Bounding aerosol radiative forcing of climate change

Nicolas Bellouin, Johannes Quaas, Edward Gryspeerdt, Stefan Kinne, Philip Stier, Duncan Watson‐Parris, Oliviér Boucher, K. S. Carslaw, Matt Christensen, Anne‐Laure Daniau, Jean‐Louis Dufresne, Graham Feingold, Stephanie Fiedler, Piers Forster, Andrew Gettelman, Jim Haywood, Florent Malavelle, Ulrike Lohmann, Thorsten Mauritsen, Daniel T. McCoy, Gunnar Myhre, J. Muelmenstaedt, David Neubauer, Anna Possner, Maria Rugenstein, Yousuke Sato, Michael Schulz, Stephen E. Schwartz, Odran Sourdeval, Trude Storelvmo, Velle Toll, D. Winker, Björn Stevens2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This review synthesizes multiple lines of evidence to provide a new, constrained range for the global aerosol radiative forcing of climate change. It finds that aerosols have likely cooled the planet by -1.6 to -0.6 W m⁻² (68% confidence interval) during the industrial era, a range that is more negative than previous assessments, highlighting the significant, yet uncertain, role of aerosols in Earth's energy balance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Earth's energy budget is influenced by various factors, including greenhouse gases and aerosols. While greenhouse gases are known to cause warming, aerosols – tiny solid and liquid particles in the atmosphere – have a more complex and uncertain effect. They can scatter or absorb solar radiation (aerosol-radiation interactions) and influence cloud properties (aerosol-cloud interactions), leading to either warming or cooling. Quantifying the net effect of aerosols, known as aerosol effective radiative forcing (ERF), is crucial for understanding past climate change and projecting future climate. However, the diverse nature of aerosols and their interactions with radiation and clouds makes this a significant challenge, leading to large uncertainties in climate models and projections. This paper aims to reduce these uncertainties by consolidating evidence from various sources to establish a more robust range for aerosol ERF.

Methods

The authors employ a comprehensive approach by combining multiple lines of evidence to constrain aerosol ERF. This includes:

  • Conceptual Model: A framework is presented that breaks down aerosol ERF into components related to aerosol-radiation interactions (ari) and aerosol-cloud interactions (aci), considering both instantaneous radiative forcing and rapid adjustments.
  • Process-Oriented Studies: Insights from microphysical and cloud-resolving models, as well as in-situ and satellite observations, are used to estimate the sensitivities of radiation and clouds to aerosol changes.
  • Large-Scale Modeling: Global climate models (GCMs) are used to estimate changes in aerosol and cloud properties from pre-industrial (1850) to present-day conditions.
  • Energy Balance Inferences: Observed changes in global temperature and radiative fluxes are used to infer constraints on aerosol ERF.
  • Monte Carlo Approach: A statistical method is used to combine uncertainty ranges from different sources to derive a final, probabilistic range for aerosol ERF.

The review specifically focuses on the effective radiative forcing (ERF), which includes rapid adjustments, as it is a better predictor of climate response than instantaneous radiative forcing. The reference period for pre-industrial conditions is set to 1850.

Datasets

The paper relies on a synthesis of existing observational data and model outputs rather than introducing new datasets. Key data sources and model intercomparison projects mentioned include:

  • Satellite Remote Sensing: Data from instruments like MODIS (Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer) and CALIOP (Cloud-Aerosol Lidar with Orthogonal Polarization) are used to retrieve aerosol optical depth (AOD) and cloud properties. CERES (Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System) data is used for cloud albedo.
  • Ground-Based Networks: AERONET (AErosol RObotic NETwork) Sun photometer data is utilized for AOD measurements.
  • Global Climate Models (GCMs): Outputs from models participating in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP) and the Aerosol Comparisons between Observations and Models (AeroCom) initiative are extensively used.
  • Perturbed Parameter Ensembles (PPEs): Simulations from models with perturbed parameters are used to explore uncertainties.
  • Reanalysis Data: Datasets like MACC (Monitoring Atmospheric Composition and Climate) are referenced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Aerosols are a Significant Cooling Agent: The paper strongly suggests that aerosols have exerted a substantial cooling influence on the Earth's climate, likely offsetting a significant portion of greenhouse gas warming.
  • Uncertainty Remains, but is Narrowing: While significant uncertainties persist, particularly regarding aerosol-cloud interactions and ice clouds, the study demonstrates how combining multiple lines of evidence can lead to more robust constraints.
  • Effective Radiative Forcing is Key: The focus on ERF, which includes rapid adjustments, is highlighted as a more accurate measure of aerosol impact on climate than instantaneous radiative forcing.
  • Aerosol-Cloud Interactions are Highly Complex: The paper emphasizes the intricate and often uncertain ways aerosols influence cloud properties, especially in mixed-phase and ice clouds.
  • Preindustrial Baseline Matters: The choice of the preindustrial baseline year (1850) influences the estimated forcing, and the paper justifies this choice based on data availability and consistency with climate simulations.

Key Results

  • Total Aerosol ERF Range: The study estimates a 68% confidence interval for the total aerosol effective radiative forcing of -1.6 to -0.6 W m⁻² for the industrial era (1850 to present-day). A 90% likelihood interval is -2.0 to -0.4 W m⁻².
  • Aerosol-Radiation Interactions (ari): The estimated RFari is -0.37 to -0.12 W m⁻², with rapid adjustments contributing -0.06 to -0.25 W m⁻².
  • Aerosol-Cloud Interactions (aci): The estimated RFaci is -1.10 to -0.33 W m⁻², with rapid adjustments contributing -1.73 to -0.27 W m⁻².
  • Industrial-Era Changes: Human activities are estimated to have increased aerosol optical depth (AOD) by 14% to 29% and cloud droplet number concentration by 5% to 17% from 1850 to the present day.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Ice Cloud Uncertainty: The interactions of aerosols with ice clouds remain poorly constrained and are not included in the final ERF estimate due to a lack of robust evidence.
  • Model Resolution and Parameterizations: Large-scale models struggle to fully capture the small-scale processes and covariabilities that influence aerosol-cloud interactions, leading to uncertainties in parameterizations.
  • Observational Constraints: While observational data is crucial, challenges remain in disentangling aerosol effects from meteorological influences and in scaling local observations to global averages.
  • Equifinality: Complex models can produce similar results from different combinations of uncertain parameters, making it difficult to isolate the true drivers of climate response.

Future work should focus on:

  • Improving the understanding and quantification of aerosol interactions with ice clouds.
  • Developing better methods to integrate small-scale process understanding into global models.
  • Enhancing observational strategies to better constrain aerosol-cloud interactions and their radiative impacts.
  • Utilizing "perfect model" comparisons and advanced statistical methods to strengthen inferences from climate observations.
  • Leveraging global large-eddy simulations to improve the quantification of aerosol-cloud interactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Earth and Space Science Open Archive PosterOpen AccessYou are viewing the latest version by default [v1]Bounding aerosol radiative forcing of climate changeAuthors Nicolas Bellouin iD Johannes Quaas iD Ed Gryspeerdt Stefan Kinne Philip Stier iD Duncan Watson-Parris iD Olivier Boucher Ken Carslaw Matt Christensen iD Anne-Laure Daniau iD Jean-Louis Dufresne Graham Feingold iD Stephanie Fiedler Piers Forster Andrew Gettelman iD Jim Haywood Florent Malavelle Ulrike Lohmann Thorsten Mauritsen iD Daniel McCoy Gunnar Myhre Johannes Muelmenstaedt David Neubauer iD Anna Possner Maria Rugenstein Yousuke Sato Michael Schulz iD Stephen Schwartz iD Odran Sourdeval Trude Storelvmo Velle Toll iD David Winker iD Bjorn Stevens iDSee all authors Nicolas BellouiniDCorresponding AuthorDepartment of Meteorology, University of ReadingiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-2109-9559view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressJohannes QuaasiDUniversity of LeipzigiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-7057-194Xview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressEd GryspeerdtImperial College Londonview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressStefan KinneMax Planck Institute for Meteorology, Hamburgview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressPhilip StieriDUniversity of OxfordiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-1191-0128view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressDuncan Watson-ParrisiDUniversity of OxfordiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-5312-4950view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressOlivier BoucherLaboratoire de Meteorologie Dynamiqueview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressKen CarslawUniversity of Leedsview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressMatt ChristenseniDUniversity of OxfordiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-4273-6644view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressAnne-Laure DaniauiDEPOC UMR5805, CNRS, University of BordeauxiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-1621-3911view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressJean-Louis DufresneLaboratoire de Meteorologie Dynamiqueview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressGraham FeingoldiDNOAA CSDiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-0774-2926view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressStephanie FiedlerMax Planck Institute for Meteorology, Hamburgview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressPiers ForsterUniversity of Leedsview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressAndrew GettelmaniDNCARiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-8284-2599view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressJim HaywoodUniversity of Exeter, UK Met Officeview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressFlorent MalavelleUniversity of Exeterview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressUlrike LohmannETH Zurichview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressThorsten MauritseniDStockholm UniversityiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-1418-4077view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressDaniel McCoyUniversity of Leedsview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressGunnar MyhreCenter for International Climate and Environmental Research Osloview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressJohannes MuelmenstaedtUniversity of Leipzigview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressDavid NeubaueriDETH Swiss Federal Institute of Technology ZurichiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-9869-3946view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressAnna PossnerUniversity of Frankfurtview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressMaria RugensteinMax Planck Institute for Meteorology, Hamburgview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressYousuke SatoHokudai Universityview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressMichael SchulziDNorwegian Meteorological InstituteiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-4493-4158view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressStephen SchwartziDBrookhaven National LaboratoryiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-6288-310Xview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressOdran SourdevalUniversite de Lilleview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressTrude StorelvmoUniversity of Osloview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressVelle TolliDUniversity of TartuiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-8760-7803view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressDavid WinkeriDNASA Langley Research CenteriDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-3919-2244view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressBjorn StevensiDMax Planck Institute for Meteorology, HamburgiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-3795-0475view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email address
BibTeX
@misc{bellouin2019bounding,
  author = {Nicolas Bellouin and Johannes Quaas and Edward Gryspeerdt and Stefan Kinne and Philip Stier and Duncan Watson‐Parris and Oliviér Boucher and K. S. Carslaw and Matt Christensen and Anne‐Laure Daniau and Jean‐Louis Dufresne and Graham Feingold and Stephanie Fiedler and Piers Forster and Andrew Gettelman and Jim Haywood and Florent Malavelle and Ulrike Lohmann and Thorsten Mauritsen and Daniel T. McCoy and Gunnar Myhre and J. Muelmenstaedt and David Neubauer and Anna Possner and Maria Rugenstein and Yousuke Sato and Michael Schulz and Stephen E. Schwartz and Odran Sourdeval and Trude Storelvmo and Velle Toll and D. Winker and Björn Stevens},
  title = {{Bounding aerosol radiative forcing of climate change}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1002/essoar.10501326.1},
}
Figure