BPS Algebras in 2D String Theory

Sarah Harrison, Natalie Paquette, Daniel Persson, Roberto VolpatoOpenReview 2023 · arXiv · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper explores a specific class of 2D string theories (heterotic and type II) arising from compactifications on factorized internal spaces. The authors demonstrate that the BPS (Bogomol'nyi–Prasad–Sommerfield) states in these theories form modules for Borcherds-Kac-Moody (BKM) algebras, and these algebras act as symmetries of string amplitudes. They also show that supersymmetric indices computed via both Hamiltonian and path integral methods correspond to BKM algebra denominator formulas, providing a concrete link between string theory states and these infinite-dimensional algebras.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of understanding the underlying algebraic structures governing BPS states in string theory, particularly in the context of compactifications to low dimensions. Specifically, it investigates string theories where the internal worldsheet conformal field theory (CFT) factorizes into two self-dual vertex operator algebras (VOAs). The authors aim to establish a direct connection between the BPS states in these compactified theories and Borcherds-Kac-Moody (BKM) algebras, which are known to be related to such states. They also seek to provide a spacetime interpretation for these BKM algebras and demonstrate their role as symmetries of string amplitudes. Furthermore, they aim to compute and interpret supersymmetric indices, showing how they relate to the denominator formulas of these BKM algebras, bridging the gap between quantum field theory calculations and algebraic structures.

Methods

The paper employs a combination of techniques from string theory and mathematics:

  • Chiral and Non-chiral String Theory Construction: They build physical states by constructing BRST cohomology for both chiral (left-moving or right-moving) and non-chiral (full) string theories. This involves defining GSO projections and working with various cohomology groups (relative, semirelative, absolute).
  • Borcherds-Kac-Moody (BKM) Algebra Construction: They leverage the standard construction of BKM algebras from vertex operator algebras (VOAs) and super-VOAs (SVOAs).
  • Supersymmetric Index Calculation: They compute supersymmetric indices using both the Hamiltonian formalism (based on the second-quantized Hilbert space) and path integral methods.
  • Path Integral and Theta Lifts: The path integral calculations are framed within the theory of automorphic forms, specifically using theta lifts to relate the computed indices to known denominator formulas of BKM algebras.
  • Analysis of Anomalies and Tadpoles: They perform consistency checks by analyzing gravitational anomalies and B-field tadpoles, which are crucial for ensuring the physical consistency of the compactified theories.

The novel aspects lie in the explicit demonstration of the BKM algebra acting as a symmetry on BPS states and amplitudes in these specific string compactifications, and the detailed computation of supersymmetric indices via path integrals, connecting them to automorphic forms and BKM denominators.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BPS States as BKM Modules: A central finding is that the BPS states in these factorized 2D string compactifications naturally form modules for BKM (super)algebras. This provides a concrete realization of the "algebra of BPS states."
  • BKM Algebras as Symmetries: The paper proves that the identified BKM algebras act as symmetries of genus zero BPS-saturated string amplitudes. This is a significant result, linking algebraic structures to the dynamics of string scattering.
  • Supersymmetric Indices as Denominators: The computed supersymmetric indices, obtained through both Hamiltonian and path integral methods, are shown to precisely reproduce the denominator formulas of the corresponding BKM algebras. This establishes a deep connection between quantum field theory observables and the structure of these infinite-dimensional algebras.
  • Path Integrals as Theta Lifts: The path integral calculations for the indices reveal their nature as automorphic forms, specifically obtained through theta lifts. This connects string theory calculations to advanced topics in number theory and representation theory.
  • Subtleties in Low-Dimensional Compactifications: The paper highlights various subtleties inherent in low-dimensional string compactifications, particularly concerning zero-momentum states, picture-changing operators, and the interpretation of physical states in these reduced dimensions.

Key Results

  • Demonstrated that BPS states in heterotic and type II string theory compactifications on $V_1 \otimes V_2$ (where $V_1, V_2$ are self-dual SVOAs) form modules for BKM (super)algebras.
  • Proved that these BKM algebras act as symmetries of genus zero BPS-saturated string amplitudes.
  • Computed supersymmetric indices using both Hamiltonian and path integral formalisms.
  • Showed that these indices correspond to the denominator formulas of the associated BKM algebras, often expressed as automorphic forms obtained via theta lifts.
  • Analyzed gravitational anomalies and B-field tadpoles for consistency.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Physical Interpretation of Amplitudes: The paper acknowledges that the physical interpretation of the amplitudes, particularly at zero momentum and in the context of spacetime filling strings, remains problematic. They suggest possibilities like topological string theories or background charges that offset couplings to massless fields.
  • Generalization to Higher Dimensions: The authors express interest in understanding if BKM algebras act as symmetries of special string solutions in higher dimensions, potentially through decompactification limits or by constructing algebras directly from higher-dimensional string theories.
  • D-brane States: Investigating D-brane states in these compactifications and their potential representation of BKM algebras is suggested as a future direction.
  • Geometric Interpretations: The connection of certain BKM denominator formulas to topological invariants like Gromov-Witten or Donaldson-Thomas invariants is highlighted as an area for further exploration.
  • CHL Models and Umbral Moonshine: The paper suggests exploring CHL models based on these compactifications and offering a physical explanation for the genus zero property of monstrous and Conway moonshine.
  • String Dualities and BKM Algebras: The authors believe that string dualities acting on these models could reveal nontrivial relations among different BKM algebras, and this is an area ripe for further investigation.
  • Twisted String Theories: Studying twisted versions of these models to obtain BPS states as physical states in a topological string theory with BKM algebra actions is proposed.

Summary updated

Abstract

We discuss a set of heterotic and type II string theory compactifications to 1+1 dimensions that are characterized by factorized internal worldsheet CFTs of the form V1⊗V2, where V1,V2 are self-dual (super) vertex operator algebras. In the cases with spacetime supersymmetry, we show that the BPS states form a module for a Borcherds-Kac-Moody (BKM) (super)algebra, and we prove that for each model the BKM (super)algebra is a symmetry of genus zero BPS string amplitudes. We compute the supersymmetric indices of these models using both Hamiltonian and path integral formalisms. The path integrals are manifestly automorphic forms closely related to the Borcherds-Weyl-Kac denominator. Along the way, we comment on various subtleties inherent to these low-dimensional string compactifications.
BibTeX
@misc{harrison2023bps,
  author = {Sarah Harrison and Natalie Paquette and Daniel Persson and Roberto Volpato},
  title = {{BPS Algebras in 2D String Theory}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2107.03507},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2107.03507},
  howpublished = {OpenReview},
}
Figure