Biomechanics do not predict perceptual and cognitive consequences of force augmentation

Maria Molina-Sanchez, Francesco Missiroli, Viktorija Pavalkyte, Mabel Ziman, Julien Russ, Maggie Szymanska, Noham Wolpe, Rani Moran, Lorenzo Masia, Tamar R. MakinarXiv 2026 · arXiv

TL;DR

While wearable exosuits successfully reduce the physical strain of lifting, these biomechanical benefits do not translate directly into how users perceive, learn, or make decisions. This study reveals that the cognitive and perceptual consequences of force augmentation are complex, often decoupled from muscle activity, and heavily influenced by a user's very first experience with the device.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The development of wearable robotics, like soft exosuits, has traditionally focused on "reducing the load"—lowering metabolic costs and muscle activation (EMG). However, human performance is not just about raw physical output; it requires accurate perception of the environment, the ability to adapt to changing conditions, and the cognitive weighing of effort against reward.

The researchers identified a critical gap: we don't fully understand how "making an action easier" affects the brain's internal models. If an object feels lighter because of a suit, does the brain update its expectations of the world, or does it become less flexible in learning new rules? This paper investigates whether the well-documented biomechanical benefits of augmentation actually lead to predictable improvements in perception and cognition.

Methods

The study employed a within-subject, two-session design with 32 healthy participants. In one session, they used a bimanual soft exosuit that assisted elbow flexion; in the other, the suit was worn but powered off. Crucially, the order of these sessions was counterbalanced to test for the effects of initial experience.

Participants performed three distinct tasks:

  1. Weight Estimation: Lifting boxes of different sizes and masses to test weight perception and the "size-weight illusion" (where smaller objects feel heavier than larger ones of the same mass).
  2. Probabilistic Learning: A volatile task where participants had to predict if a box would be "heavy" or "light" based on visual cues, with the rules reversing periodically.
  3. Effort-Reward Decision-Making: Choosing between a low-effort/low-reward lift and a high-effort/high-reward lift to see how augmentation alters the subjective cost of work.

The team recorded surface EMG from the biceps, triceps, deltoids, and lower back to quantify physical effort, alongside verbal ratings of perceived weight and fatigue.

Datasets

The study relied on primary data collected from 32 healthy adults (19 female, mean age ~24.5). The researchers did not use external public datasets but generated a rich internal dataset of EMG amplitudes, perceptual ratings, and choice behavior across 70+ trials per task.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "First Impression" Anchor: The effect of the exosuit on perceived weight was dominated by session order. If participants started without the suit, the suit made things feel significantly lighter later. If they started with the suit, the perceptual benefit was muted. This suggests that our first interaction with a new technology sets a persistent "reference point" that shapes all subsequent experiences.
  • Cognitive Flexibility Trade-off: Surprisingly, assistance actually reduced behavioral flexibility. In the learning task, participants were slower to adapt when old rules were reintroduced while wearing the suit.
  • Perception vs. Reality: Perceived fatigue did not directly track muscle activity. While the suit reduced overall fatigue, the rate at which fatigue accumulated was actually faster in the assisted condition. This was partly because the reduced physical cost encouraged participants to choose heavier, higher-reward loads more often.
  • Biomechanical Decoupling: The most significant "aha moment" is that the 31% reduction in biceps activity did not lead to a 31% change in how heavy things felt or how hard people were willing to work. The brain's interpretation of the "assisted" signal is not a linear reflection of the muscle's relief.

Key Results

  • Physical Benefit: The exosuit reliably reduced biceps EMG activity by approximately 31% across all lifting tasks.
  • Weight Perception: Assistance reduced perceived weight, but this was strongly shaped by initial experience (Interaction: $F(1, 1591) = 121.98, p < .001$). The size-weight illusion itself remained robust regardless of assistance.
Figure 1. Effects of exosuit assistance on weight perception.
  • Learning Dynamics: Accuracy in the volatile environment increased more steeply in the unassisted condition compared to the assisted condition for specific contingencies ($p < .001$), indicating a selective reduction in learning flexibility under augmentation.
Figure 2. Effects of exosuit assistance on learning and adaptation.
  • Decision-Making: Participants who started with the assisted session maintained high-effort choices longer, whereas those who started unassisted showed a decline in high-effort choices over time, even when the suit was eventually provided.
Figure 3. Effects of exosuit assistance on perceived fatigue and effort-based decision-making.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study looked at a single experimental session. It remains unknown whether these perceptual and cognitive "lags" persist after weeks or months of training. As users become "embodied" with the device, their internal models might eventually align with the biomechanical benefits.

Future research should focus on longitudinal studies and explore these effects in clinical populations (e.g., stroke rehabilitation) or high-stakes occupational settings where accurate perception and rapid learning are mission-critical. The takeaway for engineers is clear: evaluating an exosuit based on EMG alone is only telling half the story.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wearable force-augmentation technologies, including exoskeletons and soft exosuits, are being developed for occupational and rehabilitation settings to enhance performance by reducing the muscular demands of movements. Yet enhanced performance also requires users to perceive the environment accurately, adapt to changing conditions, and decide whether actions are worth their physical cost. We used an elbow-assisting exosuit to investigate the physiological, perceptual and cognitive consequences of force augmentation during lifting. We assessed weight perception, adaptation in a volatile environment, and effort-based decision-making with and without assistance. While assistance reduced muscle activity, its behavioural outcomes did not simply reflect this biomechanical change. Assistance reduced perceived weight, but this effect was strongly shaped by participants' initial experience. Assistance also selectively reduced adaptation to changing environmental contingencies. Finally, reducing the muscular demands of lifting did not translate straightforwardly into how demanding the action felt or whether participants chose to perform it: differences in effort-based decisions were shaped by initial experience rather than simply tracking reductions in muscle activity or perceived fatigue. Together, we show that the perceptual and cognitive consequences of force augmentation cannot be inferred from its biomechanical benefits alone. Effective augmentation therefore requires perceptual and cognitive outcomes to be evaluated alongside physical performance.
BibTeX
@misc{molinasanchez2026biomechanics,
  author = {Maria Molina-Sanchez and Francesco Missiroli and Viktorija Pavalkyte and Mabel Ziman and Julien Russ and Maggie Szymanska and Noham Wolpe and Rani Moran and Lorenzo Masia and Tamar R. Makin},
  title = {{Biomechanics do not predict perceptual and cognitive consequences of force augmentation}},
  year = {2026},
  eprint = {2610.41679},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.41679},
}
Figure