Bone Marrow Adiposity and Fragility Fractures in Postmenopausal Women: The ADIMOS Case-Control Study

Julien Paccou, Sammy Badr, Daniela Lombardo, Huda Khizindar, Valérie Deken, Stefan Ruschke, Dimitrios C. Karampinos, Anne Cotten, Bernard CortetThe Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates whether bone marrow fat content (adiposity) measured by MRI can predict fragility fractures in postmenopausal women. While lumbar spine fat content showed no association with fractures, lower fat content in the proximal femur (specifically the femoral neck and diaphysis) was linked to an increased risk of clinical vertebral fractures, suggesting this region may be a more sensitive indicator of fracture risk.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Osteoporotic fractures are a major health concern, leading to reduced quality of life and increased mortality. Current methods for diagnosing osteoporosis and predicting fracture risk, primarily based on bone mineral density (BMD) measured by DXA, often miss individuals who are at high risk. This is because many fractures occur in people who haven't been diagnosed with osteoporosis or have few clinical risk factors. Therefore, there's a critical need for improved methods to identify individuals at higher risk of fracture. Bone marrow adiposity (BMA), the amount of fat within the bone marrow, has emerged as a potential new biomarker. Previous studies have suggested a link between higher BMA and lower BMD, but the association between BMA and actual fractures, particularly in postmenopausal women and across different skeletal sites, remains unclear and requires further investigation.

Methods

The researchers conducted a case-control study involving 199 postmenopausal women aged 50-90. The "patient cases" group (n=100) had recent osteoporotic fractures (within 12 months), while the "controls" group (n=99) had osteoarthritis but no history of fragility fractures.

Bone marrow adiposity was assessed using two primary MRI techniques:

  • Water-Fat Separation MRI (WFI): This technique, specifically a multi-echo gradient-echo sequence called mDixon-Quant, was used to quantify the proton density fat fraction (PDFF) in the lumbar spine and proximal femur (femoral head, neck, and diaphysis). This is a non-invasive imaging method.
  • Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (MRS): A subgroup of participants underwent ¹H-MRS to measure PDFF and apparent lipid unsaturation level (aLUL) in the lumbar spine and femoral neck. This technique provides more detailed information about fat composition.

Bone mineral density (BMD) was measured using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) at the lumbar spine and hip.

Statistical analyses included comparisons of patient characteristics, BMD, and PDFF between groups, adjusting for age, Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI), and BMD using analysis of covariance (ANCOVA).

Datasets

The study utilized data from 199 postmenopausal women recruited at Lille University Hospital, France. This cohort was divided into two groups:

  • Patient Cases (n=100): Women with recent osteoporotic fractures (hip, vertebral, proximal humerus, pelvis, ribs, and forearm/wrist).
  • Controls (n=99): Women with osteoarthritis and no history of fragility fractures.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study used existing clinical data and imaging techniques.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Lumbar spine fat isn't the whole story: The study found no significant association between bone marrow fat content in the lumbar spine and the presence of osteoporotic fractures. This challenges some previous assumptions and highlights that different skeletal sites may behave differently.
  • Proximal femur fat matters for vertebral fractures: A key finding is that lower fat content in the femoral neck and diaphysis was associated with clinical vertebral fractures. This is a novel observation and suggests that the proximal femur might be a more sensitive indicator for this specific type of fracture.
  • MRI PDFF as a potential complementary tool: The results suggest that imaging-based PDFF measurements of the proximal femur could potentially serve as a non-invasive biomarker to help differentiate postmenopausal women with and without vertebral fractures, independent of traditional risk factors like age, CCI, and BMD.
  • MRS and WFI are comparable: The study found strong correlations between PDFF measurements obtained from both WFI (imaging-based) and MRS (spectroscopy-based) techniques, supporting the use of WFI for its speed and broader applicability.

