Boundary effects on entropy and two-site entanglement of the spin-1 valence-bond solid

Heng Fan, V. E. Korepin, Vwani Roychowdhury, Christopher Hadley, Sougato BosePhysical 2007 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper investigates the von Neumann entropy of a subsystem block within the spin-1 valence-bond solid (VBS) state under general open boundary conditions. We demonstrate that boundary effects on entanglement entropy decay exponentially with the distance from the boundary, a behavior that distinguishes non-critical (gapped) systems from critical ones. Furthermore, we show that as the subsystem size increases, its entropy saturates to the sum of the entropies of its two ends, confirming the 1D area law. Interestingly, while boundary conditions decrease the overall block entropy, they are found to enhance the local entanglement between individual neighboring spins.

Introduction

In quantum many-body physics, entanglement is a primary tool for characterizing phases of matter. While theoretical models often utilize periodic boundary conditions for simplicity, real-world systems and numerical methods like the Density Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG) must account for open boundaries. A critical question is the "reach" of these boundaries: how far into the bulk does the edge influence the quantum state?

In critical systems, such as the 1D XXZ model, boundary effects are long-ranged. This study focuses on the non-critical VBS state of the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki (AKLT) model to prove that in gapped systems, these influences are strictly short-ranged and decay fundamentally differently.

Methodology

The study employs an analytical framework to partition a 1D spin-1 chain into three distinct segments: a left boundary, a central block of $L$ spins (the subsystem of interest), and a right boundary.

The 1D spin chain is partitioned into LEFT, CENTRAL, and RIGHT segments to analyze the spatial reach of boundary effects.

To simplify the many-body problem, the authors use Schmidt decomposition to map the complex states of the boundary segments onto simpler bipartite states. This reduces the system to a more manageable model of $L+2$ sites. Entanglement is then quantified using the von Neumann entropy ($S$) for block-wide correlations, and Negativity ($\mathcal{N}$) or Realignment ($\mathcal{R}$) for local two-site correlations.

Key Insights and Results

Exponential Decay and the Area Law

The most significant finding is that the boundary's influence on the central block's entropy vanishes exponentially as the distance from the boundary increases. The convergence speed is governed by the factor $p = (-1/3)^L$. Unlike critical systems where entropy grows with block size, the VBS entropy saturates to a constant value: the sum of the entropies of the two boundaries. This provides a clear 1D demonstration of the "area law," where entanglement is concentrated at the boundaries of a subsystem.

The Monogamy of Entanglement

A counter-intuitive result emerged regarding local entanglement. While boundary operators decrease the total von Neumann entropy of a block, they actually increase the entanglement between two individual neighboring spins within that block. This is explained by the principle of entanglement monogamy: as a spin becomes less entangled with the distant boundaries, it has a greater capacity to be entangled with its immediate neighbor.

Table showing the enhancement of local entanglement (scaled values) as boundaries ($N_l, N_r$) are brought closer to the two-site subsystem.

As shown in the data above, when the boundaries are immediate neighbors ($N_l=N_r=1$), the entanglement measure is at its highest (approximately $1.459/9$). As the boundaries move toward infinity, the value settles to the exact bulk value of $1/9$.

Discussion and Future Work

The rapid exponential decay of boundary effects in gapped systems has significant implications for numerical physics. It suggests that methods like DMRG are exceptionally efficient for these models because the "influence" of the edge is so localized.

While this study is limited to 1D VBS/AKLT models, the principles relate to the broader area law in higher dimensions. Future research could extend these analytical bounds to optimize algorithms for gapped 2D systems, such as those using Projected Entangled Pair States (PEPS).

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the von Neumann entropy of a block of subsystem for the valence-bond solid (VBS) state with general open boundary conditions. We show that the effect of the boundary on the von Neumann entropy decays exponentially fast in the distance between the subsystem considered and the boundary sites. Further, we show that as the size of the subsystem increases, its von Neumann entropy exponentially approaches the summation of the von Neumann entropies of the two ends, the exponent being related to the size. In contrast to critical systems, where boundary effects to the von Neumann entropy decay slowly, the boundary effects in a VBS, a noncritical system, decay very quickly. We also study the entanglement between two spins. Curiously, while the boundary operators decrease the von Neumann entropy of $L$ spins, they increase the entanglement between two spins.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fan2007boundary,
  author = {Heng Fan and V. E. Korepin and Vwani Roychowdhury and Christopher Hadley and Sougato Bose},
  title = {{Boundary effects on entropy and two-site entanglement of the spin-1 valence-bond solid}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.76.014428},
}

Loading related content...

Figure