Black Hole Hair in Higher Dimensions

Chao Cao, Yi-Xin Chen, Jianlong LiCommunications 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper investigates the conditions under which static, spherically symmetric black holes in $D$-dimensional spacetime can exist in equilibrium with surrounding matter, a phenomenon referred to as "black hole hair." We derive a universal equation of state (EOS) for such matter, $\omega \equiv p_r/\rho = -1/(1+2kn)$, which appears mathematically independent of the number of dimensions $D$. However, when this condition is applied to specific physical models, significant dimensional restrictions emerge. Notably, cosmic strings require even dimensions ($D=2+2kn$) for equilibrium, and linear dilaton fields are found to be permissible only in 4-dimensional spacetime. These results suggest that $D=4$ holds a unique position in the stability and existence of black hole hair.

Introduction

In classical General Relativity, the "No-Hair Theorem" suggests that black holes are remarkably simple objects, characterized solely by their mass, charge, and angular momentum. Under standard conditions, any surrounding matter is typically either accreted or expelled. However, theoretical developments in higher-dimensional physics and string theory have raised the possibility that certain types of exotic matter—such as quintessence or cosmic strings—could exist in a stable, static equilibrium around a black hole, effectively providing it with "hair."

This study seeks to determine the mathematical requirements for this equilibrium in $D$ dimensions. Understanding these constraints is critical for high-energy physics frameworks that rely on extra dimensions for mathematical consistency.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The researchers employed a purely theoretical approach grounded in General Relativity to analyze the interaction between black hole geometry and surrounding matter. The study follows a four-step derivation:

  1. Metric Setup: The analysis begins with a general static, spherically symmetric metric in $D$ dimensions.
  2. Einstein Field Equations: The Einstein equations are used to relate the spacetime geometry (represented by the Ricci tensor) to the energy-momentum tensor of an ideal fluid, which represents the potential "hair."
  3. Near-Horizon Analysis: By performing a Taylor expansion of the metric functions near the event horizon ($u \to u_h$), the authors determined the specific conditions required for the matter density ($\rho$) and radial pressure ($p_r$) to remain smooth and finite at the horizon.
  4. Model Comparison: These general requirements were then tested against specific physical models, including cosmic strings, quintessence, and linear dilaton fields.

The Universal Equation of State

A central finding of the paper is the derivation of a universal Equation of State (EOS) required for matter to remain in equilibrium with a $D$-dimensional black hole:

$$\omega \equiv \frac{p_r}{\rho} = -\frac{1}{1 + 2kn}$$

In this expression, $k$ and $n$ are positive integers related to the order of the horizon and the density distribution. Surprisingly, this specific mathematical requirement for $\omega$ does not explicitly depend on the number of dimensions $D$. This suggests that, at a fundamental level, the balance of forces required for equilibrium is a universal property of the horizon geometry.

Dimensional Constraints in Specific Models

While the general EOS is dimension-independent, the physical realization of this state in specific models reveals strict dimensional dependencies:

  • The Even Dimension Constraint: When modeling the hair as cosmic strings (one-dimensional topological defects), the authors found that equilibrium is only possible if $D = 2 + 2kn$. This implies that the spacetime must be even-dimensional ($D=4, 6, 8, \dots$). This result aligns with certain string theory predictions regarding tachyon condensation.
  • The Special Status of 4D: The linear dilaton field, a specific scalar field arising from string theory, is highly restrictive. The analysis shows it can only satisfy the equilibrium condition in exactly 4 dimensions. Furthermore, the mathematics suggest that 3-dimensional spacetime cannot support this kind of hair, effectively establishing $D=4$ as the minimum viable dimension for these models.

Key Results and Implications

The study provides several definitive conclusions regarding the nature of black hole hair:

  • Cosmic Strings: For equilibrium to exist, $D$ must be even and $\ge 4$. In the standard 4D case, this corresponds to an EOS of $\omega = -1/3$.
  • Quintessence: In models featuring an exponential potential, the EOS required for equilibrium matches the cosmic string result: $\omega = -1/(D-1)$.
  • Exclusion of Matter Types: The results exclude "phantom" matter (where $\rho + p_r < 0$) and standard radiation or dust from being black hole hair, as they do not satisfy the required EOS interval.

Conclusion and Future Work

The research demonstrates that while the mathematical possibility of black hole hair exists across various dimensions, the physical models that might produce such hair are often constrained to even dimensions or specifically to $D=4$.

Future research is required to move beyond the limitations of this study, which was restricted to static, spherically symmetric black holes. Generalizing these findings to rotating (Kerr-like) black holes and investigating the dynamical formation of this hair in the early universe remain significant open questions in the field of higher-dimensional gravity.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the property of matter in equilibrium with a static, spherically symmetric black hole in D-dimensional spacetime. It requires this kind of matter has an equation of state (\omega\equiv p_r/\rho=-1/(1+2kn), k,n\in \mathbb{N}), which seems to be independent of D. However, when we associate this with specific models, some interesting limits on space could be found: (i)(D=2+2kn) while the black hole is surrounded by cosmic strings; (ii)the black hole can be surrounded by linear dilaton field only in 4-dimensional spacetime. In both cases, D=4 is special.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cao2010black,
  author = {Chao Cao and Yi-Xin Chen and Jianlong Li},
  title = {{Black Hole Hair in Higher Dimensions}},
  booktitle = {Communications},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1088/0253-6102/53/2/16},
}

Loading related content...

Figure