Birth and birth-related obstetrical characteristics in southwestern China associated with the current adjustment of family planning policy: a 7-year retrospective study

Xiyao Liu, Dongni Huang, Yu Wang, Yuwen Gao, Miaomiao Chen, Yuxiang Bai, Mengshi Wu, Xin Luo, Hongbo QiScientific 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

China's shift from a one-child policy to a universal two-child policy led to a surge in births, primarily driven by older and multiparous women. This change impacted obstetrical care, increasing the complexity of cases for providers, and highlighted the need for individualized studies to guide future healthcare strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, China's strict one-child policy shaped its demographics and healthcare landscape. The subsequent relaxation and eventual implementation of a universal two-child policy aimed to address concerns like an aging population and a shrinking workforce. However, the precise impact of these policy shifts on the obstetrical characteristics of pregnant women and the adaptability of the medical system remained less understood. This paper investigates how these policy changes influenced birth trends, the demographic profile of pregnant women, and associated maternal and neonatal outcomes in a major tertiary care center in southwestern China.

Methods

This study employed a retrospective observational design, analyzing over 50,000 individual medical records from January 2012 to December 2018. The researchers used a combination of statistical analyses:

  • Trend Analysis: Visual inspection and analysis of monthly delivery and abortion/miscarriage trends to identify patterns before and after policy changes.
  • Chi-squared Tests: To assess statistically significant differences in the background characteristics of pregnant women (age, parity, multiple pregnancies, IVF-ET) across the different policy periods (one-child, selective two-child, universal two-child).
  • Multivariable Logistic Regression: To identify factors influencing specific obstetrical outcomes (e.g., Cesarean section rate, pregnancy complications) while controlling for the effects of policy, maternal age, and parity.
  • Hypothetical Birth Modeling: A novel approach was used to estimate "additional births" attributed to policy changes by comparing actual birth trends to a hypothetical trend that would have occurred without policy shifts.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 53,437 medical records of pregnant women who delivered at the First Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University between January 2012 and December 2018. After exclusions for incomplete records and early gestations (<28 weeks), 51,062 records (representing 52,589 neonates) were included in the final analysis. This dataset is a single-center, retrospective collection.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Policy-Sensitive Subgroups: The study strongly suggests that older women (≥35 years) and multiparous women were the primary drivers of the "additional births" following the policy changes. This indicates that these groups were more responsive to the policy shifts, likely due to prior fertility experiences or a desire to have more children within a new policy framework.
  • Increased Case Complexity: While the overall number of births stabilized after an initial increase, care providers faced "fewer but more difficult cases." This implies a shift towards higher-risk pregnancies, necessitating more specialized care and potentially straining resources.
  • Age as a Major Risk Factor: Advanced maternal age (≥35 years) was consistently identified as a significant risk factor for various maternal complications, including preeclampsia, gestational diabetes, and increased risk of referral to the ICU. This underscores the importance of considering maternal age in risk assessment and care planning.
  • Parity's Dual Role: Parity showed a complex association with outcomes. While multiparity was linked to increased risks of placenta previa and ICU admission, it also appeared to be protective against gestational diabetes and PROM.
  • Declining CS Rate (with caveats): The Cesarean section (CS) rate generally decreased across the policy periods. However, it remained high, and advanced maternal age and multiparity were identified as strong risk factors for CS, suggesting that while the overall trend is positive, specific subgroups still face higher rates.

Key Results

  • Birth Trends: Monthly deliveries showed a stable trend from 2012-2013, followed by a marked increase after the universal two-child policy announcement, peaking in late 2014 and 2016, and then stabilizing again.
  • Demographic Shift: The proportion of pregnant women aged 35 and older, and multiparous women, increased significantly after the policy changes, while the proportion of "right-age" women (20-35 years) decreased.
  • Additional Births: The study estimated approximately 123 and 173 additional births per month following the selective and universal two-child policies, respectively, with older and multiparous mothers contributing disproportionately.
  • Maternal Complications: Advanced age was a protective factor for PROM but a risk factor for PE, ICP, GDM, PP, and ICU admission. Multiparity was a risk factor for PP and ICU admittance but protective against GDM and PROM.
  • Neonatal Outcomes: Pregnant women aged 35+ had a significantly higher risk of babies with chromosomal abnormalities (approx. 4.03 times). Multiparous women had an increased likelihood of stillbirth or macrosomia/LBW babies, but these babies were less likely to have abnormal chromosomes.
  • Sex Ratio: The neonatal sex ratio approached a more balanced status, showing no significant bias attributed to policy changes, maternal age, or parity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single-Center Study: The study was conducted at a single tertiary care center in southwestern China. While representative of that region, the findings may not be universally applicable to all of China, especially rural areas.
  • Hypothetical Birth Model Bias: The authors acknowledge that the model used to estimate hypothetical births might introduce bias, though they believe it wouldn't reverse their core conclusions.
  • Uncontrolled Covariates: Individual socioeconomic status (SES) was not controlled for in the regression models, which could potentially overestimate the policy's effect on certain outcomes.
  • Future Work: The authors recommend more individual-based studies to further understand policy impacts. They also emphasize the need for improved obstetrical services to manage increased complexity and advocate for childbearing within the optimal maternal age range. Machine learning approaches are suggested for future research to better analyze age-event curves and covariate impacts.

Summary updated

Abstract

In China, the adjustment of the family planning policy was expected to increase the number of births and trigger a change in the demographic and obstetrical background of pregnant women. The policy itself, and corresponding background variations of the pregnant mothers, might have various influences on certain birth-related characteristics. Moreover, the adaption of the medical system to the policy needs to be demonstrated. To address these issues, over 50,000 individual records from January 2012 to December 2018 were collected from a large tertiary care centre of southwest China as a representative. The monthly numbers of deliveries and births showed stabilized patterns after remarkable upward trends. Policy-sensitive women, among whom older age and multiparity were typical features, contributed considerably to the remarkable additional births. Indeed, multivariable logistic regression analysis identified the child policy and these two background characteristics as factors influencing CS (caesarean section) rate and certain pregnancy complications or adverse outcomes. After the implementation of the two-child policy, a care provider was faced with fewer but more difficult cases. Briefly speaking, more individual-based studies on family planning policy and more efforts to improve obstetrical service are needed to better guide clinical practice in the new era.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2020birth,
  author = {Xiyao Liu and Dongni Huang and Yu Wang and Yuwen Gao and Miaomiao Chen and Yuxiang Bai and Mengshi Wu and Xin Luo and Hongbo Qi},
  title = {{Birth and birth-related obstetrical characteristics in southwestern China associated with the current adjustment of family planning policy: a 7-year retrospective study}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-73039-7},
}
Figure