Breakdown of nonlinear elasticity in amorphous solids at finite temperatures

Itamar Procaccia, Corrado Rainone, Carmel A. B. Z. Shor, Murari SinghPhysical 2016 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: It is known that amorphous solids at zero temperature do not possess a nonlinear elasticity theory: besides the shear modulus, which exists, none of the higher order coefficients exist in the thermodynamic limit. Here we show that the same phenomenon persists up to temperatures comparable to that of the glass transition. The zero-temperature mechanism due to the prevalence of dangerous plastic modes of the Hessian matrix is replaced by anomalous stress fluctuations that lead to the divergence of the variances of the higher order elastic coefficients. The conclusion is that in amorphous solids elasticity can never be decoupled from plasticity: the nonlinear response is very substantially plastic.

Introduction: The Failure of Textbook Elasticity

In standard material science, the response of a solid to mechanical stress is described by a Taylor expansion of the energy. The first term, the linear shear modulus, defines the material's stiffness. Subsequent terms represent nonlinear elastic coefficients. For crystalline materials, these coefficients are "self-averaging" properties—they remain stable and well-defined regardless of the sample size.

However, amorphous solids like glass behave differently. Previous research at absolute zero ($T=0$) revealed that these materials are "mechanically marginal," possessing structural weaknesses (soft modes) that cause nonlinear coefficients to fluctuate wildly. This paper investigates whether thermal energy at finite temperatures can "smear out" these instabilities and restore standard nonlinear elasticity.

Methodology

The researchers employed Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of a 2D Kob-Andersen binary mixture, a standard model for glass-forming liquids. The system was cooled into a glass and subsequently reheated to temperatures ranging from $T = 0.05$ to $0.35$. To rigorously test for self-averaging, the team analyzed 1,000 independent samples for each system size, with $N$ ranging from 200 to 10,000 particles. They derived exact statistical mechanics expressions for the first three elastic coefficients ($B_1, B_2, B_3$) and measured how their variances scaled with $N$.

The Death of Self-Averaging

The core finding is that while the linear shear modulus ($B_1$) is well-behaved, higher-order coefficients are not. As the system size $N$ increases, the probability distribution of $B_1$ narrows, indicating it converges to a single value. In contrast, the distributions for $B_2$ and $B_3$ broaden significantly.

Distributions of the first three elastic coefficients ($B_1, B_2, B_3$) for different system sizes $N$. The narrowing of $P(B_1)$ and widening of $P(B_2), P(B_3)$ demonstrate the failure of self-averaging for higher-order terms.

This broadening implies that in the "thermodynamic limit" (infinitely large systems), these coefficients do not exist as stable material properties. Any attempt to define a "purely elastic" nonlinear regime is futile; the response is dominated by plastic rearrangements.

Quantitative Scaling and Thermal Persistence

The breakdown is quantified by the power-law scaling of the variance $(\delta B_n)^2$ against system size $N$. For $B_1$, the variance decreases as $N^{-0.68}$, confirming that linear elasticity holds. However, for $B_2$ and $B_3$, the variances grow with $N$ (scaling as $N^{0.78}$ and $N^{1.92}$, respectively).

Variance of elastic coefficients as a function of system size $N$ across different temperatures. The positive slopes for $B_2$ and $B_3$ confirm that nonlinear elasticity theory fails in the thermodynamic limit.

Crucially, these scaling exponents remain largely independent of temperature. While the mechanism at $T=0$ involves near-zero eigenvalues of the Hessian matrix, at $T>0$ it manifests as anomalous stress fluctuations. In both cases, the physical result is the same: elasticity and plasticity are fundamentally inseparable in amorphous solids.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study proves that the breakdown of nonlinear elasticity is a robust feature of glasses up to the glass transition temperature. While the fact of the breakdown is established, future work is needed to determine if the specific scaling exponents are universal across different glass models. Additionally, the potential link to the "Gardner Transition" remains an intriguing area for further investigation, particularly regarding whether this breakdown disappears above a specific Gardner temperature.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is known [H. G. E. Hentschel et al., Phys. Rev. E 83, 061101 (2011)PLEEE81539-375510.1103/PhysRevE.83.061101] that amorphous solids at zero temperature do not possess a nonlinear elasticity theory: besides the shear modulus, which exists, none of the higher order coefficients exist in the thermodynamic limit. Here we show that the same phenomenon persists up to temperatures comparable to that of the glass transition. The zero-temperature mechanism due to the prevalence of dangerous plastic modes of the Hessian matrix is replaced by anomalous stress fluctuations that lead to the divergence of the variances of the higher order elastic coefficients. The conclusion is that in amorphous solids elasticity can never be decoupled from plasticity: the nonlinear response is very substantially plastic.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{procaccia2016breakdown,
  author = {Itamar Procaccia and Corrado Rainone and Carmel A. B. Z. Shor and Murari Singh},
  title = {{Breakdown of nonlinear elasticity in amorphous solids at finite temperatures}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.93.063003},
}
Figure