Both prey and predator features predict the individual predation risk and survival of schooling prey

Jolle W. Jolles, Matthew M. G. Sosna, Geoffrey P. F. Mazué, Colin R. Twomey, Joseph B. Bak-Coleman, Daniel I. Rubenstein, Iain D. CouzineLife 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses high-resolution tracking to reveal that both predator behavior and prey characteristics dictate an individual's risk of being targeted and surviving an attack in schooling fish. Surprisingly, central prey are more vulnerable, and successful evasion hinges on rapid acceleration and distance from the predator's head.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Predation is a major evolutionary force shaping social behavior, and while it's understood that not all individuals in a group face equal risk, precisely quantifying this differential risk has been challenging. This is due to the speed and complexity of predator attacks and the dynamic responses of prey. Previous research often treated predators as abstract threats, overlooking their specific attack strategies and how these interact with prey behavior. This paper aims to bridge this gap by simultaneously analyzing the fine-grained spatial and kinematic details of both predator (Northern pike) and prey (golden shiners) during attacks on schooling fish.

Methods

The researchers employed high-resolution video tracking (120 fps) to capture detailed movement data of individual pike and golden shiners during simulated predation events. They developed custom software to track fish positions, orientations, and movement kinematics. To analyze the complex interplay of factors influencing predation risk, they utilized a multi-model inference approach. This involved fitting numerous statistical models with various combinations of prey and predator features to predict: 1) the likelihood of an individual being targeted, and 2) the likelihood of a targeted individual surviving the attack. This approach allowed them to assess the relative importance of different features.

Datasets

The study used a dataset of 125 recorded attacks by Northern pike on schooling golden shiners. This dataset was generated through controlled laboratory experiments. The data includes detailed, synchronized, individual-level tracking of predator and prey movements throughout each attack.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Predator Strategy Matters: Pike don't just attack the nearest prey; they employ a stealthy approach, often entering the school before striking, making prey in the "strike zone" most vulnerable.
  • Central Prey are Not Always Safest: Contrary to some "selfish herd" predictions, prey in the center of the school were more likely to be targeted, especially if they were less aligned with their neighbors.
  • Evasion is Dynamic: Surviving an attack isn't just about being in the "right" place; it critically depends on a rapid, high-acceleration response just before the strike and maintaining distance from the predator's head.
  • Interplay is Crucial: Understanding predation risk requires considering both the predator's attack strategy and the prey's spatial and kinematic characteristics, not just one in isolation.

Key Results

  • Targeting:
    • Pike tended to approach groups head-on.
  • Targeted individuals were more likely to be in central positions within the school (mean position 0.45±0.02 on a front-back scale).
  • Prey with less alignment to neighbors and a larger "limited domain of danger" (less surrounded by conspecifics) were more likely to be targeted.
  • From the predator's perspective, prey within the pike's "strike zone" (roughly 8 cm wide, 15 cm long) were most likely to be targeted, with distance and angle to the pike being key predictors.
  • Survival:
    • 70% of attacks were successful (prey eaten).
  • Targeted individuals were more likely to survive if they exhibited higher maximum acceleration in the moments before the attack and were further away from the pike's head.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their laboratory arena, while large for behavioral studies, is still a simplification of natural environments. They suggest future work should extend to deeper water and more complex environments with vegetation to better understand the role of the third dimension and hiding places. They also note that while their study focused on pike, different predator types might employ different attack strategies, and the observed effects might vary in much larger prey groups where spatial constraints could limit predator access to the group center. Further experimental manipulations and directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) are recommended to disentangle causal relationships more definitively.

Summary updated

Abstract

Predation is one of the main evolutionary drivers of social grouping. While it is well appreciated that predation risk is likely not shared equally among individuals within groups, its detailed quantification has remained difficult due to the speed of attacks and the highly dynamic nature of collective prey response. Here, using high-resolution tracking of solitary predators (Northern pike) hunting schooling fish (golden shiners), we not only provide insights into predator decision-making, but show which key spatial and kinematic features of predator and prey predict the risk of individuals to be targeted and to survive attacks. We found that pike tended to stealthily approach the largest groups, and were often already inside the school when launching their attack, making prey in this frontal 'strike zone' the most vulnerable to be targeted. From the prey's perspective, those fish in central locations, but relatively far from, and less aligned with, neighbours, were most likely to be targeted. While the majority of attacks were successful (70%), targeted individuals that did manage to avoid being captured exhibited a higher maximum acceleration response just before the attack and were further away from the pike's head. Our results highlight the crucial interplay between predators' attack strategy and response of prey underlying the predation risk within mobile animal groups.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jolles2022both,
  author = {Jolle W. Jolles and Matthew M. G. Sosna and Geoffrey P. F. Mazué and Colin R. Twomey and Joseph B. Bak-Coleman and Daniel I. Rubenstein and Iain D. Couzin},
  title = {{Both prey and predator features predict the individual predation risk and survival of schooling prey}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.76344},
}

Loading related content...

Figure