BRCA1 Recruitment to Transcriptional Pause Sites Is Required for R-Loop-Driven DNA Damage Repair

Elodie Hatchi, Konstantina Skourti-Stathaki, Steffen Ventz, Luca Pinello, Angela Yen, Kinga Kamieniarz-Gdula, Stoil D. Dimitrov, Shailja Pathania, Kristine McKinney, Matthew L. Eaton, Manolis Kellis, Sarah J. Hill, Giovanni Parmigiani, Nicholas Proudfoot, David M. LivingstonMolecular 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that the tumor suppressor protein BRCA1, in partnership with senataxin (SETX), is recruited to specific "pause sites" during gene transcription. This complex acts to prevent DNA damage that arises from R-loops, a normal but potentially harmful RNA-DNA hybrid structure. The findings suggest a novel mechanism for maintaining genomic stability and shed light on how BRCA1 deficiency contributes to breast cancer.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Transcription, the process of copying DNA into RNA, is fundamental to life. However, it can also be a source of genomic instability. One such source is the formation of R-loops, which are hybrid structures of RNA and DNA that can arise during transcription. While R-loops are normal intermediates, their aberrant persistence can lead to DNA damage, mutations, and genomic instability, all of which are implicated in cancer. The precise mechanisms by which cells manage R-loop-associated DNA damage, particularly at specific genomic locations, were not well understood. This paper investigates the role of BRCA1, a well-known tumor suppressor involved in DNA repair, in dealing with R-loop-driven DNA damage at transcriptional pause sites.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Co-immunoprecipitation (Co-IP): To confirm the physical interaction between endogenous BRCA1 and SETX in cell extracts.
  • In vitro interaction assays: Using recombinant protein fragments to map the specific domains responsible for BRCA1-SETX interaction.
  • Chromatin Immunoprecipitation (ChIP): To determine where BRCA1 and SETX bind to DNA within the genome, specifically at transcription termination regions. They also used ChIP to detect the presence of phosphorylated H2AX (γH2AX), a marker of DNA damage.
  • RNA:DNA Immunoprecipitation (DIP): To directly measure the abundance of R-loops in different cellular conditions.
  • siRNA-mediated depletion: To experimentally reduce the levels of BRCA1 or SETX and observe the downstream effects on R-loop formation and DNA damage.
  • RNaseH1 overexpression: RNaseH1 is an enzyme that degrades RNA in RNA:DNA hybrids, so its overexpression was used to reduce R-loop formation and assess its impact on BRCA1/SETX recruitment and DNA damage.
  • Ligation-mediated quantitative PCR (LM-qPCR): A specialized technique to detect and quantify single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) breaks.
  • Genome-wide meta-analysis: Combining data from multiple deep-sequencing datasets (ChIP-seq, RNA-seq, DRIP-seq) to identify genomic regions where BRCA1 binds and is associated with R-loops.
  • Mutation analysis of breast cancer genomes: Analyzing existing sequencing data from breast tumors to identify specific types of mutations (indels, single-base mutations) in genes known to be associated with BRCA1 binding at termination sites.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available datasets, including:

  • ENCODE BRCA1 ChIP-seq data: For genome-wide identification of BRCA1 binding sites.
  • ENCODE RNAPII CTD Ser2-P ChIP-seq data: To identify actively transcribing genes and paused RNA polymerase II.
  • DRIP-seq data: To map R-loop locations in the genome.
  • RNA-seq data: To assess gene expression levels.
  • Whole-genome sequencing data from breast cancer patients: To analyze somatic mutations in BRCA1-associated genes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BRCA1 and SETX form a functional complex at transcription pause sites: The study provides strong evidence for a direct, physiological interaction between BRCA1 and SETX, and crucially, that this complex is recruited to specific R-loop-associated transcription termination regions.
  • R-loops are a direct trigger for BRCA1/SETX recruitment: The recruitment of BRCA1 and SETX to these sites is dependent on the presence of R-loops, as demonstrated by experiments with RNaseH1.
  • BRCA1/SETX acts as a protective shield against R-loop damage: When this complex is disrupted, DNA damage (γH2AX accumulation and ssDNA breaks) specifically arises at these R-loop-rich pause sites.
  • BRCA1 binding at termination regions is linked to high gene expression: The meta-analysis revealed that BRCA1 preferentially binds to the termination regions of highly transcribed genes, suggesting a role in managing the increased R-loop burden in such loci.
  • BRCA1 deficiency in tumors correlates with specific mutations: The analysis of breast cancer genomes showed an enrichment of indel mutations near BRCA1 binding sites in termination regions of BRCA1-mutant tumors, providing a direct link between impaired BRCA1 function and genomic alterations in these specific loci.

Key Results

  • BRCA1 and SETX co-immunoprecipitate, indicating a physical interaction.
  • SETX binds to the BRCT motif of BRCA1.
  • BRCA1 and SETX are recruited to the transcription termination site of the human β-actin gene in a BRCA1-dependent manner.
  • Depletion of BRCA1 or SETX leads to increased R-loop abundance and accumulation of γH2AX at transcription termination sites.
  • BRCA1/SETX depletion results in ssDNA breaks at R-loop-associated pause sites.
  • RNaseH1 overexpression (reducing R-loops) suppresses BRCA1/SETX binding and DNA damage.
  • Genome-wide analysis shows BRCA1 binding enrichment at R-loop-rich termination regions of actively transcribed genes.
  • BRCA1-mutant breast tumors exhibit a significant enrichment of indel mutations in genes with BRCA1-bound termination regions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanism of R-loop recognition by BRCA1: The paper acknowledges that how BRCA1 specifically recognizes R-loop structures remains to be fully elucidated. They propose possibilities, such as direct recognition of the RNA:DNA hybrid or interaction with other protein complexes.
  • Distinguishing BRCA1 and BRCA2 roles: While the study highlights differences in mutational patterns between BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutant tumors at these termination sites, further research is needed to fully understand the distinct roles and contexts in which BRCA1 and BRCA2 operate regarding R-loops.
  • Broader genomic impact: While the study focuses on specific genes and termination regions, further investigation into the genome-wide implications of BRCA1/SETX function in R-loop management is warranted.
  • Therapeutic implications: Understanding this repair pathway could potentially lead to new therapeutic strategies for BRCA1-deficient cancers.

The study opens up new avenues for understanding how cells maintain genomic integrity in the face of transcription-associated challenges and highlights a critical, previously underappreciated role for BRCA1 in this process.

Summary updated

Abstract

The mechanisms contributing to transcription-associated genomic instability are both complex and incompletely understood. Although R-loops are normal transcriptional intermediates, they are also associated with genomic instability. Here, we show that BRCA1 is recruited to R-loops that form normally over a subset of transcription termination regions. There it mediates the recruitment of a specific, physiological binding partner, senataxin (SETX). Disruption of this complex led to R-loop-driven DNA damage at those loci as reflected by adjacent γ-H2AX accumulation and ssDNA breaks within the untranscribed strand of relevant R-loop structures. Genome-wide analysis revealed widespread BRCA1 binding enrichment at R-loop-rich termination regions (TRs) of actively transcribed genes. Strikingly, within some of these genes in BRCA1 null breast tumors, there are specific insertion/deletion mutations located close to R-loop-mediated BRCA1 binding sites within TRs. Thus, BRCA1/SETX complexes support a DNA repair mechanism that addresses R-loop-based DNA damage at transcriptional pause sites.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hatchi2015brca,
  author = {Elodie Hatchi and Konstantina Skourti-Stathaki and Steffen Ventz and Luca Pinello and Angela Yen and Kinga Kamieniarz-Gdula and Stoil D. Dimitrov and Shailja Pathania and Kristine McKinney and Matthew L. Eaton and Manolis Kellis and Sarah J. Hill and Giovanni Parmigiani and Nicholas Proudfoot and David M. Livingston},
  title = {{BRCA1 Recruitment to Transcriptional Pause Sites Is Required for R-Loop-Driven DNA Damage Repair}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1016/j.molcel.2015.01.011},
}
Figure