BoPCOVIPIP: Capturing the Dynamics of Marketing Mix Among Bottom of Pyramid Consumers during COVID-19

Debadrita Panda, Sabyasachi Mukhopadhyay, Rajarshi Saha, Prasanta K. PanigrahiInternational Journal of Intelligent Systems and Applications 2022 · DOI

Abstract

The behaviour of consumers mostly follows the guidelines derived from marketing theories and models. But under some unavoidable circumstances, the consumers show a complete deviation compared to their existing consumption pattern, purchase behaviour, decision-making and so on. Under similar circumstances, this study aims to capture both urban and rural Bottom of the Pyramid (BoP) consumers’ perceptions of various marketing mixes during the COVID-19 pandemic situation. With a sample size of 378 and 282, the perception towards different marketing mixes has been captured for Pre-COVID and During-COVID periods, respectively. The adopted quantitative analysis indicates a difference in perception towards marketing mix During COVID compared to Pre-COVID. Moreover, the selection of West Bengal, India, as an area of research fulfills the BoP literature’s existing prominent research gap. This study also comes with the potential to assist marketers and the Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) industry in framing strategies to target BoP consumers.

Introduction

The "Bottom of the Pyramid" (BoP) refers to the approximately 4 billion people globally living on less than $1,500 per year. For marketers in the Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) sector, this segment is notoriously difficult to navigate due to high heterogeneity, limited formal education, and "media dark" environments.

Standard marketing theories, such as the 4Ps (Product, Price, Place, Promotion), often assume stable consumer behavior. However, the COVID-19 pandemic created "unavoidable circumstances" that forced a complete deviation from existing consumption patterns. This paper addresses a critical research gap: how do these vulnerable consumers re-prioritize their needs when a global health crisis intersects with extreme financial constraints? Specifically, the study examines the FMCG sector in West Bengal, India, a region previously underrepresented in BoP literature.

Methodology

The researchers employed a quantitative approach, collecting primary data via structured questionnaires from two districts in West Bengal: Paschim Medinipur and North 24 Parganas. The study utilized a Pre-COVID sample of 378 respondents and a During-COVID sample of 282 respondents.

Research Methodology Flowchart

To analyze the data, the researchers used Association Rule Mining (ARM), comparing the classical Apriori algorithm with the more efficient FP-Growth (Frequent Pattern Growth). FP-Growth was selected for its computational superiority, as it uses a tree structure to avoid the expensive candidate generation steps required by Apriori. Statistical significance was validated using metrics such as Support, Confidence, and Lift, alongside Kulczynski and Cosine measures to ensure rule harmony.

Key Insights and Ideas

The study revealed a fundamental shift in the BoP marketing mix priorities:

  • The "Packaging" Pivot: Pre-pandemic, BoP consumers often viewed packaging as an unnecessary cost or a marketing trick, preferring "loose" goods. During COVID-19, packaging was re-contextualized as a proxy for hygiene and safety—a "silent salesman" signaling that the product was untouched and safe.
  • Price vs. Safety: While price remains the most crucial factor for BoP consumers, the pandemic showed a willingness to trade off some price sensitivity for perceived safety and hygiene.
  • The Power of the 'Kirana' Store: The study reinforces the importance of "Place" (Availability). Local small-scale retail outlets (Kirana stores) became vital during lockdowns, providing essential credit facilities and a sense of belonging that supermarkets could not offer.
  • Product Core: Regardless of the era, "Product" remains the anchor. If the price isn't justified by the product's functional utility, BoP consumers will not purchase it, regardless of promotion.

Key Results

The quantitative shift is clearly visible in the generated association rules. In the Pre-COVID era, the strongest rule was Product ⇒ Price (75% support, 91% confidence), with packaging showing minimal occurrence.

Marketing Mix Item Counts During COVID-19

During the pandemic, the rules evolved to include packaging as a critical consequence. The top rule became Product ⇒ Price, Packaging (92.2% confidence, 1.23 lift). In 79.5% of cases where consumers were concerned with product and price, they also specifically sought out packaging. Conversely, "Promotion" showed the least occurrence across all rules, suggesting that functional attributes far outweigh marketing "noise" during a crisis for this segment.

Conclusion and Future Work

The BoPCOVIPIP study demonstrates that BoP consumers are dynamic and responsive to environmental shocks. The emergence of packaging as a hygiene signal represents a significant shift for the FMCG industry. Future research should expand to other geographic regions and sectors beyond FMCG, potentially incorporating qualitative studies to gain deeper psychological insights into these behavioral shifts.

Summary updated

Abstract

The behaviour of consumers mostly follows the guidelines derived from marketing theories and models. But under some unavoidable circumstances, the consumers show a complete deviation compared to their existing consumption pattern, purchase behaviour, decision-making and so on. Under similar circumstances, this study aims to capture both urban and rural Bottom of the Pyramid (BoP) consumers’ perceptions of various marketing mixes during the COVID-19 pandemic situation. With a sample size of 378 and 282, the perception towards different marketing mixes has been captured for Pre-COVID and During-COVID periods, respectively. The adopted quantitative analysis indicates a difference in perception towards marketing mix During COVID compared to Pre-COVID. Moreover, the selection of West Bengal, India, as an area of research fulfills the BoP literature’s existing prominent research gap. This study also comes with the potential to assist marketers and the Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) industry in framing strategies to target BoP consumers.
BibTeX
@article{panda2022bopcovipip,
  author = {Debadrita Panda and Sabyasachi Mukhopadhyay and Rajarshi Saha and Prasanta K. Panigrahi and Prasanta K. Panigrahi},
  title = {{BoPCOVIPIP: Capturing the Dynamics of Marketing Mix Among Bottom of Pyramid Consumers during COVID-19}},
  journal = {International Journal of Intelligent Systems and Applications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5815/ijisa.2022.04.04},
}
Figure