Block Gibbs Sampling for Bayesian Random Effects Models With Improper Priors: Convergence and Regeneration

Aixin Tan, James P. HobertJournal of Computational and Graphical Statistics 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a robust method for analyzing Bayesian random effects models, even when using "improper" priors, by developing a block Gibbs sampler with guaranteed convergence properties. They achieve this by combining theoretical analysis of the sampler's geometric ergodicity with a regenerative simulation technique, allowing for reliable estimation of posterior expectations and the calculation of valid standard errors, akin to classical Monte Carlo methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bayesian analysis of random effects models is common, but often relies on "improper" priors (priors that don't integrate to 1) for certain parameters, especially variance components. While these priors can be theoretically appealing and recommended in the literature, they can lead to intractable posterior distributions. Standard Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods, like Gibbs sampling, are used to explore these posteriors, but their theoretical guarantees (like convergence to the true distribution and reliable error estimation) can be difficult to establish, especially with improper priors and complex models. Specifically, the authors address the challenge of:

  1. Ensuring the posterior is proper: Improper priors can sometimes lead to improper posteriors, meaning they don't represent a valid probability distribution.
  2. Establishing convergence guarantees: Proving that a Gibbs sampler will eventually converge to the correct stationary distribution (the posterior) and at what rate is crucial for trusting the results. This is particularly challenging for complex models and improper priors.
  3. Obtaining reliable standard errors: Standard methods for calculating confidence intervals and determining sample size in MCMC can be problematic due to the dependent nature of MCMC samples.

Methods

The paper tackles these challenges through a two-pronged approach:

  1. Block Gibbs Sampler: Instead of updating each parameter individually, they group parameters into blocks (specifically, variance components and the rest of the parameters) and update them together. This "blocking" strategy can often improve convergence properties compared to univariate Gibbs sampling.
  2. Theoretical Analysis of Geometric Ergodicity: They rigorously prove that their block Gibbs sampler is "geometrically ergodic" under certain conditions. This is a strong theoretical guarantee, implying that the sampler converges to its stationary distribution at a geometric rate, meaning it "forgets" its initial state quickly. This analysis involves proving a "drift condition" for the Markov chain, a key theoretical tool.
  3. Regenerative Simulation Method: This is the core methodological contribution for practical application. They introduce a technique that breaks the MCMC chain into independent "tours" or segments. This allows them to leverage standard i.i.d. (independent and identically distributed) statistical theory for analysis.
  4. Minorization Condition: They establish a "minorization condition" for their block Gibbs sampler, which is a technical requirement for regeneration.
  5. Bernoulli Sampling: After each standard Gibbs iteration, they simulate an extra Bernoulli random variable. When this variable signals a "regeneration," it effectively restarts the chain from a known distribution, creating i.i.d. segments.
  6. Asymptotic Standard Errors: This regenerative approach allows for the calculation of simple, asymptotically valid standard errors for the estimated posterior expectations. These standard errors are crucial for determining the required sample size to achieve a desired level of precision, mirroring the process in classical Monte Carlo.

Datasets

The paper uses a real dataset from a study on styrene exposure to illustrate their method. This dataset involves measurements of styrene exposure for 13 workers, with each worker having three separate measurements.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Improper Priors are Manageable: The paper demonstrates that even with improper priors, which are often recommended for Bayesian hierarchical models, a well-designed Gibbs sampler can be used reliably.
  • Geometric Ergodicity is Achievable: Proving geometric ergodicity for complex MCMC samplers, especially those used with improper priors, is a significant theoretical hurdle. The paper provides conditions under which their block Gibbs sampler achieves this.
  • Regeneration as a "Free Lunch" for MCMC: The regenerative simulation method effectively turns dependent MCMC samples into independent ones for analytical purposes. This allows for the straightforward calculation of standard errors and sample size determination, a major practical advantage.
  • Block Gibbs Can Outperform Univariate: The theoretical analysis suggests that blocking variables can lead to better convergence properties, making the sampler more efficient.
  • Data Balance Matters: The conditions for geometric ergodicity are shown to depend on the sample size and the balance of data across groups, highlighting that highly unbalanced datasets can pose challenges.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Guarantee: The paper proves that the block Gibbs Markov chain is geometrically ergodic under specific conditions related to the number of groups (q), total sample size (M), and hyper-parameters of the prior. For the standard diffuse prior, this holds if q ≥ 4 and M > q + 3, or for q=3 under specific conditions on sample sizes.
  • Regenerative Method for Standard Errors: The proposed regenerative simulation method yields simple, asymptotically valid standard errors for posterior expectation estimates.
  • Styrene Exposure Example: The method is successfully applied to the styrene exposure data, demonstrating its practical utility. The results show stable estimates and confidence intervals for variance components and other parameters of interest. For instance, after 40,000 regenerations, the estimated margin of error for the posterior mean of $\sigma_\theta^2$ was about 1% of its magnitude.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Alternative Blocking Schemes: The authors note that their proof of geometric ergodicity is specific to their chosen blocking scheme. They suspect that an alternative blocking scheme (grouping $\theta$ and then $(\mu, \sigma_\theta^2, \sigma_\epsilon^2)$) is also geometrically ergodic but state that their current proof techniques are not directly applicable, leaving this as an open question.
  • Data Balance: While the conditions for geometric ergodicity are generally met, the paper highlights that extremely small and unbalanced datasets can be problematic. The specific conditions for geometric ergodicity in such cases are detailed.
  • Computational Cost: While the regenerative method simplifies analysis, the simulation itself can still be computationally intensive, especially for achieving high precision. The paper mentions that 40,000 regenerations took 3 minutes on their system.

The paper's main contribution is providing a theoretically sound and practically useful framework for analyzing Bayesian random effects models with improper priors, bridging the gap between theoretical guarantees and practical implementation of MCMC methods.

Summary updated

Abstract

Bayesian versions of the classical one-way random effects model are widely used to analyze data. If the standard diffuse prior is adopted, there is a simple block Gibbs sampler that can be employed to explore the intractable posterior distribution. In this article, theoretical and methodological results are developed that allow one to use this block Gibbs sampler with the same level of confidence that one would have using classical (iid) Monte Carlo. Indeed, a regenerative simulation method is developed that yields simple, asymptotically valid standard errors for the ergodic averages that are used to estimate intractable posterior expectations. These standard errors can be used to choose an appropriate (Markov chain) Monte Carlo sample size. The regenerative method rests on the assumption that the underlying Markov chain converges to its stationary distribution at a geometric rate. Another contribution of this article is a result showing that, unless the dataset is extremely small and unbalanced, the block Gibbs Markov chain is geometrically ergodic. We illustrate the use of the regenerative method with data from a styrene exposure study. R code for the simulation is posted as an online supplement.
BibTeX
@article{tan2009block,
  author = {Aixin Tan and James P. Hobert},
  title = {{Block Gibbs Sampling for Bayesian Random Effects Models With Improper Priors: Convergence and Regeneration}},
  journal = {Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1198/jcgs.2009.08153},
}
Figure