Brain dynamics reflecting an intra-network brain state is associated with increased posttraumatic stress symptoms in the early aftermath of trauma

Mohammad S.e. Sendi, Zening Fu, Nathaniel G. Harnett, Sanne J.h. van Rooij, Victor M. Vergara, Diego A. Pizzagalli, Nikolaos P. Daskalakis, Stacey L. House, Francesca L. Beaudoin, Xinming An, Thomas C. Neylan, Gari D. Clifford, Tanja Jovanović, Sarah D. Linnstaedt, Laura Germine, Kenneth A. Bollen, Scott L. Rauch, John P. Haran, Alan B. Storrow, Christopher Lewandowski, Paul I. Musey, Phyllis L. Hendry, Sophia Sheikh, Christopher W. Jones, Brittany E. Punches, Robert A. Swor, Nina Gentile, Vishnu P. Murty, Lauren A. Hudak, José L. Pascual, Mark J. Seamon, Erica Harris, Anna Marie Chang, Claire Pearson, David A. Peak, Roland C. Merchant, Robert M. Domeier, Niels K. Rathlev, Brian J. O’Neil, Paulina Sergot, León D. Sánchez, Steven E. Bruce, John F. Sheridan, Steven E. Harte, Ronald C. Kessler, Karestan C. Koenen, Samuel A. McLean, Jennifer S. Stevens, Vince D. Calhoun, Kerry J. ResslerResearch Square 2024 · DOI

Introduction

Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a debilitating condition that often takes months to diagnose. Identifying individuals at high risk during the "acute" phase—the first few weeks following a traumatic event—is critical for early intervention. However, reliable biological markers for this early stage have remained elusive. Traditional neuroimaging often relies on static Functional Network Connectivity (sFNC), which averages brain activity over several minutes. This study, conducted by researchers from Harvard Medical School, Emory University, and other institutions, shifts the focus to dynamic Functional Network Connectivity (dFNC). By capturing the "flickering" transitions between different brain states, the researchers aimed to identify neural signatures that predict long-term posttraumatic stress (PTS) symptoms.

Methodology

The study utilized data from the AURORA project, a longitudinal study of trauma survivors recruited from emergency departments across the United States. The sample included 275 individuals (181 female, 94 male) who had recently experienced traumas such as motor vehicle accidents or physical assaults.

Resting-state fMRI scans were conducted approximately two weeks post-trauma. The researchers applied a "sliding window" approach, calculating connectivity within small, shifting time windows (approx. 47 seconds) across a 9-minute scan. Using a hybrid Independent Component Analysis (ICA) template (the Neuromark framework), they identified 53 brain nodes across seven functional networks. K-means clustering was then used to identify three distinct "brain states." The primary metric was the Occupancy Rate (OCR)—the percentage of time a participant spent in each state.

Key Findings: Integration vs. Isolation

The analysis revealed two critical brain states associated with symptom progression:

  1. The Risk State (State 1): Characterized as an intra-network state, where brain networks are more siloed and disconnected from one another. A higher occupancy rate in this "isolated" state two weeks post-trauma was a significant predictor of increased symptom severity three months later ($r = 0.192, p_{corrected} = 0.021$).
  2. The Protective State (State 3): Characterized as an inter-network state, showing high integration between sensory networks (visual, auditory, and motor). Spending more time in this integrated state was associated with lower symptom severity both immediately ($r = -0.179, p_{corrected} = 0.021$) and at the three-month mark ($r = -0.166, p_{corrected} = 0.029$).

These results suggest that how the brain integrates basic sensory information in the immediate wake of trauma is a fundamental component of either recovery or the development of pathology.

The Role of Biological Sex

A major insight of this study is the influence of biological sex on these neural dynamics. The protective effect of the integrated state (State 3) was significantly more pronounced in females than in males ($r = -0.244, p_{corrected} = 0.014$ for females at 2 weeks). Given that women are two to three times more likely to develop PTSD than men, understanding these sex-specific neural signatures is crucial for developing tailored diagnostic and therapeutic approaches.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The findings highlight that dFNC features can forecast symptoms up to ten weeks into the future, outperforming many traditional static measures. This suggests that the brain's dynamic "flickering" patterns shortly after trauma serve as a potent early biomarker for PTSD risk.

While the study is limited by the lack of a non-traumatized control group and a relatively smaller male subgroup, it opens the door for future longitudinal research. Tracking how these brain states evolve over a full year could reveal whether the brain "locks" into certain maladaptive states as PTSD becomes chronic. Ultimately, these insights move us closer to a future where early neuroimaging can guide personalized interventions for trauma survivors.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study examines the association between brain dynamic functional network connectivity (dFNC) and current/future posttraumatic stress (PTS) symptom severity, and the impact of sex on this relationship. By analyzing 275 participants' dFNC data obtained ~2 weeks after trauma exposure, we noted that brain dynamics of an inter-network brain state link negatively with current (r=-0.179, <i>p</i> <sub><i>corrected</i></sub> = 0.021) and future (r=-0.166, <i>p</i> <sub><i>corrected</i></sub> = 0.029) PTS symptom severity. Also, dynamics of an intra-network brain state correlated with future symptom intensity (r = 0.192, <i>p</i> <sub><i>corrected</i></sub> = 0.021). We additionally observed that the association between the network dynamics of the inter-network brain state with symptom severity is more pronounced in females (r=-0.244, <i>p</i> <sub><i>corrected</i></sub> = 0.014). Our findings highlight a potential link between brain network dynamics in the aftermath of trauma with current and future PTSD outcomes, with a stronger protective effect of inter-network brain states against symptom severity in females, underscoring the importance of sex differences.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sendi2024brain,
  author = {Mohammad S.E. Sendi and Zening Fu and Nathaniel G. Harnett and Sanne J.H. van Rooij and Victor M. Vergara and Diego A. Pizzagalli and Nikolaos P. Daskalakis and Stacey L. House and Francesca L. Beaudoin and Xinming An and Thomas C. Neylan and Gari D. Clifford and Tanja Jovanović and Sarah D. Linnstaedt and Laura Germine and Kenneth A. Bollen and Scott L. Rauch and John P. Haran and Alan B. Storrow and Christopher Lewandowski and Paul I. Musey and Phyllis L. Hendry and Sophia Sheikh and Christopher W. Jones and Brittany E. Punches and Robert A. Swor and Nina Gentile and Vishnu P. Murty and Lauren A. Hudak and José L. Pascual and Mark J. Seamon and Erica Harris and Anna Marie Chang and Claire Pearson and David A. Peak and Roland C. Merchant and Robert M. Domeier and Niels K. Rathlev and Brian J. O’Neil and Paulina Sergot and León D. Sánchez and Steven E. Bruce and John F. Sheridan and Steven E. Harte and Ronald C. Kessler and Karestan C. Koenen and Samuel A. McLean and Jennifer S. Stevens and Vince D. Calhoun and Kerry J. Ressler},
  title = {{Brain dynamics reflecting an intra-network brain state is associated with increased posttraumatic stress symptoms in the early aftermath of trauma}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-4004473/v1},
}
Figure