Bond-bending isomerism of Au2I3−: competition between covalent bonding and aurophilicity

Wan‐Lu Li, Hong-tao Liu, Tian Jian, Gary V. Lopez, Zachary A. Piazza, Dao-Ling Huang, Teng-Teng Chen, Jing Su, Ping Yang, Xin Chen, Lai‐Sheng Wang, Jun LiChemical 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals a fascinating molecular phenomenon in the gaseous Au<sub>2</sub>I<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup> cluster: it exists as two distinct "bond-bending isomers" that can interconvert. This isomerism arises from a delicate balance between strong Au-I covalent bonds and weaker, yet significant, Au-Au "aurophilic" interactions, offering a rare glimpse into molecular flexibility driven by competing forces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The fundamental principle in chemistry is that molecules typically adopt a single, stable geometric structure dictated by their bonding. While the concept of "bond-stretch isomers" (BSIs) – molecules existing in two stable forms with different bond lengths – has been proposed, experimental evidence has been scarce and often debated, with many early claims attributed to artifacts or solid-state effects. This paper addresses the challenge of experimentally observing and theoretically understanding molecular structures that can exist in multiple, nearly degenerate forms due to competing chemical forces, specifically focusing on bond-bending rather than bond-stretching. The authors investigate the Au<sub>2</sub>I<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup> cluster, a system where the interplay of strong covalent bonding and the unique "aurophilicity" of gold is expected to lead to complex structural behavior.

Methods

The researchers employed a dual approach combining experimental photoelectron spectroscopy (PES) with sophisticated quantum chemical calculations.

  • Photoelectron Spectroscopy (PES): Two distinct PES setups were used to probe the electronic structure of the Au<sub>2</sub>I<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup> anion. One used electrospray ionization (ESI) to produce the anions, while the other employed laser vaporization. Temperature-dependent experiments were crucial, using variations in cluster residence time in the nozzle to simulate "hot," "warm," and "cold" conditions. This allowed them to observe how the spectral features changed with temperature, providing clues about the presence and relative stability of different isomers.
  • Quantum Chemical Calculations: A suite of high-level ab initio methods, including coupled-cluster theory [CCSD(T)] and SCS-MP2, were used to optimize the geometries of potential Au<sub>2</sub>I<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup> isomers and calculate their energies. Density Functional Theory (DFT) was also explored, though some functionals were found to be less reliable for this system. To understand the bonding, they utilized energy decomposition analysis (EDA), electron localization functions (ELFs), and natural population analyses (NPA).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the experimental and theoretical characterization of a specific molecular cluster, Au<sub>2</sub>I<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup>, rather than training or evaluating models on large datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bond-Bending Isomerism: The most striking finding is the clear experimental and theoretical evidence for two distinct "bond-bending isomers" (BBIs) of Au<sub>2</sub>I<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup>. These isomers differ primarily in the bending angle of the I-Au-I-Au-I backbone.
  • Competition Between Forces: The existence of these isomers is attributed to a fundamental competition between strong Au-I covalent bonding, which favors a more obtuse bending angle, and weaker, but significant, Au-Au aurophilic interactions, which pull the gold atoms closer and favor a more acute angle.
  • Nearly Degenerate and Interconvertible: The two isomers are found to be nearly degenerate in energy, separated by a very small energy barrier (1.78 kJ/mol). This low barrier allows for facile interconversion, especially at higher temperatures.
  • Temperature-Dependent Spectroscopy: The temperature-dependent PES experiments provided compelling evidence for the co-existence of isomers. At low temperatures ("cold" conditions), only the more stable, obtuse isomer is observed, while at higher temperatures ("hot" and "warm" conditions), spectral features attributed to the acute isomer appear.
  • Aurophilicity's Role: The study highlights the crucial role of aurophilicity – the attractive interaction between gold atoms with filled d-orbitals – in stabilizing the acute isomer and driving this unique structural phenomenon.

Key Results

  • Two distinct geometric isomers of Au<sub>2</sub>I<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup> were identified: an "obtuse" isomer with an I-Au-I angle of 100.7° and an "acute" isomer with an I-Au-I angle of 72.0°.
  • The acute isomer features a short Au-Au distance of 3.08 Å, indicative of strong aurophilic interactions, while the obtuse isomer has a longer Au-Au distance (3.99 Å) and is slightly more stable.
  • The energy barrier between the two isomers is very low (1.78 kJ/mol), suggesting facile interconversion.
  • Temperature-dependent PES experiments showed that at low temperatures, only the obtuse isomer is observed, while at higher temperatures, evidence for the acute isomer emerges.
  • High-level theoretical calculations (CCSD(T)) accurately reproduced the experimental PES spectra, validating the proposed structures and their relative energies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Solid-State vs. Gas Phase: While the study focuses on the gas phase, the authors suggest that in the condensed phase, the lifetime of the acute isomer might be significantly longer, potentially allowing for the stable existence of separate BBIs in solid materials.
  • Spin-Orbit Coupling: While spin-orbit (SO) coupling effects were found to be important for the electronic structure, they did not significantly alter the relative energies of the isomers, suggesting that the primary drivers of isomerism are covalent and aurophilic interactions.
  • Future Directions: The paper opens avenues for exploring similar bond-bending isomerism in other gold-containing clusters and complexes where competing bonding interactions are present. Further investigation into the dynamics of interconversion and the influence of the environment (e.g., solvent or solid matrix) on isomer stability would be valuable. The authors also note that while DFT methods were explored, high-level ab initio methods were essential for accurate characterization, suggesting a need for careful functional selection in future studies of similar systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report a joint photoelectron spectroscopy and theoretical investigation of the gaseous Au<sub>2</sub>I<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup> cluster, which is found to exhibit two types of isomers due to competition between Au-I covalent bonding and Au-Au aurophilic interactions. The covalent bonding favors a bent IAuIAuI<sup>-</sup> structure with an obtuse Au-I-Au angle (100.7°), while aurophilic interactions pull the two Au atoms much closer, leading to an acutely bent structure (72.0°) with an Au-Au distance of 3.08 Å. The two isomers are separated by a small barrier and are nearly degenerate with the obtuse isomer being slightly more stable. At low temperature, only the obtuse isomer is observed; distinct experimental evidence is observed for the co-existence of a combination of isomers with both acute and obtuse bending angles at room temperature. The two bond-bending isomers of Au<sub>2</sub>I<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup> reveal a unique example of one molecule being able to oscillate between different structures as a result of two competing chemical forces.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2015bond,
  author = {Wan‐Lu Li and Hong-tao Liu and Tian Jian and Gary V. Lopez and Zachary A. Piazza and Dao-Ling Huang and Teng-Teng Chen and Jing Su and Ping Yang and Xin Chen and Lai‐Sheng Wang and Jun Li},
  title = {{Bond-bending isomerism of Au<sub>2</sub>I<sub>3</sub><sup>−</sup>: competition between covalent bonding and aurophilicity}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1039/c5sc03568f},
}
Figure