Bison Hacks the Yard: Assisting Underrepresented Students Overcome Impostor Syndrome with Augmented Reality and Artificial Intelligence

Nicole SullivanAAAI 2021 · DOI

Introduction

The field of Computer Science (CS) faces a persistent retention crisis, particularly among first-generation and ethnic minority students. A primary psychological driver of this attrition is Impostor Syndrome (IS)—the persistent belief that one’s academic or professional success is the result of luck rather than merit. Students suffering from IS often feel they do not belong in the CS community, leading to high dropout rates despite their technical potential.

This research introduces Bison Hacks the Yard (BHY), an innovative augmented reality (AR) game designed to combat IS among underrepresented computer science students. By integrating adaptive AI-driven learning with personal testimonials from successful alumni, the project aims to boost student confidence and improve retention rates in STEM.

The Problem: Competence and Belonging

The author identifies two critical levers necessary to mitigate Impostor Syndrome:

  1. Competence: Strengthening foundational knowledge (specifically in complex areas like Data Structures) to build academic confidence.
  2. Belonging: Providing "social proof" through representation, demonstrating that successful individuals from similar backgrounds have faced and overcome similar struggles.

Methodology

BHY is hosted on the Metaverse platform and employs a multi-faceted technical approach to address these levers:

Augmented Reality (AR) for Low-Pressure Learning

BHY utilizes AR to overlay 3D diagrams and data structure visualizations onto the physical world. Research indicates that AR environments can lower student anxiety and increase "self-efficacy"—the belief in one’s ability to succeed—compared to traditional, high-stakes classroom settings. By moving learning out of the abstract and into the student's physical environment, the system makes theoretical concepts more tangible.

AI-Driven Adaptive Pathways

To maintain engagement and prevent frustration, the system proposes using Decision Trees or Bayesian Networks. These AI techniques analyze student performance in real-time to adjust the difficulty of tasks. If a student struggles with a specific concept, the system provides hints and encouraging feedback, maintaining a positive learning loop that reinforces competence without overwhelming the learner.

Integrated Mentorship and Social Proof

The application includes three specific "IS activities" featuring pre-recorded videos of Historically Black College or University (HBCU) alumni. These alumni share personal narratives regarding their battles with Impostor Syndrome, creating a virtual support network that fosters a sense of belonging.

Research Design and Evaluation

As a research proposal and initial implementation, the study focuses on undergraduate students at Howard University enrolled in CS I, II, and III. The evaluation framework utilizes a control group and an experimental group, with data gathered via pre- and post-trial questionnaires. The study measures three primary variables:

  • Sense of belonging within the CS community.
  • Severity of Impostor Syndrome symptoms.
  • Objective knowledge of Data Structures (DS).

Key Insights

  • Self-Efficacy as the Antidote: The core thesis is that self-efficacy is the functional opposite of Impostor Syndrome. By creating a "low-pressure" AR environment where students can fail safely and receive immediate, encouraging feedback, the system builds psychological resilience.
  • Functional Representation: The inclusion of alumni videos is a targeted intervention. Literature identifies a "sense of belonging" as a critical factor for program completion; thus, representation is treated as a functional requirement rather than a symbolic addition.

Expected Results and Future Work

The framework anticipates a measurable decrease in IS survey scores and a corresponding increase in objective test scores for fundamental Data Structures among the experimental group. Qualitatively, the author expects to see increased student confidence and a stronger reported connection to the Howard University CS community.

Future iterations of the project aim to expand beyond Howard University to other HBCUs. Planned technical enhancements include "geospatial AR," where specific data structure challenges are tied to physical landmarks on campus, effectively turning the entire university into an interactive, immersive classroom. While the current study covers a three-month period, future longitudinal research will be required to track the long-term impact on graduation rates.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{sullivan2021bison,
  author = {Nicole Sullivan},
  title = {{Bison Hacks the Yard: Assisting Underrepresented Students Overcome Impostor Syndrome with Augmented Reality and Artificial Intelligence}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v35i18.17987},
}
Figure