Bounding the Family-Wise Error Rate in Local Causal Discovery Using Rademacher Averages (Extended Abstract)

Dario Simionato, Fabio VandinIJCAI 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces RAveL, a novel suite of algorithms for local causal discovery that provides rigorous guarantees on the Family-Wise Error Rate (FWER), meaning it minimizes the chance of falsely identifying causal relationships. By leveraging Rademacher averages, RAveL overcomes limitations of existing methods that rely on unrealistic assumptions about the accuracy of statistical tests.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Discovering causal relationships from observational data is a crucial but challenging task in many scientific fields, from biology to medicine. While identifying all causal links in a system (global causal discovery) is often computationally prohibitive, focusing on the causal relationships involving a specific "target" variable (local causal discovery) is a more tractable problem. This local discovery aims to identify two sets of variables: the "parent-children" set (direct causes and consequences) and the "Markov boundary" (a minimal set of variables that makes the target predictable).

A major hurdle in causal discovery is the need to validate candidate relationships with experiments, which can be costly. To reduce wasted experimental effort, it's essential to minimize "false positives" – relationships that appear causal but aren't. A common way to control false positives is by bounding the Family-Wise Error Rate (FWER), the probability of making at least one false discovery. However, existing local causal discovery algorithms either lack FWER guarantees or rely on strong, untestable assumptions (like perfect independence tests). This paper addresses this gap by developing algorithms that provide provable FWER control without these restrictive assumptions.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper lies in the introduction of RAveL (Rademacher Averages for Local structure discovery), a suite of algorithms that leverage Rademacher averages to bound the FWER. Rademacher averages are a concept from statistical learning theory that allows for data-dependent confidence intervals. Instead of relying on conservative, distribution-free bounds (like Bonferroni correction), RAveL uses Rademacher averages to compute tighter, data-driven confidence intervals for independence tests.

The paper presents two main algorithms:

  • RAveL-PC: For discovering the parent-children set of a target variable. It utilizes an independence test function that corrects for multiple hypotheses testing.
  • RAveL-MB: For discovering the Markov boundary. This algorithm first uses RAveL-PC to identify a subset of potential candidates and then applies further tests, including a novel formulation for testing the "spouse condition," to refine the Markov boundary.

Crucially, RAveL algorithms are designed to control the FWER without requiring infinite statistical power from the independence tests, a significant improvement over prior methods.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its algorithms using:

  • Synthetic data: Generated from a Bayesian network with 30 variables. The authors tested performance across various sample sizes and multiple datasets to estimate the FWER.
  • Real-world data: The Boston housing dataset was used to identify variables related to housing prices.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the focus was on evaluating RAveL against existing state-of-the-art methods on established datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rademacher Averages for FWER Control: The paper demonstrates that Rademacher averages are a powerful tool for achieving provable FWER guarantees in local causal discovery, offering a more data-adaptive approach than traditional multiple testing corrections.
  • Overcoming Unrealistic Assumptions: RAveL successfully bypasses the need for assumptions like perfect independence tests or infinite statistical power, which are often required by existing algorithms but are impractical in real-world scenarios.
  • Guaranteed FWER for Local Discovery: This work provides the first algorithms for local causal discovery (both parent-children and Markov boundary) with provable guarantees on the FWER, a critical step towards more reliable causal inference from observational data.
  • Limitations of Existing Methods: The authors highlight that standard algorithms, even when augmented with Bonferroni correction, may not provide reliable FWER control due to their inherent assumptions and the high dimensionality of causal discovery problems.

Key Results

  • FWER Control: Experiments on synthetic data show that RAveL-PC and RAveL-MB consistently control the FWER below the desired threshold (δ = 0.05) across various sample sizes.
  • Comparison with State-of-the-Art: While some existing methods (like GetPC with Bonferroni correction) also showed good performance in specific synthetic tests, the paper argues that they lack the theoretical guarantees of RAveL. Notably, PCMB with Bonferroni correction failed to bound the FWER in some scenarios where RAveL succeeded.
  • Real-World Application: On the Boston housing dataset, RAveL identified two variables (suburb income and number of rooms) that are causally related to housing prices, aligning with prior knowledge.
  • False Negative Reduction: The paper notes that while RAveL might have a higher percentage of false negatives compared to some uncorrected methods at smaller sample sizes, this can be mitigated with a simple modification to the test statistic, achieving good performance with as few as 100 samples.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While RAveL provides theoretical guarantees, the paper acknowledges that the computational cost of Rademacher averages can be significant, especially for very large datasets or high-dimensional problems.
  • Data Requirements: Although RAveL is more data-efficient than some methods, achieving low FWER and minimizing false negatives still depends on sufficient sample sizes. The paper suggests that further optimizations to the test statistic can reduce these requirements.
  • Future Work: The authors imply that further research could focus on optimizing the computational efficiency of Rademacher averages in this context and exploring their application to other areas of causal inference. The full version of the paper is mentioned as containing proofs and further details on test statistic modifications.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{simionato2023bounding,
  author = {Dario Simionato and Fabio Vandin},
  title = {{Bounding the Family-Wise Error Rate in Local Causal Discovery Using Rademacher Averages (Extended Abstract)}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2023/726},
}
Figure