Stokes-Einstein (SE) relation is a bedrock of statistical mechanics. It states that a particle's diffusion coefficient ($D$) is inversely proportional to the liquid's viscosity ($\eta$) divided by temperature ($T$). Essentially, if the liquid gets twice as thick, particles should move half as fast.

However, as liquids are cooled toward a "glassy" state, this relation fails spectacularly: particles diffuse much faster than the soaring viscosity would suggest. Physicists usually attribute this to Dynamical Heterogeneity (DH)—the idea that the liquid isn't uniform, but contains "fast" and "slow" regions. This paper investigates how this breakdown changes across different spatial dimensions (2D, 3D, and 4D) to see if our current theories about glass formation hold up when the geometry of space changes.

Methods

The authors employed NVT Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations to track the movement of particles in various model glass-formers.

  • Models: They used the classic Kob-Andersen (KA) binary mixture, a modified KA (MKA) model, and a purely repulsive soft-sphere model (R10).
  • Dimensions: Simulations were performed in 2, 3, and 4 spatial dimensions.
  • Measurements: They calculated diffusion coefficients ($D$), shear viscosity ($\eta$), and relaxation times ($\tau$). To quantify the "clumping" of dynamics (DH), they measured the dynamical susceptibility ($\chi_4$), the non-Gaussian parameter ($\alpha_2$), and the stretching exponent ($\beta_{KWW}$).

Datasets

The "datasets" in this study are the results of high-performance simulations of specific physical models:

  • KA Model: 80:20 mixture in 2D, 3D, and 4D.
  • MKA Model: 65:35 mixture in 2D.
  • R10 Model: 50:50 binary mixture of soft spheres in 2D and 3D.
  • System Sizes: Ranged from $N=1,000$ to $N=10,000$ particles depending on the dimensionality and model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dimensionality Dampens the Breakdown: The failure of the Stokes-Einstein relation is most extreme in 2D and becomes progressively weaker in 3D and 4D. In higher dimensions, the "effective exponent" $\xi$ in the fractional relation $D \propto (T/\eta)^\xi$ gets closer to the ideal value of 1.
  • The Adam-Gibbs Connection: In 3D and 4D, the breakdown can be explained by the Adam-Gibbs relation, which links dynamics to configurational entropy. The authors show that diffusion and viscosity have different "activation energies" in this framework, which naturally leads to the SE breakdown.
  • 2D is the "Odd One Out": Two-dimensional systems don't follow the standard Adam-Gibbs relation. Instead, they follow a "generalized" version, and their high-temperature behavior is qualitatively different from 3D and 4D systems.
  • The Fragility Paradox: Usually, physicists expect "fragile" liquids (those whose viscosity changes rapidly with temperature) to have the most heterogeneous dynamics and the strongest SE breakdown. This paper finds the opposite: fragility increases with dimensionality, even though the SE breakdown and some measures of heterogeneity actually weaken.

Key Results

  • Breakdown Exponents: For the KA model, the SE exponent $\xi$ was $\sim 0.82$ in 2D, $\sim 0.83$ in 3D, and $\sim 0.90$ in 4D. (A value of 1.0 represents no breakdown).
  • Onset Temperature: The SE breakdown begins at $T_{onset}$, the same temperature where the liquid's dynamics change from simple (Arrhenius) to complex (super-Arrhenius).
  • Thermodynamic Scaling: The increase in fragility with dimension was successfully rationalized through the properties of the "potential energy landscape"—specifically, the variance in the distribution of local energy minima (inherent structures) increases in higher dimensions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors note that while most measures of dynamical heterogeneity correlate well with the SE breakdown, the non-Gaussian parameter ($\alpha_2$) behaves inconsistently in 2D, suggesting it might be a poor indicator of heterogeneity in low dimensions.

Future work is needed to explore the specific length scales of these heterogeneous regions. The authors suggest that while the degree of heterogeneity might decrease in higher dimensions, the geometry of how these regions are connected (e.g., string-like vs. compact clusters) might be the key to reconciling the fragility paradox.

Summary updated

Abstract

The breakdown of the Stokes-Einstein (SE) relation between diffusivity and viscosity at low temperatures is considered to be one of the hallmarks of glassy dynamics in liquids. Theoretical analyses relate this breakdown with the presence of heterogeneous dynamics, and by extension, with the fragility of glass formers. We perform an investigation of the breakdown of the SE relation in 2, 3, and 4 dimensions in order to understand these interrelations. Results from simulations of model glass formers show that the degree of the breakdown of the SE relation decreases with increasing spatial dimensionality. The breakdown itself can be rationalized via the difference between the activation free energies for diffusivity and viscosity (or relaxation times) in the Adam-Gibbs relation in three and four dimensions. The behavior in two dimensions also can be understood in terms of a generalized Adam-Gibbs relation that is observed in previous work. We calculate various measures of heterogeneity of dynamics and find that the degree of the SE breakdown and measures of heterogeneity of dynamics are generally well correlated but with some exceptions. The two-dimensional systems we study show deviations from the pattern of behavior of the three- and four-dimensional systems both at high and low temperatures. The fragility of the studied liquids is found to increase with spatial dimensionality, contrary to the expectation based on the association of fragility with heterogeneous dynamics.
BibTeX
@article{sengupta2013breakdown,
  author = {S. Sengupta and Smarajit Karmakar and Chandan Dasgupta and Srikanth Sastry},
  title = {{Breakdown of the Stokes-Einstein relation in two, three, and four dimensions}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1063/1.4792356},
}
Figure