Key Results

  • Baseline Differences: Controls were significantly younger and had higher BMD at all measured sites compared to patient cases.
  • Lumbar Spine PDFF: No statistically significant differences in lumbar spine PDFF were found between patient cases (overall, vertebral fractures, or nonvertebral fractures) and controls, even after adjusting for age, CCI, and lumbar spine BMD.
  • Proximal Femur PDFF (Vertebral Fractures): Women with clinical vertebral fractures had significantly lower femoral neck PDFF (adjusted mean 79.3% vs. 83.0%, P=0.020) and femoral diaphysis PDFF (adjusted mean 77.7% vs. 81.6%, P=0.029) compared to controls.
  • Proximal Femur PDFF (Nonvertebral Fractures): No significant differences in hip PDFF were found between patients with nonvertebral fractures and controls.
  • MRS Results: Femoral neck PDFF measured by MRS was also found to be lower in cases compared to controls (adjusted mean 78.3% vs. 82.3%, P=0.028).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-sectional design: The study's design prevents establishing a temporal relationship between PDFF and fracture outcomes.
  • Lack of age matching: While statistical adjustments were made, the lack of strict age matching in the overall cohort is a limitation.
  • Sample size for specific fracture types: The study may not be adequately powered to detect meaningful differences between specific fracture types (e.g., comparing vertebral fractures to nonvertebral fractures directly against controls).
  • Control group: The use of women with osteoarthritis as controls might introduce some bias, as osteoarthritis can affect bone marrow composition.
  • Generalizability: The findings are specific to postmenopausal women and may not apply to men or younger age groups.

Future Work: The authors recommend that future studies investigating BMAT and bone health should prioritize measuring proximal femur PDFF rather than lumbar spine PDFF. They also emphasize the need for longitudinal studies to confirm these findings and suggest that PDFF could be a useful, radiation-free tool to complement BMD in assessing bone fragility. Standardization of imaging protocols, as recommended by the Bone Marrow Adiposity Society, is crucial for comparability across studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Context Noninvasive assessment of proton density fat fraction (PDFF) by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) may improve the prediction of fractures. Objective This work aimed to determine if an association exists between PDFF and fractures. Methods A case-control study was conducted at Lille University Hospital, Lille, France, with 2 groups of postmenopausal women: one with recent osteoporotic fractures, and the other with no fractures. Lumbar spine and proximal femur (femoral head, neck, and diaphysis) PDFF were determined using chemical shift-based water-fat separation MRI (WFI) and dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry scans of the lumbar spine and hip. Our primary objective was to determine the relationship between lumbar spine PDFF and osteoporotic fractures in postmenopausal women. Analysis of covariance was used to compare PDFF measurements between patient cases (overall and according to the type of fracture) and controls, after adjusting for age, Charlson comorbidity index (CCI) and BMD. Results In 199 participants, controls (n = 99) were significantly younger (P < .001) and had significantly higher BMD (P < 0.001 for all sites) than patient cases (n = 100). A total of 52 women with clinical vertebral fractures and 48 with nonvertebral fractures were included. When PDFFs in patient cases and controls were compared, after adjustment on age, CCI, and BMD, no statistically significant differences between the groups were found at the lumbar spine or proximal femur. When PDFFs in participants with clinical vertebral fractures (n = 52) and controls were compared, femoral neck PDFF and femoral diaphysis PDFF were detected to be lower in participants with clinical vertebral fractures than in controls (adjusted mean [SE] 79.3% [1.2] vs 83.0% [0.8]; P = 0.020, and 77.7% [1.4] vs 81.6% [0.9]; P = 0.029, respectively). Conclusion No difference in lumbar spine PDFF was found between those with osteoporotic fractures and controls. However, imaging-based proximal femur PDFF may discriminate between postmenopausal women with and without clinical vertebral fractures, independently of age, CCI, and BMD.
BibTeX
@article{paccou2023bone,
  author = {Julien Paccou and Sammy Badr and Daniela Lombardo and Huda Khizindar and Valérie Deken and Stefan Ruschke and Dimitrios C. Karampinos and Anne Cotten and Bernard Cortet},
  title = {{Bone Marrow Adiposity and Fragility Fractures in Postmenopausal Women: The ADIMOS Case-Control Study}},
  journal = {The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology \& Metabolism},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1210/clinem/dgad195},
}
Figure