Black–White Color Metaphors of Justice: Two Experiments on Justice as a Legal Value

Shuhui Xu, Weiwei Sun, Kaihang ZhangBehavioral 2026 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the common "black and white" color metaphors influence our understanding of justice. They found that while white is consistently associated with justice, the association between black and injustice is more context-dependent, appearing more strongly when people are explicitly asked to make a choice. This suggests that these color metaphors play a role in shaping our legal cognition, but their activation is flexible.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Justice is a fundamental, yet abstract, legal and moral concept. While we often rely on abstract reasoning for legal matters, research in cognitive science suggests that our understanding of abstract concepts can be grounded in more concrete, embodied experiences, such as sensory perceptions. One common area of research is the influence of color on moral judgments. Previous work has shown general associations between light/white and positive attributes, and dark/black with negative attributes. However, it's unclear if these general associations specifically apply to the legal value of justice, and whether these associations are automatic or require more deliberate processing. This paper aims to bridge this gap by specifically testing the metaphorical link between black/white colors and the concept of justice as a legal value, and to see how this link manifests under different cognitive demands.

Methods

The researchers conducted two experiments to investigate the black-white color metaphors for justice:

  • Experiment 1: Stroop-style Lexical-Judgment Task: Participants were presented with words related to justice or injustice, colored either black or white. They had to quickly classify the word's meaning. This task is designed to detect automatic processing biases. If a color-meaning association exists, congruent trials (e.g., white word for justice) should be processed faster and more accurately than incongruent trials (e.g., white word for injustice).
  • Experiment 2: Translation-Matching Paradigm: Participants were shown Chinese words for justice or injustice and had to choose between two foreign (Russian) translation options, one presented in black and the other in white. Crucially, participants were not expected to know the meaning of the Russian words, so their choices would be driven by implicit associations rather than explicit semantic retrieval. This task probes more explicit, but still intuitive, color-concept associations.

Both experiments carefully controlled for factors like affective valence and word frequency to isolate the effect of color.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used custom-generated stimuli (justice- and injustice-related words in Chinese, paired with Russian translations) and did not rely on pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Justice is not just abstract: Our understanding of complex legal values like justice can be influenced by basic sensory experiences, like color.
  • White = Justice, but it's complicated: The association between white and justice is quite robust and appears even in tasks that tap into more automatic processing.
  • Black-injustice is context-dependent: The link between black and injustice is less automatic. It emerges more strongly when people are explicitly asked to make a choice, suggesting it requires more deliberate cognitive engagement.
  • Metaphors are flexible, not rigid: These color-justice associations aren't fixed rules but rather probabilistic mappings that can be activated differently depending on the cognitive task.

Key Results

  • Experiment 1 (Stroop):
    • Participants responded faster to justice-related words than injustice-related words.
  • Words presented in white were classified more accurately than words in black.
  • Crucially, there was no significant interaction between color and meaning. This means that while white might have generally improved accuracy, there wasn't a clear advantage for "white-justice" or "black-injustice" combinations in terms of speed or accuracy, suggesting no strong automatic congruency effect.
  • Experiment 2 (Translation-Matching):
    • Participants were significantly more likely to choose the white translation for justice-related words (58.12% of the time) compared to injustice-related words (42.71%).
  • Conversely, they were more likely to choose the black translation for injustice-related words (57.29%) compared to justice-related words (41.88%).
  • These results indicate a clear, explicit color-justice association under conditions that minimized explicit semantic retrieval.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Homogeneity: The study participants were primarily undergraduate students from a similar cultural and geographic background. Future research should explore these effects in more diverse age groups, cultural contexts, and socioeconomic strata to assess generalizability.
  • Cultural Specificity: While the study hints at cultural influences, more systematic cross-cultural research is needed to disentangle culturally specific associations from potentially universal cognitive tendencies.
  • Affective States: The study did not control for participants' mood, which can influence perception and judgment. Future work could incorporate mood assessments.
  • Temporal Dynamics: The current behavioral measures don't fully reveal the temporal sequence of these associations. Integrating methods like event-related potentials (ERPs) or the Implicit Association Test (IAT) could better distinguish automatic from controlled processes.
  • Ecological Validity: The findings are based on laboratory experiments. Future research should explore these effects in real-world settings, such as judicial contexts or educational materials, to assess their practical impact on trust in institutions and law-abiding behavior.

Summary updated

Abstract

Color metaphors may shape how people mentally represent abstract legal values such as justice and thereby influence legal socialization and law-related cognition. We tested whether black/white color terms are metaphorically linked to justice conceived specifically as a legal value, and whether these linkages vary with task demands. In two preregistered experiments that controlled for affective valence, word frequency, and semantic relatedness, Experiment 1 employed a Stroop-style lexical-judgment task with law-relevant terms and found faster responses to justice-related (legal) words than to injustice-related words and higher accuracy for white-colored stimuli, but no reliable color × meaning interaction—suggesting the absence of an automatic color–justice congruency effect during early, automatic processing. Experiment 2 used a translation-matching paradigm in which participants selected black or white translations for unfamiliar foreign words; here, participants systematically matched justice-related (legal) items with white and injustice-related items with black at rates above chance, revealing explicit color–justice associations. Together, the results point to a robust mental linkage of white with justice as a legal value, while black–injustice mappings emerge primarily under explicit selection demands. These findings suggest that black/white color metaphors organize law-related moral cognition but are flexibly activated depending on cognitive task and processing level.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2026blackwhite,
  author = {Shuhui Xu and Weiwei Sun and Kaihang Zhang},
  title = {{Black–White Color Metaphors of Justice: Two Experiments on Justice as a Legal Value}},
  booktitle = {Behavioral},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.3390/bs16030367},
}
Figure