TL;DR
This paper investigates how the molecular chaperone BiP (an Hsp70 protein) communicates between its nucleotide-binding and substrate-binding domains. By mutating a key residue (R197) and its interacting partners in the substrate-binding domain, the researchers found that charge at R197 is crucial for BiP's function, influencing its ATPase activity, substrate binding/release, and overall cellular protein folding and assembly.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Molecular chaperones, like BiP, are essential cellular machinery that help proteins fold correctly, prevent aggregation, and facilitate protein transport. Hsp70s, a major class of chaperones, have two main functional domains: an N-terminal nucleotide-binding domain (NBD) that controls their activity by binding ATP or ADP, and a C-terminal substrate-binding domain (SBD) that interacts with unfolded proteins. The precise mechanism by which these two domains communicate and how cochaperones, such as DnaJ proteins, regulate this process has been a long-standing question. Specifically, how DnaJ proteins accelerate the ATPase activity of Hsp70s to stabilize protein interactions was not fully understood. This paper aims to elucidate the interdomain communication within BiP and the role of cochaperones in this process, focusing on a specific residue (R197) and its interaction partners.
Methods
The researchers employed a combination of biochemical and cell-based assays:
- Site-Directed Mutagenesis: They created specific mutations in the hamster BiP gene, altering the amino acid at position 197 (R197H, R197A, R197E) and three glutamic acid residues in the SBD (E536R, E537R, E539R, and a triple mutant TM).
- Recombinant Protein Expression and Purification: Wild-type and mutant BiP proteins, as well as fragments like the NBD, were expressed in E. coli and purified for in vitro studies.
- ATPase Assays: They measured the rate at which BiP proteins hydrolyze ATP, both basally and when stimulated by a DnaJ protein fragment (J domain) or a model peptide substrate.
- Protease Sensitivity Assays: This technique was used to probe conformational changes in BiP upon nucleotide binding. Different nucleotide states (ATP or ADP) confer distinct protease resistance patterns, revealing whether BiP is in an "open" (ATP-bound) or "closed" (ADP-bound) conformation.
- Co-immunoprecipitation Assays: They assessed the ability of mutant BiP proteins to bind to Ig heavy chains (a model substrate) in vitro and their release upon ATP addition.
- Cellular Assays (Transient Transfection): COS-1 cells were used to express BiP mutants along with Ig light chains or Ig heavy and light chains.
- Ig Light Chain Folding: Cells were pulse-labeled and chased to assess how well BiP mutants facilitated the oxidative folding of Ig light chains.
- Ig Assembly and Secretion: Cells were pulse-labeled and chased to monitor the assembly of Ig heavy and light chains into functional antibodies and their subsequent secretion.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on in vitro biochemical assays and cell-based experiments using transfected constructs, rather than large-scale datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Charge Matters at R197: The positive charge at residue 197 in BiP's NBD is critical. Reducing this positive charge (from Arginine to Histidine, Alanine, or Glutamic Acid) progressively impairs BiP's ability to interact with DnaJ proteins and destabilizes the interaction between the NBD and SBD.
- Interdomain Communication is Charge-Dependent: The interaction between the NBD and SBD is not static. The positive charge at R197 appears to help "hold" the SBD in an open conformation when BiP is bound to ATP, preventing premature ATPase activity.
- DnaJ Proteins Act as "Wedges": The study proposes that DnaJ proteins, by interacting with R197, physically push the SBD away from the NBD. This action likely relieves the suppressive effect of the SBD on the NBD, thereby stimulating ATP hydrolysis and promoting the "closing" of the SBD onto the substrate.
- SBD Mutations Mimic R197 Effects: Mutating specific negatively charged residues in the SBD (E536, E537, E539) to positively charged arginines also disrupted interdomain communication and mimicked some of the effects seen with R197 mutations, further supporting the idea of an electrostatic interaction.
- R197 is a Hub for Multiple Interactions: This single residue is crucial for interactions with both DnaJ cochaperones and the SBD itself, highlighting its central role in regulating BiP's ATPase cycle and function.
Key Results
- R197 mutants fail to bind ERdj3 J domain: Recombinant BiP mutants R197H, R197A, and R197E showed no detectable binding to a recombinant ERdj3 J domain.
- R197 mutations alter ATPase activity and conformation:
- R197H showed no stimulation of ATPase activity by ERdj3.
- R197A and R197E showed increased basal ATPase activity, with the negative charge (R197E) leading to the highest basal activity.
- Protease sensitivity assays revealed that R197A and R197E mutants failed to adopt the ATP-induced "open" conformation (60 kDa fragment protection), remaining in a "closed" state.
- R197 mutants are partially defective in substrate release: While R197H showed release similar to wild-type BiP, R197A and R197E were partially defective in ATP-mediated release of Ig heavy chains in vitro.
- R197 mutants show impaired cellular function:
- R197E was significantly defective in facilitating Ig light chain folding and Ig assembly/secretion in vivo.
- R197A was also impaired, though less so than R197E.
- R197H showed near wild-type levels of function in these cellular assays.
- SBD triple mutant (TM) mimics R197E effects: The TM mutant (E536R, E537R, E539R) exhibited significantly higher basal ATPase activity, poor stimulation by J domain or peptide, and defective substrate release in vitro, similar to R197E.
Limitations and Future Work
- Absence of ATP-bound Hsp70 Structure: The authors acknowledge that their interpretations are made in the absence of a full-length crystal structure of an ATP-bound Hsp70 protein. They rely on existing structures of ADP-bound forms and related proteins (like Ssc1) to inform their model.
- In Vitro vs. In Vivo Correlation: While the in vitro findings strongly correlate with in vivo functional defects, the precise molecular events in the complex cellular environment can be challenging to fully replicate.
- Future Directions: The study suggests that further investigation into the specific electrostatic interactions between R197 and the SBD, as well as the role of other conserved residues, could provide deeper insights. Understanding how these interdomain interactions are fine-tuned by different cochaperones and substrates remains an important area for future research. The findings also open avenues for exploring how mutations in these critical residues might contribute to disease states associated with protein misfolding.
Summary updated