Brain-Inspired Planning for Better Generalization in Reinforcement Learning

Mingde "Harry" ZhaoarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces novel brain-inspired techniques to improve the generalization capabilities of Reinforcement Learning (RL) agents. By mimicking human planning strategies like "spatial abstraction" and "delusion mitigation," the authors develop frameworks that allow RL agents to adapt to new, unseen environments more effectively, a critical challenge in current RL research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reinforcement Learning (RL) agents excel in controlled environments but struggle to generalize their learned skills to real-world scenarios that differ from their training conditions. This "generalization gap" is a major hurdle for deploying RL in practical applications. The paper argues that this limitation stems from RL agents' reliance on "intuition-based" decision-making and their inability to perform robust, long-term planning, mirroring challenges faced by human cognition. Specifically, the paper addresses:

  • Poor generalization: RL agents fail to adapt to Out-Of-Distribution (OOD) scenarios.
  • Delusional planning: Agents blindly trust targets generated by their models, leading to flawed plans and unsafe behaviors.
  • Lack of abstract reasoning: Current RL agents often operate at an atomic level, struggling with long-horizon tasks.

Methods

The paper proposes three main contributions, building upon each other:

  1. Conscious Planning (Chap. 4): Introduces a "bottleneck mechanism" inspired by human conscious attention. This mechanism allows a decision-time planning agent to dynamically focus on the most relevant aspects of the environmental state, achieving "spatial abstraction" and improving OOD generalization. This is implemented using top-down semi-hard attention.
  2. Skipper Framework (Chap. 5): Builds on spatial abstraction to introduce temporal abstraction. Skipper automatically decomposes complex tasks into smaller, manageable sub-tasks by constructing "proxy problems" (simplified graph representations). This framework leverages learned spatial and temporal abstractions for more robust and generalizable planning.
  3. Rejecting Hallucinations (Chap. 6): Addresses the issue of "delusional planning" where agents trust infeasible targets generated by their models. Inspired by the human brain's belief evaluation system, the authors propose a "feasibility evaluator" that learns to reject hallucinated targets. This evaluator is designed to be minimally intrusive and compatible with various TAP agents.

Datasets

The paper utilizes custom-designed environments for evaluation:

  • RDS (Random Distribution Shift): A gridworld navigation task designed to test generalization, where lava traps and goal locations are randomized.
  • SSM (SwordShieldMonster): A more complex gridworld task involving item collection and a monster, designed to expose failure modes in target-assisted planning.

These environments are built upon the MiniGrid repository and are designed to generate specific task instances with varying difficulties and layouts to challenge generalization.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Brain-inspired AI for generalization: Mimicking human cognitive processes like conscious attention and delusion mitigation can significantly improve RL agent generalization.
  • Spatial abstraction as a bottleneck: Focusing on relevant environmental aspects, rather than processing all information, is crucial for efficient and generalizable planning.
  • Task decomposition via proxy problems: Breaking down complex tasks into smaller, manageable sub-problems (proxy problems) is a powerful strategy for hierarchical planning and generalization.
  • The "hallucination-delusion" perspective: Recognizing that generative models can produce infeasible targets, leading to "delusional" agent behavior, is key to developing more robust planning agents.
  • Feasibility evaluation as a firewall: An external evaluator can act as a "firewall" to reject hallucinated targets, preventing delusional planning without altering the core agent architecture.

Key Results

  • Improved OOD Generalization: The proposed "Conscious Planning" agent (CP) demonstrated significant improvements in OOD generalization compared to baselines like UP and model-free agents.
  • Skipper's Effectiveness: The Skipper framework showed a significant advantage in zero-shot generalization, outperforming state-of-the-art hierarchical planning methods.
  • Reduced Delusional Behaviors: The feasibility evaluator significantly reduced delusional behaviors in TAP agents, leading to improved performance and safety. For instance, in experiments, the evaluator reduced feasibility errors and hallucinated target selection.
  • Scalability: Skipper showed good generalization performance even with a large number of training tasks and was less affected by larger environments with more objects.
  • Robustness to Stochasticity: Skipper was shown to be compatible with stochastic environments.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Limited Scope of Experiments: Experiments were conducted in minimalist, carefully controlled environments. Extending to widely-used benchmark suites or real-world tasks is needed for broader validation.
  • Dynamics-Consistent OOD: The methods are primarily effective for OOD challenges that are dynamics-consistent. Handling distributional shifts with inconsistent or unknown local dynamics remains an open problem.
  • Decision-Time Planning Susceptibility: While argued to be better for generalization, decision-time planning can be more susceptible to model errors.
  • Skipper's Task-Awareness: Skipper's checkpoint generation is not inherently task-informed, and checkpoints are not always prioritized based on predictability or importance.
  • Continuous State Spaces & Partial Observability: The current implementation of Skipper is limited to discrete state and action spaces and fully observable environments.
  • Proxy Problem Theory Boundaries: The precise theoretical boundaries of proxy problems are not fully understood.
  • Dreamer Implementation: Preliminary Atari results with Dreamer showed negligible performance gains, possibly due to the significant training time required for stabilization and adaptation of the evaluator.

Future Work:

  • Extend to Diverse Environments: Test the proposed methods on more complex environments and TAP agents.
  • Handle Unknown Dynamics: Develop methods for distributional shifts with inconsistent or unknown local dynamics.
  • Improve Skipper: Incorporate task-awareness into checkpoint generation and explore planning with high-level transitions rather than just states.
  • Continuous State Spaces & Partial Observability: Extend Skipper to handle continuous state spaces and partial observability, potentially using recurrent mechanisms.
  • Theoretical Understanding: Explore the precise boundaries of proxy problem theory and find more powerful theoretical results.
  • Abstract Planning: Develop agents that reason in a space of abstract situations and events, discovered autonomously through trial-and-error, potentially guided by a generic credit-assignment mechanism.
  • Investigate Dreamer: Conduct extended experiments with Dreamer to better understand the evaluator's impact and explore its potential.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhao2025brain,
  author = {Mingde "Harry" Zhao},
  title = {{Brain-Inspired Planning for Better Generalization in Reinforcement Learning}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2511.06470},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.06470},
}
Figure