Biotic interactions shape the realised niche of toxic cyanobacteria

Pinelopi Ntetsika, Stefanie Merkli, Ewa Merz, Marta Reyes, Benno Käch, Stephan B. Munch, Stuart R. Dennis, Marco Baity‐Jesi, Francesco PomatibioRxiv 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Cyanobacterial blooms, a growing threat to freshwater ecosystems, are not solely driven by temperature and nutrients. This study reveals that interactions with other plankton species fundamentally alter the conditions under which these blooms occur, shifting temperature and nutrient thresholds significantly. This highlights the critical need to incorporate biotic interactions into predictive models for better bloom management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cyanobacterial blooms are a major ecological and economic problem, exacerbated by climate change and eutrophication. While we know that temperature and nutrient availability are key drivers, our ability to predict when and where these blooms will occur remains limited. This is because current models often overlook the complex web of interactions between cyanobacteria and other organisms in the water. The authors argue that this "biotic ignorance" is a critical knowledge gap, preventing us from accurately forecasting bloom dynamics and developing effective management strategies. They aim to demonstrate how these biotic interactions fundamentally shape the "realized niche" of cyanobacteria – the actual environmental conditions they occupy, which is a subset of their potential niche.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated approach using high-frequency, daily monitoring data from Lake Greifensee, Switzerland, spanning five years.

  • State-Space Reconstruction (SSR) and Multiview Distance Regularised S-map (MDR S-map): These advanced modeling techniques were used to analyze the complex, non-linear dynamics of plankton communities. Unlike traditional models, SSR and S-maps can capture time-varying interactions and are well-suited for noisy, high-dimensional ecological data.
  • Convergent Cross-Mapping (CCM): This method was used to identify and quantify the strength of causal links between environmental variables (both abiotic and biotic) and cyanobacterial net growth rates (nGR). They specifically looked for daily-scale couplings that went beyond seasonal patterns.
  • Partial Dependence Plots: These were used to visualize how specific biotic and abiotic factors influence cyanobacterial growth, allowing the researchers to isolate the effects of individual interactions.
  • Zero Net Growth Isocline Analysis: This technique was used to determine the temperature and phosphate thresholds at which cyanobacteria transition from negative to positive growth, effectively defining the conditions for bloom formation.

Datasets

The study utilized a comprehensive dataset from Lake Greifensee, Switzerland, collected between March 2019 and December 2023. This included:

  • Environmental Data: Daily measurements of water temperature, photosynthetically active radiation (PAR), dissolved oxygen, nitrate, ammonium, and phosphate. Meteorological data (wind speed, precipitation, air pressure) were also included.
  • Plankton Community Data: High-resolution, daily time series of the abundance of 83 plankton taxa, including cyanobacteria, phytoplankton, and zooplankton, captured using an automated underwater microscope.

This dataset represents a novel, high-frequency, multi-year record of a complex plankton community, allowing for the detailed analysis of dynamic biotic interactions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Biotic Interactions are Not Just Noise, They're the Signal: The study strongly suggests that biotic interactions are not secondary factors but fundamentally shape cyanobacterial bloom dynamics, often more so than seasonal abiotic changes on a daily scale.
  • Realized Niche is Dynamic and Biotically Driven: Cyanobacteria don't just occupy a fixed niche based on temperature and nutrients; their actual environmental requirements are constantly being reshaped by their interactions with other plankton.
  • Facilitation Can Lead to Unexpected Blooms: Certain phytoplankton groups (like chrysophytes) can facilitate cyanobacterial growth, allowing blooms to occur even at unexpectedly low nutrient levels.
  • Grazers as Bloom Regulators: Zooplankton, particularly rotifers and copepods, can act as significant inhibitors, raising the environmental thresholds required for blooms to form.
  • Taxon-Specific Interactions: The effects of biotic interactions are not uniform; they vary significantly between different cyanobacterial species (e.g., Microcystis vs. Dolichospermum) and the interacting plankton groups.

Key Results

  • Significant Shift in Thresholds: Biotic interactions were found to shift temperature thresholds by up to 13°C and phosphorus requirements by over 20 µg/L, which is substantial enough to determine bloom occurrence.
  • Microcystis Expansion: For Microcystis, many zooplankton groups facilitated growth, effectively expanding its realized niche.
  • Dolichospermum Constrained: In contrast, Dolichospermum's realized niche was predominantly constrained by biotic interactions, with most groups acting as inhibitors.
  • Predictive Power: The developed S-map models consistently outperformed a simple persistence model in forecasting cyanobacterial growth rates over extended horizons, demonstrating their ability to capture underlying system dynamics.
  • Key Interacting Groups Identified: Rotifers and chrysophytes were identified as particularly influential groups, acting as strong inhibitors and facilitators, respectively.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Microbial Ecology Unexplored: The study acknowledges that some aspects of microbial ecology, such as the role of parasites and heterotrophic bacteria, remain unexplored and could influence nGR.
  • Context Dependency: Cyanobacterial responses are context-dependent, and future work should consider how these interactions might change in different lakes or under novel perturbations like species invasions.
  • Broader Application: While the findings are from Lake Greifensee, the authors believe the fundamental mechanisms of biotic modification of environmental thresholds are universally applicable to freshwater systems.
  • Monitoring and Management Integration: The authors propose integrating high-frequency plankton data into monitoring programs and predictive models to improve forecasting and develop targeted interventions, such as manipulating key planktonic groups.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Cyanobacterial blooms increasingly threaten vital freshwater ecosystems, with harmful impacts exacerbated by climate change and eutrophication. Despite extensive research on temperature and nutrient effects, our predictive capacity remains limited. We propose that this limitation stems from insufficient understanding of how biotic interactions modify cyanobacterial responses to abiotic conditions. Using five years of daily monitoring data from a eutrophic lake and state-space reconstruction modelling, we show that interactions with co-occurring plankton species fundamentally reshape the realised niche of bloom-forming cyanobacteria. Biotic interactions shift temperature thresholds by up to 13°C and phosphorus requirements by over 20 μg/L—effects substantial enough to determine whether environmental conditions support or prevent blooms in Microcystis and Dolichospermum . Grazing inhibits bloom formation across cyanobacterial taxa, while facilitation by other phytoplankton may allow blooms at unexpectedly low temperatures and phosphate concentrations. These findings address a fundamental research gap—how species interactions shape realised niches in natural systems—while offering practical insights for bloom management. By integrating biotic interactions into monitoring programs and predictive models, we can improve forecasting accuracy and develop targeted interventions that complement traditional nutrient control approaches. These findings parallel recent advances in ecology suggesting the fundamental role of biotic interactions in mediating species’ responses to environmental change.
BibTeX
@misc{ntetsika2025biotic,
  author = {Pinelopi Ntetsika and Stefanie Merkli and Ewa Merz and Marta Reyes and Benno Käch and Stephan B. Munch and Stuart R. Dennis and Marco Baity‐Jesi and Francesco Pomati},
  title = {{Biotic interactions shape the realised niche of toxic cyanobacteria}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1101/2025.04.16.649070},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure