Biophysical models reveal the relative importance of transporter proteins and impermeant anions in chloride homeostasis

Kira M. Düsterwald, Christopher Brian Currin, Richard J. Burman, Colin J. Akerman, Alan R. Kay, Joseph V. RaimondoeLife 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses biophysical modeling and experimental validation to investigate the determinants of neuronal chloride (Cl⁻) homeostasis. It reveals that while impermeant anions play a role in setting intracellular Cl⁻ concentration, cation-chloride cotransporters (CCCs) are the primary modulators of the Cl⁻ driving force, crucial for inhibitory signaling.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fast synaptic inhibition in the brain relies on the flow of chloride ions (Cl⁻) across neuronal membranes. This flow is driven by the "Cl⁻ driving force," which is influenced by the concentration gradient of Cl⁻ and the neuron's membrane potential. For a long time, it was thought that a group of proteins called cation-chloride cotransporters (CCCs) were the main players in setting this driving force. However, recent research has proposed that impermeant anions – charged molecules that can't easily cross the cell membrane – might be more important. This creates a debate: are CCCs or impermeant anions the key regulators of neuronal inhibition? This paper aims to resolve this by building a comprehensive biophysical model and testing its predictions experimentally.

Methods

The authors developed a sophisticated biophysical model of a neuron based on the "pump-leak" formulation. This model incorporates several key cellular components:

  • Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase: The primary active transporter responsible for maintaining ion gradients and cell volume.
  • Ion Conductances: Passive channels for K⁺, Na⁺, and Cl⁻.
  • Cation-Chloride Cotransporters (CCCs): Specifically modeled KCC2, which transports K⁺ and Cl⁻.
  • Impermeant Anions (X⁻): Represented as a group with a defined mean charge and concentration.
  • Cell Volume Dynamics: Modeled to account for osmotic water fluxes.

They employed both numerical simulations (solving differential equations over time) and novel analytic solutions to explore the model's behavior across a wide range of parameters. To validate their model's predictions, they used gramicidin perforated patch-clamp recordings in mouse and rat neurons. This technique allows for the measurement of membrane potential and chloride reversal potential (EGABA, a proxy for the Cl⁻ driving force) while minimizing disruption to intracellular ion concentrations. They also used electroporation of anionic dextrans to experimentally manipulate intracellular impermeant anion concentrations and optogenetic activation of GABAergic interneurons.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CCCs are the primary drivers of Cl⁻ driving force: The models strongly indicate that CCCs, particularly KCC2, are the key regulators of the Cl⁻ driving force. Their activity directly influences the Cl⁻ reversal potential, which in turn dictates the driving force for inhibitory signaling.
  • Impermeant anions have a limited role in driving force: While impermeant anions can influence intracellular Cl⁻ concentration ([Cl⁻]ᵢ) by affecting cell volume and indirectly influencing active transport, their direct impact on the Cl⁻ driving force is negligible under physiological conditions.
  • The Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase is crucial for homeostasis, but not fine-tuning inhibition: The Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase is essential for maintaining basic ionic gradients and cell volume. However, above a certain activity level, its role in fine-tuning the Cl⁻ driving force is minimal.
  • Local CCC activity can create regional differences: In a multi-compartment model, localized changes in KCC2 activity can create regional differences in Cl⁻ driving force, but this effect is dependent on the diffusion rate of Cl⁻.
  • Reconciling conflicting experimental findings: The study provides a framework that explains why some experiments suggest a strong role for impermeant anions, while others highlight the importance of CCCs.

Key Results

  • Model Validation: The biophysical model accurately reproduced known relationships, such as the dependence of membrane potential on extracellular K⁺ concentration.
  • CCC Blockade: Experimental blockade of KCC2 with furosemide significantly reduced the GABAAR driving force, consistent with model predictions.
  • Impermeant Anion Manipulation:
    • Changing the concentration of impermeant anions had minimal persistent effects on the Cl⁻ driving force, primarily affecting cell volume.
  • Modifying the charge of impermeant anions could shift the Cl⁻ reversal potential but had negligible effects on the driving force due to compensatory shifts in membrane potential.
  • Experimental addition of anionic dextrans confirmed that while EGABA could be shifted, the Cl⁻ driving force remained largely unaffected.
  • KCC2 Activity and Driving Force: A meta-analysis of experimental data showed a strong correlation between KCC2 expression levels and Cl⁻ driving force, but not membrane potential.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The model uses a single-compartment representation for much of the analysis, which may not fully capture the complexity of neuronal morphology. While a multi-compartment model was used to explore local effects, further refinement could be beneficial. The model also does not explicitly include bicarbonate ions, which can contribute to acute depolarizing effects of GABA.
  • Water Permeability: While the model accounts for water flux, the assumption of water permeability across the phospholipid bilayer might not hold true for all neurons, potentially affecting the time course of volume changes.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest further investigation into the role of other CCCs (e.g., NKCC1) and the interplay between different ion transporters and channels. Exploring the impact of these mechanisms in specific neuronal populations and during different developmental stages is also a promising avenue. The findings also open doors for identifying new therapeutic targets for neurological disorders linked to altered chloride homeostasis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fast synaptic inhibition in the nervous system depends on the transmembrane flux of Cl<sup>-</sup> ions based on the neuronal Cl<sup>-</sup> driving force. Established theories regarding the determinants of Cl<sup>-</sup> driving force have recently been questioned. Here, we present biophysical models of Cl<sup>-</sup> homeostasis using the pump-leak model. Using numerical and novel analytic solutions, we demonstrate that the Na<sup>+</sup>/K<sup>+</sup>-ATPase, ion conductances, impermeant anions, electrodiffusion, water fluxes and cation-chloride cotransporters (CCCs) play roles in setting the Cl<sup>-</sup> driving force. Our models, together with experimental validation, show that while impermeant anions can contribute to setting [Cl<sup>-</sup>]<sub>i</sub> in neurons, they have a negligible effect on the driving force for Cl<sup>-</sup> locally and cell-wide. In contrast, we demonstrate that CCCs are well-suited for modulating Cl<sup>-</sup> driving force and hence inhibitory signaling in neurons. Our findings reconcile recent experimental findings and provide a framework for understanding the interplay of different chloride regulatory processes in neurons.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dusterwald2018biophysical,
  author = {Kira M. Düsterwald and Christopher Brian Currin and Richard J. Burman and Colin J. Akerman and Alan R. Kay and Joseph V. Raimondo},
  title = {{Biophysical models reveal the relative importance of transporter proteins and impermeant anions in chloride homeostasis}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.39575},
}
Figure