Brain-wide human oscillatory LFP activity during visual working memory

Balbir Singh, Zhengyang Wang, Leen M. Madiah, Sarah Elizabeth Gatti, Jenna N. Fulton, Graham W. Johnson, Rui Li, Benoît M. Dawant, Dario J. Englot, Sarah K. Bick, Shawniqua Williams Roberson, Christos ConstantinidisbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates brain-wide oscillatory activity during visual working memory using intracranial recordings in epilepsy patients. They found that while stimulus presentation broadly increases brain activity, specific frequency bands (high-gamma and beta) show distinct regional patterns that are characteristic of visual working memory maintenance across a widespread network.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The precise role and distribution of oscillatory brain activity during working memory have been a long-standing debate. While some research points to the prefrontal cortex as central for maintaining information, other studies suggest a more distributed network. This paper aims to clarify this by examining brain-wide local field potential (LFP) activity during visual working memory tasks in humans, looking for region-specific signatures of oscillatory processes.

Methods

The researchers recorded local field potentials (LFPs) from intracranial depth electrodes implanted in 12 adult epilepsy patients. These electrodes, originally placed to localize seizure foci, allowed for high-resolution neural recordings from various brain regions. Participants performed two types of visual working memory tasks: a spatial task and a shape-matching task, with varying delay intervals. LFP data were preprocessed and analyzed using time-frequency analysis to examine power spectra across different frequency bands (specifically beta and high-gamma). Statistical analyses, including ANOVAs, were used to compare power across brain regions and task conditions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected from 12 human participants undergoing intracranial monitoring for epilepsy.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Brain-wide Network Engagement: Working memory isn't confined to a single brain area; it involves a widespread network of cortical and subcortical regions.
  • Frequency-Specific Signatures: Different frequency bands (beta and high-gamma) play distinct roles and show unique regional patterns during working memory.
  • Occipital Cortex Specialization: The occipital (visual) cortex shows a particularly strong high-gamma response during stimulus presentation, suggesting its crucial role in initial visual processing for memory.
  • Beta Oscillations as Top-Down Markers: The suppression and regional timing of beta oscillations might reflect top-down control processes involved in working memory.

Key Results

  • Stimulus presentation in visual working memory tasks consistently produced a broadband increase in LFP power across most brain areas.
  • High-gamma power (100-150 Hz) was significantly elevated in the occipital cortex during stimulus presentation compared to other regions.
  • Beta frequency power (16-40 Hz) showed a decrease after stimulus presentation, with a region-specific time course that varied from occipital to parietal and prefrontal areas.
  • In the shape-matching task, high-gamma power during the delay period was not significantly different across regions, though the prefrontal cortex showed the highest power. However, beta power differed systematically across regions during this delay period, with the occipital region showing the greatest amplitude.
  • The 6-second delay version of the spatial task showed higher high-gamma power compared to the 3-second delay, and this elevated power was present even during the fixation period, suggesting task anticipation or preparation influences activity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Patient Population: The study was conducted on epilepsy patients, and their cognitive deficits, particularly in frontal lobe function, might lead to brain activity patterns that deviate from those of healthy individuals.
  • LFP vs. Spiking Activity: The study relied solely on LFP data. While informative, LFP power doesn't perfectly map onto spiking activity, and future work combining LFP with single-neuron recordings could provide a more detailed understanding.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future research combining methodologies, including neuron recordings and LFP analysis, will be crucial for a detailed understanding of the roles of different brain areas and neuronal activity patterns in working memory.

Summary updated

Abstract

Oscillatory activity is thought to be a marker of cognitive processes, although its role and distribution across the brain during working memory has been a matter of debate. To understand how oscillatory activity differentiates tasks and brain areas in humans, we recorded local field potentials (LFPs) in 12 adults as they performed visual-spatial and shape-matching memory tasks. Tasks were designed to engage working memory processes at a range of delay intervals between stimulus delivery and response initiation. LFPs were recorded using intracranial depth electrodes implanted to localize seizures for management of intractable epilepsy. Task-related LFP power analyses revealed an extensive network of cortical regions that were activated during the presentation of visual stimuli and during their maintenance in working memory, including occipital, parietal, temporal, insular, and prefrontal cortical areas, and subcortical structures including the amygdala and hippocampus. Across most brain areas, the appearance of a stimulus produced broadband power increase, while gamma power was evident during the delay interval of the working memory task. Notable differences between areas included that occipital cortex was characterized by elevated power in the high gamma (100-150 Hz) range during the 500 ms of visual stimulus presentation, which was less pronounced or absent in other areas. A decrease in power centered in beta frequency (16-40 Hz) was also observed after the stimulus presentation, whose magnitude differed across areas. These results reveal the interplay of oscillatory activity across a broad network, and region-specific signatures of oscillatory processes associated with visual working memory.
BibTeX
@misc{singh2023brain,
  author = {Balbir Singh and Zhengyang Wang and Leen M. Madiah and Sarah Elizabeth Gatti and Jenna N. Fulton and Graham W. Johnson and Rui Li and Benoît M. Dawant and Dario J. Englot and Sarah K. Bick and Shawniqua Williams Roberson and Christos Constantinidis},
  title = {{Brain-wide human oscillatory LFP activity during visual working memory}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.09.06.556554},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure