Blockchain-Based Secure Storage and Access Control Scheme for Supply Chain Ecological Business Data: A Case Study of the Automotive Industry

Songjiang Li, Tao Zhou, Huamin Yang, Peng Wang2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel blockchain-based system for secure storage and fine-grained access control of automotive supply chain data. It tackles the challenges of data privacy, storage pressure, and trust in traditional systems by combining Hyperledger Fabric, IPFS, and a dual-layer attribute-based encryption approach, offering enhanced security and efficiency for complex supply chains.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The automotive industry's supply chain is notoriously complex, involving numerous global suppliers and intricate interdependencies. This complexity leads to challenges in data sharing, including slow response times, poor integration, and a general lack of trust and transparency among participants. Traditional data sharing solutions struggle to meet the growing demands for robust privacy protection and secure, flexible access control, especially in light of regulations like GDPR. Furthermore, storing large volumes of data directly on a blockchain creates significant storage pressure and performance bottlenecks. This paper aims to address these issues by proposing a secure, efficient, and privacy-preserving solution for automotive supply chain data management.

Methods

The proposed solution integrates several key technologies:

  • Hyperledger Fabric: A permissioned blockchain platform is used to manage data access policies, store metadata (like content identifiers and encrypted keys), and provide an auditable ledger of access records.
  • IPFS (InterPlanetary File System): This decentralized storage system is employed to store the actual encrypted business data, alleviating the storage burden on the blockchain.
  • Hybrid Encryption: A two-tiered encryption approach is utilized. First, data is encrypted using AES (Advanced Encryption Standard) for efficient and secure storage on IPFS. Second, the AES key is then encrypted using a Ciphertext-Policy Attribute-Based Encryption (CP-ABE) algorithm. This CP-ABE encryption incorporates the access policy, ensuring that only users with the specified attributes can decrypt the key and subsequently access the data.
  • Dual-Layer Auditable Access Control Model: This model combines an off-chain CP-ABE mechanism for fine-grained access control based on attributes (company, department, role) with an on-chain smart contract-based system. The on-chain component enforces policies, manages access requests, and crucially, creates immutable audit logs of all access activities.
  • Smart Contracts: Four smart contracts are developed on Hyperledger Fabric to manage data storage, access policies, access requests, and record auditing, enabling automated and transparent operations.

Datasets

The experimental evaluation utilized real production business data provided by China FAW Group Co., Ltd. The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather uses this real-world data to simulate various scenarios for performance and security testing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decoupling Data Storage: Storing large data files on IPFS and only blockchain metadata (like content identifiers and encrypted keys) on Hyperledger Fabric is a crucial strategy to overcome blockchain's storage limitations and improve scalability.
  • Hybrid Encryption for Efficiency: Combining AES for bulk data encryption with CP-ABE for key encryption offers a balance between security and performance. While CP-ABE alone can be computationally intensive, using it only for the smaller AES key significantly improves efficiency, especially with a large number of attributes.
  • Attribute-Based Access Control for Granularity: CP-ABE allows for highly flexible and fine-grained access control based on user attributes, moving beyond traditional role-based systems and enabling policies like "users from the 'Information Department' of 'Logistics Provider B' can access this data."
  • On-Chain Auditability is Paramount: The integration of smart contracts to log every access request and outcome on the blockchain provides an immutable audit trail, essential for compliance, dispute resolution, and detecting malicious activities.
  • Privacy Under Ciphertext: The dual-layer model ensures that access control decisions and data access occur under ciphertext, minimizing the risk of sensitive information being exposed in plaintext during the process.

Key Results

  • Performance Gains: The proposed hybrid encryption scheme demonstrated significant time advantages, especially under conditions of large-scale data and a high number of attributes, compared to using CP-ABE alone. For instance, with 50 attributes and a 50M file, the hybrid scheme maintained a consistent time overhead, while CP-ABE alone showed a linear increase.
  • Storage Efficiency: By storing data on IPFS, the scheme significantly reduces on-chain storage requirements, mitigating blockchain storage bottlenecks.
  • High Throughput: The Hyperledger Fabric network achieved high throughput for various operations, with query operations generally outperforming write/update operations due to less overhead. The system throughput stabilized around 400 concurrent requests, indicating efficient handling of concurrent access.
  • Security: The scheme provides strong confidentiality through AES encryption, integrity through IPFS content addressing and blockchain hashing, and tamper resistance. The attribute-based access control and on-chain auditing enhance security against unauthorized access and data leakage.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Node Attribute Authority: Currently, the attribute authorization authority is managed by a single node. The authors propose to adapt the CP-ABE scheme to accommodate multiple institutions, distributing this authority across different nodes to enhance scalability and fault tolerance.
  • Real-World Deployment: The solution has been tested with simulated data and in a lab environment. The next step involves research and application in a real-world setting, such as at China FAW Group Co., Ltd., to serve as a reference for intelligent automotive supply chains.
  • Enhanced Privacy with Zero-Knowledge Proofs: To further improve data privacy, the authors suggest introducing zero-knowledge proof technology for attribute set verification. This would allow proving attribute compliance without revealing the actual attribute information, offering a higher level of privacy.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{li2023blockchain,
  author = {Songjiang Li and Tao Zhou and Huamin Yang and Peng Wang},
  title = {{Blockchain-Based Secure Storage and Access Control Scheme for Supply Chain Ecological Business Data: A Case Study of the Automotive Industry}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23167036},
}
Figure