Board # 65 : Retention and Persistence among STEM Students: A Comparison of Direct Admit and Transfer Students across Engineering and Science

Omaima Almatrafi, Aditya Johri, Huzefa Rangwala, Jaime Lester2018 · DOI

Abstract

This research examines the "leaky pipeline" in STEM education by analyzing longitudinal enrollment data from a large public university. By comparing persistence rates between the College of Engineering and the College of Science, as well as between direct-admit and transfer students, the study identifies critical trends in student retention. Key findings include a significant "transfer advantage" in engineering and the emergence of Information Technology as a primary destination for students migrating between majors.

Introduction

The United States faces a critical shortage of STEM professionals, a problem exacerbated by high attrition rates among undergraduate students. While traditional research often focuses on the transition from K-12 to college, this study investigates the dynamics of persistence once students have entered a degree program. A particular focus is placed on transfer students, a demographic that is frequently overlooked in retention studies despite making up a substantial portion of the STEM student body.

Methodology

The authors conducted a longitudinal descriptive analysis of enrollment data from 2009 to 2014. The study tracked three distinct cohorts: 328 direct-admit engineering students, 299 science students, and 573 transfer students entering engineering. Persistence was defined as the percentage of students remaining in their original matriculated major over eight semesters. The research also mapped "within-school migration" to understand where students go when they switch majors but remain within the same college.

Disciplinary Persistence and the "Transfer Advantage"

The data reveals a stark contrast in persistence between disciplines. Engineering students maintained a persistence rate of approximately 70%, whereas science students saw a much lower rate of 44%.

Persistence rates by major in the College of Engineering over eight semesters.

A surprising finding was the "transfer advantage": transfer students in engineering exhibited persistence rates exceeding 80%, significantly higher than their direct-admit counterparts. This suggests that the experience of transferring may select for students with higher career certainty or resilience. Furthermore, the College of Engineering's policy of allowing students to remain "Undeclared" (UNDE) for longer periods appeared to support retention, with these students showing a 71% persistence rate within the college.

Migration Patterns and the IT Magnet

The study found that over 50% of major-switching occurs within the first two years of study. When students do switch majors within the engineering school, they gravitate toward specific programs. Information Technology (INFT) emerged as the most significant "magnet" major.

Within-school migration patterns showing the percentage of students moving to various engineering majors.

As shown in the migration data, INFT is the primary destination for internal migrators and was the top choice for half of all transfer students. INFT also boasted the highest individual persistence rate at 84.6%.

Conclusion

This study challenges the notion of a universally "leaky" STEM pipeline by demonstrating that specific institutional structures and student pathways—such as the transfer process and undeclared major flexibility—can significantly enhance persistence. By identifying Information Technology as a key destination for migrating students, administrators can better tailor support services to help students find sustainable paths within STEM. Future research will utilize predictive modeling to identify students at risk of attrition before they leave the field.

Summary updated

Abstract

Johri studies the use of information and communication technologies (ICT) for learning and knowledge sharing
BibTeX
@misc{almatrafi2018board,
  author = {Omaima Almatrafi and Aditya Johri and Huzefa Rangwala and Jaime Lester},
  title = {{Board \# 65 : Retention and Persistence among STEM Students: A Comparison of Direct Admit and Transfer Students across Engineering and Science}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.18260/1-2--27899},
}

Loading related content...

Figure