Bound preserving Lax-Wendroff flux reconstruction method for special relativistic hydrodynamics

Shankar Basak, Arpit Babbar, Harish Kumar, Praveen ChandrashekarJournal of Computational Physics 2024 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new numerical method, the Bound Preserving Lax-Wendroff Flux Reconstruction (LWFR) scheme, for simulating special relativistic hydrodynamics (RHD). This method is designed to accurately and robustly handle the complex, non-linear behavior of fluids at relativistic speeds, particularly near discontinuities, while ensuring the physical admissibility of the solutions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Simulating relativistic hydrodynamics (RHD) is crucial for understanding phenomena in high-energy physics and astrophysics, such as black holes and gamma-ray bursts. The RHD equations are a system of hyperbolic conservation laws that are notoriously difficult to solve numerically due to their strong non-linearity, especially when fluid velocities approach the speed of light. A key challenge is maintaining the physical admissibility of the solution, meaning that quantities like density and pressure must remain positive, and velocities must be less than the speed of light. Existing numerical methods often struggle with these constraints, leading to unphysical solutions and potential instability, particularly near shocks or other discontinuities. This paper aims to develop a high-order, accurate, and stable numerical method that specifically addresses these admissibility issues in RHD simulations.

Methods

The core of this work is a novel Jacobian-free Lax-Wendroff Flux Reconstruction (LWFR) scheme. LWFR methods are known for their high-order accuracy in both space and time with a single internal time step, making them computationally efficient. To tackle the oscillations near discontinuities, the authors blend this high-order LWFR scheme with a first-order finite volume scheme. This blending is adaptively controlled by a discontinuity indicator model specifically designed for RHD equations. This indicator helps to determine where to apply the more robust, lower-order scheme to prevent unphysical oscillations without sacrificing accuracy in smooth regions.

A significant contribution is the development of a new discontinuity indicator based on Legendre orthogonal basis functions, which is shown to be more effective for RHD than previous models. Furthermore, the paper addresses the admissibility preservation challenge. They achieve this by first ensuring the admissibility of the solution's element means and then employing a scaling limiter. To overcome the difficulty of expressing primitive variables in terms of conservative variables for RHD, they utilize an equivalent, convex admissibility region that is directly computable from conservative variables.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on numerical methods and their validation through various test cases.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Admissibility is Paramount: The paper strongly emphasizes that for RHD simulations to be physically meaningful, solutions must remain within an "admissible region" (positive density/pressure, velocity < c). Failure to do so leads to ill-posed problems.
  • LWFR for RHD: The Lax-Wendroff Flux Reconstruction (LWFR) method, known for its efficiency and high-order accuracy, is adapted for the complex RHD equations.
  • Blending for Robustness: A clever blending strategy with a first-order finite volume scheme is employed to control oscillations near discontinuities, a common problem in high-order methods.
  • Novel Discontinuity Indicator: A new discontinuity indicator model, tailored for RHD and using Legendre polynomials, is introduced and shown to be more effective than existing methods in capturing local irregularities and controlling oscillations.
  • Efficient Admissibility Check: By reformulating the admissibility constraints in terms of conservative variables and leveraging their concavity, the computational cost of ensuring physical admissibility is significantly reduced.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed Bound Preserving LWFR scheme through extensive numerical simulations in one and two dimensions.

  • Accuracy: The scheme achieves high-order accuracy, with convergence rates consistent with the polynomial degree used (e.g., O(∆x)N+1).
  • Robustness: The method successfully captures various wave phenomena, including shocks, rarefactions, and contact discontinuities, across a wide range of test cases, including those with strong discontinuities and high Lorentz factors.
  • Oscillation Control: The blending strategy with the new discontinuity indicator effectively controls spurious oscillations, particularly near discontinuities, outperforming previous methods like the TVB limiter.
  • Admissibility Preservation: The scheme consistently maintains the physical admissibility of the solution throughout the simulations.
  • Efficiency: The Jacobian-free nature of the LWFR scheme and the efficient admissibility checks contribute to its computational performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Admissibility Constraints: While the paper successfully reformulates admissibility constraints to be concave functions of conservative variables, the authors note that this is not naturally the case for RHD, requiring this specific transformation.
  • Parameter Tuning: The discontinuity indicator model involves parameters (Eu, El, amax) that are determined through numerical experiments, suggesting potential for further optimization or adaptive selection of these parameters.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that the developed discontinuity indicator model could be useful for other conservation laws and that the admissibility preserving limiter is crucial for problems where solutions are close to the boundaries of the admissible region. Further exploration of adaptive mesh refinement with this scheme could also be a promising direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Lax-Wendroff flux reconstruction (LWFR) schemes have high order of accuracy in both space and time despite having a single internal time step. Here, we design a Jacobian-free LWFR type scheme to solve the special relativistic hydrodynamics equations on Cartesian grids. We then blend the scheme with a first-order finite volume scheme to control the oscillations near discontinuities. We also use a scaling limiter to preserve the physical admissibility of the solution after ensuring the scheme is admissible in means. A particular focus is given to designing a discontinuity indicator model to detect the local non-smoothness in the solution of the highly non-linear relativistic hydrodynamics equations. Finally, we present numerical results for a wide range of test cases to show the robustness and efficiency of the proposed scheme.
BibTeX
@article{basak2024bound,
  author = {Shankar Basak and Arpit Babbar and Harish Kumar and Praveen Chandrashekar},
  title = {{Bound preserving Lax-Wendroff flux reconstruction method for special relativistic hydrodynamics}},
  journal = {Journal of Computational Physics},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure