Birds land reliably on complex surfaces by adapting their foot-surface interactions upon contact

William R. T. Roderick, Diana D. Chin, Mark R. Cutkosky, David LentinkeLife 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Birds achieve remarkably stable landings on diverse surfaces by dynamically adjusting their foot and claw movements. This study reveals a sophisticated strategy involving predictable toe pad friction and probabilistic claw interactions, allowing them to adapt to varying perch textures and diameters, a principle applicable to robotic design.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While humans rely on engineered, flat landing surfaces for aircraft and robots, birds effortlessly land on a vast array of natural and artificial perches with varying geometries and textures. Previous research has focused on the aerial and leg dynamics of bird landings, but a significant gap existed in understanding the intricate foot-surface interactions at the moment of contact. Specifically, how birds achieve such reliable and seemingly effortless grasps on such diverse surfaces remained unclear. This paper aims to elucidate the specific foot and claw kinematics and the underlying mechanisms that enable birds to adapt their grip to complex environments.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to study Pacific parrotlets (Forpus coelestis) during landings. High-speed cameras (3000 fps) captured detailed 3D kinematics of the birds' bodies, feet, and claws. Instrumented perches, split in half and equipped with force/torque sensors, measured net and squeeze forces exerted by the feet. To characterize perch properties, 3D surface scanning was used to quantify roughness, and specialized tests were conducted to measure friction forces (toe and claw drag tests) and surface deformation (claw indentation tests). A novel dynamic grasping model was developed, integrating these experimental measurements to simulate and understand the bird's perching strategy.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from nine different perch variations: three natural (Coast Live Oak, Floss-Silk tree, Sweet Olive tree) and six man-made (birch dowels of varying diameters, foam, Teflon, sandpaper). The data generated includes:

  • High-speed video recordings of parrotlet landings.
  • Force and torque measurements from instrumented perches.
  • 3D surface scans of perch roughness.
  • Friction force measurements from toe and claw drag tests.
  • Surface deformation measurements from claw indentation tests.
  • Kinematic data of foot and claw movements.

All data files are available on Dryad.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stereotyped Aerial, Surface-Specific Ground: Birds exhibit consistent leg and wing dynamics during the aerial phase of landing, but their foot and claw movements become highly adapted to the specific perch surface upon contact.
  • Predictable Toe Pads, Probabilistic Claws: Birds leverage the reliable friction from their toe pads and combine it with the more variable, probabilistic friction from their claws. The claws actively "drag" to find surface asperities, especially when grip is more challenging.
  • Superfast Claw Movements: Parrotlet claws can exhibit incredibly rapid movements (1-2 ms) on moderately slippery surfaces. This is likely driven by stored elastic energy in tendons, allowing them to quickly find secure anchor points.
  • "Overcompensation then Relax" Strategy: Birds initially increase their grip (squeeze force and safety margins) upon landing, prioritizing safety, and then gradually relax to conserve energy once a stable grasp is established.
  • Scale Matters: The study suggests that smaller animals and robots may have an advantage on rough surfaces due to their ability to find more usable surface area with their claws. However, this trend can reverse on smoother surfaces.

Key Results

  • Parrotlets consistently use a four-phase landing strategy: aerial, absorption, anchoring, and adjustments.
  • Foot and claw kinematics diverge significantly after perch contact, adapting to perch diameter and texture.
  • Claw curling is more pronounced on perches that are harder to grasp (e.g., smaller diameter, smoother surfaces).
  • Superfast claw movements (1-2 ms) were observed, particularly on intermediate surfaces, suggesting a mechanism beyond muscle contraction alone.
  • The dynamic grasping model demonstrated that birds balance safety margin with muscular squeeze force, with safety margins being highly variable but generally positive.

Limitations and Future Work

  • The study acknowledges that the 0.25" diameter perch is not well described by the friction-based model, as muscular and structural constraints become dominant.
  • The model simplifies the bird's foot to a 2D rigid body with five contact points, not accounting for all lateral forces or torques.
  • The exact role of tactile feedback in adjusting grip is still unclear and warrants further investigation.
  • Future work could explore how these findings apply to takeoff maneuvers and how to better incorporate these avian-inspired grasping strategies into aerial robot design for enhanced versatility.

Summary updated

Abstract

Birds land on a wide range of complex surfaces, yet it is unclear how they grasp a perch reliably. Here, we show how Pacific parrotlets exhibit stereotyped leg and wing dynamics regardless of perch diameter and texture, but foot, toe, and claw kinematics become surface-specific upon touchdown. A new dynamic grasping model, which integrates our detailed measurements, reveals how birds stabilize their grasp. They combine predictable toe pad friction with probabilistic friction from their claws, which they drag to find surface asperities-dragging further when they can squeeze less. Remarkably, parrotlet claws can undergo superfast movements, within 1-2 ms, on moderately slippery surfaces to find more secure asperities when necessary. With this strategy, they first ramp up safety margins by squeezing before relaxing their grasp. The model further shows it is advantageous to be small for stable perching when high friction relative to normal force is required because claws can find more usable surface, but this trend reverses when required friction shrinks. This explains how many animals and robots may grasp complex surfaces reliably.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{roderick2019birds,
  author = {William R. T. Roderick and Diana D. Chin and Mark R. Cutkosky and David Lentink},
  title = {{Birds land reliably on complex surfaces by adapting their foot-surface interactions upon contact}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.46415},
}

Loading related content...

Figure