Bipolar polaron pair recombination in P3HT/PCBM solar cells

Alexander J. Kupijai, Konstantin M. Behringer, Michael Corazza, Suren A. Gevorgyan, Frederik C. Krebs, M. Stutzmann, Martin BrandtarXiv 2015 · DOI · arXiv

This paper, published in early 2015, represents a significant step forward in understanding the "spintronics" of organic solar cells. By applying advanced pulsed magnetic resonance techniques—originally developed for inorganic semiconductors like silicon—the authors settle a long-standing debate about how charges interact and recombine in organic photovoltaic materials.

TL;DR

Researchers used multi-frequency pulsed Electrically Detected Magnetic Resonance (pEDMR) to prove that spin-dependent charge transport in P3HT/PCBM solar cells is driven by bipolar polaron pair recombination. They successfully measured the precise coupling strength between these charges and found that parallel-spin pairs survive nearly 40 times longer than antiparallel ones.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Organic semiconductors (OSCs) are prized for their flexibility and low cost, but their efficiency is governed by complex "spin-dependent" processes. Because carbon-based materials have low spin-orbit coupling, electron spins stay "coherent" for a long time, significantly influencing how charges move or recombine.

For years, a debate persisted: is the dominant spin-dependent process unipolar (two same-sign charges forming a "bipolaron") or bipolar (a positive and negative charge recombining)? Distinguishing between these is notoriously difficult because the spectroscopic signatures of positive and negative charges (polarons) often overlap. This paper aims to provide a definitive answer for the popular P3HT/PCBM material system.

Methods

The authors utilized pulsed Electrically Detected Magnetic Resonance (pEDMR). Unlike standard EPR, which measures microwave absorption, EDMR measures changes in the device's actual photocurrent.

Key techniques included:

  • Multi-frequency addressing: Because the positive polaron ($P^+$ in P3HT) and negative polaron ($P^-$ in PCBM) have slightly different g-factors (magnetic signatures), the researchers could "talk" to them separately using different microwave frequencies.
  • Spin Locking: A technique used to observe the simultaneous driving of two coupled spins, resulting in a characteristic doubling of the Rabi frequency.
  • ELDOR & DEER: Advanced pulse sequences (Electron Double Resonance and Double Electron-Electron Resonance) used to manipulate one spin species and observe the effect on its partner.
  • Sample Variety: They compared lab-standard spin-coated cells with industrial-scale roll-to-roll printed solar cells to ensure their findings were universal.

Datasets

The study focused on:

  • P3HT/PCBM Bulk Heterojunctions: The "workhorse" material of organic solar cell research.
  • Comparison Samples: They tested both spin-coated laboratory devices and flexible, roll-to-roll printed modules from the Technical University of Denmark.
  • Reference Measurements: Light-induced EPR (LEPR) and continuous-wave EDMR were used to establish baseline spectroscopic signatures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Smoking Gun" for Bipolar Pairs: By using ELDOR, the team showed that inverting the spin of the $P^-$ polaron directly inverted the Rabi oscillation signal of the $P^+$ polaron. This is definitive proof that they are recombination partners (bipolar) rather than same-sign charges (unipolar).
  • Spin-Dependent Lifetimes: The study quantified the massive difference in recombination rates. Pairs with antiparallel spins (singlet-like) recombine rapidly, while parallel spins (triplet-like) are "spin-blocked" and must wait for a spin-flip to occur before they can recombine.
  • Nuclear Interaction: The researchers detected a subtle signal at 14.8 MHz. They identified this as the Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) of hydrogen protons in the organic polymer, showing how the electron spins are "sensing" the local chemical environment.
  • Technique Transfer: A major takeaway is that the sophisticated pulse protocols used in "classical" semiconductor physics (like those used to study defects in silicon) are perfectly applicable to the "messier" world of organic polymers.

Key Results

  • Recombination Kinetics:
    • Antiparallel recombination time ($\tau_{ap}$): ~74 µs
    • Parallel recombination time ($\tau_p$): ~3 ms
  • Coupling Strength: The exchange coupling between the two polarons was measured at approximately 2 MHz.
  • Coherence Time ($T_2$): The spin coherence lasted roughly 1.5 to 1.9 µs for both species at 10 K.
  • Industrial Relevance: The same bipolar recombination process was found in both lab-scale and industrial roll-to-roll printed cells, suggesting these physics are fundamental to the P3HT/PCBM system regardless of fabrication method.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Temperature Constraints: The most precise measurements were performed at 10 K to ensure spin stability. While the authors argue the physics should be similar at higher temperatures, room-temperature dynamics are much faster and harder to capture with current pulse sequences.
  • Coupling Distribution: The DEER data suggested a broad distribution of coupling strengths (likely due to the disordered nature of the polymer blend), which was not fully captured in their simplified numerical models.
  • Next Steps: The authors suggest using nanosecond optical pulses to study the formation of these polaron pairs in real-time, which could lead to better strategies for preventing recombination and boosting solar cell voltage.

Summary updated

Abstract

The unique properties of organic semiconductors make them versatile base materials for many applications ranging from light emitting diodes to transistors. The low spin-orbit coupling typical for carbon-based materials and the resulting long spin lifetimes give rise to a large influence of the electron spin on charge transport which can be exploited in spintronic devices or to improve solar cell efficiencies. Magnetic resonance techniques are particularly helpful to elucidate the microscopic structure of paramagnetic states in semiconductors as well as the transport processes they are involved in. However, in organic devices the nature of the dominant spin-dependent processes is still subject to considerable debate. Using multi-frequency pulsed electrically detected magnetic resonance (pEDMR), we show that the spin-dependent response of P3HT/PCBM solar cells at low temperatures is governed by bipolar polaron pair recombination involving the positive and negative polarons in P3HT and PCBM, respectively, thus excluding a unipolar bipolaron formation as the main contribution to the spin-dependent charge transfer in this temperature regime. Moreover the polaron-polaron coupling strength and the recombination times of polaron pairs with parallel and antiparallel spins are determined. Our results demonstrate that the pEDMR pulse sequences recently developed for inorganic semiconductor devices can very successfully be transferred to the study of spin and charge transport in organic semiconductors, in particular when the different polarons can be distinguished spectrally.
BibTeX
@misc{kupijai2015bipolar,
  author = {Alexander J. Kupijai and Konstantin M. Behringer and Michael Corazza and Suren A. Gevorgyan and Frederik C. Krebs and M. Stutzmann and Martin Brandt},
  title = {{Bipolar polaron pair recombination in P3HT/PCBM solar cells}},
  year = {2015},
  eprint = {1505.01411},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1505.01411},
}

Loading related content...

Figure