Abstract
Reusing solutions from smaller subproblems can significantly accelerate reinforcement learning in complex environments, but it often introduces a suboptimality gap in the global policy. This paper introduces a novel mathematical bound based on boundary values that tightly quantifies this performance loss. Unlike traditional Bellman-error-based bounds, which are often too conservative for practical use, the proposed "Boundary Bound" provides a realistic estimate of policy quality, enabling better engineering decisions in problem decomposition.
Introduction
Solving large-scale Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) from scratch is often computationally prohibitive. A common strategy is to decompose the problem into smaller, manageable subproblems—such as learning to navigate a single room—and then combining these local policies into a global solution. However, a local policy that is optimal for a subproblem may not be optimal for the overall task. The critical challenge lies in predicting the maximum possible performance loss (suboptimality) without knowing the true global optimum. Existing metrics, such as the Bellman error bound, typically yield overly pessimistic results, rendering them ineffective for practical system design.
Methodology
The authors focus on Goal State MDPs, where rewards are only granted upon reaching a specific destination. They propose a new "Boundary Bound" derived from the values at the subproblem's exit points.
Key components of the method include:
- Subproblem Formalization: Defining subproblems based on a subset of states and their immediate reachable "boundary" states.
- Boundary Value Bound: Instead of looking at global Bellman error, the authors derive a bound based on the values at the subproblem's boundaries. They introduce $α$-equivalence, which measures how similar expected values are across different exit points.
- Stochasticity Measure ($ρ$): An adjustment for environmental randomness to ensure the bound's validity in non-deterministic settings.
Experimental Setup
The theory was evaluated using simulated grid-world benchmarks designed to provide clear ground-truth optimal values for comparison against theoretical predictions.
- Hallway Example: An agent must navigate through a series of rooms (shown above).
- Doorways Example: A variation featuring multiple exits to test the bound's sensitivity to different "exit" qualities.
Results and Discussion
The experimental results demonstrate that the proposed Boundary Bound is significantly tighter and more predictive than the standard Bellman error bound developed by Williams and Baird (1993).
As shown in the results table above, the standard Bellman error bound is often too blunt. For instance, in the Hallway (Left and Middle Rooms) scenario, it predicts a near-zero optimality (0.01), while the actual performance is 0.66. In contrast, the authors' Boundary Bound provides a much tighter estimate of 0.65.
This predictive power helps identify better subproblems. In the doorways task, the bound reveals that including specific middle doors in the subproblem goal set significantly improves the guaranteed global performance. The "Boundary" is key: if all exits from a subproblem lead to states with roughly equal future value, then any optimal path to that boundary is likely to be globally near-optimal.
Conclusion
The Boundary Bound provides a practical tool for quantifying the trade-offs in hierarchical reinforcement learning. While currently limited to Goal State MDPs and single subproblem reuse, it represents a significant step toward more efficient and predictable problem decomposition. Future work will explore extending these bounds to MDPs with dense rewards and multiple overlapping subproblems.
Summary updated