Biomechanical effects of the medial meniscus horizontal tear and the resection strategy on the rabbit knee joint under resting state: finite element analysis

An‐qi Xue, Zuming Mao, Xiaoyu Zhu, Qiang Yang, Peichen Wang, Zimu Mao, Mingze Du, Xu Ma, Dong Jiang, Yubo Fan, Feng ZhaoFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Biomechanical changes following meniscal tears and subsequent surgeries can accelerate the onset of osteoarthritis. This study utilizes finite element analysis (FEA) to investigate the biomechanical effects of horizontal medial meniscus tears and various resection strategies on a rabbit knee joint. Seven models were established: intact medial meniscus (IMM), horizontal tear (HTMM), superior leaf partial meniscectomy (SLPM), inferior leaf partial meniscectomy (ILPM), double-leaf partial meniscectomy (DLPM), subtotal meniscectomy (STM), and total meniscectomy (TTM). Results indicate that while a horizontal tear itself has minimal impact on joint stress at rest, the choice of surgical resection strategy significantly alters load distribution. Among the strategies, SLPM showed the minimal effect on joint stress, suggesting it is the preferred approach for preserving joint health.

Introduction

The meniscus is a critical shock absorber in the knee, responsible for distributing weight and protecting articular cartilage. Horizontal tears—where the tissue splits into superior and inferior layers—account for approximately 35% of meniscal injuries. If left untreated or managed with inappropriate surgical techniques, these tears can trigger a cycle of mechanical instability leading to osteoarthritis. This paper provides a systematic biomechanical comparison of different surgical "trimming" strategies to identify which approach best preserves joint function.

Methods

The researchers developed a high-fidelity 3D Finite Element (FE) model based on high-resolution MRI (0.1mm slices) of a healthy male New Zealand rabbit knee.

  • The Models: Seven distinct scenarios were simulated: Intact (IMM), Horizontal Tear (HTMM), Superior Leaf removal (SLPM), Inferior Leaf removal (ILPM), Double-leaf removal (DLPM), Subtotal (STM), and Total Meniscectomy (TTM).
  • Physics and Simulation: Cartilage and bone were modeled as linear elastic isotropic materials, while ligaments were treated as nonlinear hyperelastic (Neo-Hookean). An axial load of 40N was applied at a 45° flexion angle to simulate a resting state.
  • Software: Reconstruction was performed in Mimics 21.0, with mechanical simulations executed in ABAQUS 2021.
Finite element models of the rabbit knee joint and various medial meniscus conditions, including intact (IMM), horizontal tear (HTMM), and various resection strategies (SLPM, ILPM, DLPM, STM, and STM).

Key Insights and Results

The Stability of Horizontal Tears

The study found that a horizontal tear (HTMM) only increased the axial load on the tibial cartilage by 1.6% compared to an intact knee. This is attributed to the preservation of "hoop stress"; as long as the tear does not reach the outer peripheral edge, the meniscus continues to distribute loads effectively.

Comparing Resection Strategies

When surgery is required, the specific tissue removed drastically changes the joint's mechanical environment:

  • Superior Leaf (SLPM): This strategy had the minimal effect on joint stress, making it the most favorable surgical option.
  • Inferior Leaf (ILPM): Removing the bottom leaf decreased the load-bearing capacity of the meniscus by 42.2%, indicating the inferior layer is more vital for the meniscus-tibial interface.
  • Double-leaf (DLPM): Aggressive "cleaning up" of both layers increased the maximum von Mises stress on the remaining meniscus by 156.5%, potentially accelerating tissue failure.
  • Subtotal (STM): This resulted in the meniscus bearing almost no load (97% decrease), shifting the entire burden to the underlying cartilage.

The Importance of Root Preservation

Preserving the posterior root and the peripheral rim is essential. Once these structures are compromised, as seen in subtotal or total meniscectomies, the meniscus loses its ability to resist radial displacement, leaving the cartilage vulnerable to damaging forces.

Discussion and Limitations

While this study provides valuable insights into surgical planning, it is limited by its focus on a static "resting state" at 45° flexion. Real-world activities involve dynamic loads that may reveal different stress patterns. Additionally, the use of linear elastic models for cartilage does not account for its poroelastic nature, where fluid movement affects long-term wear. Future research should incorporate dynamic gait cycles and explore kinetic loading to further validate these findings.

Conclusion

Horizontal meniscal tears that do not compromise the peripheral rim have minimal biomechanical impact on the rabbit knee joint at rest. However, if surgical intervention is necessary, Superior Leaf Partial Meniscectomy (SLPM) is recommended over other strategies to minimize joint stress. Surgeons should prioritize preserving the posterior root and the remaining peripheral edge to maintain the mechanical integrity of the joint.

Summary updated

Abstract

The biomechanical changes following meniscal tears and surgery could lead to or accelerate the occurrence of osteoarthritis. The aim of this study was to investigate the biomechanical effects of horizontal meniscal tears and different resection strategies on a rabbit knee joint by finite element analysis and to provide reference for animal experiments and clinical research. Magnetic resonance images of a male rabbit knee joint were used to establish a finite element model with intact menisci under resting state. A medial meniscal horizontal tear was set involving 2/3 width of a meniscus. Seven models were finally established, including intact medial meniscus (IMM), horizontal tear of the medial meniscus (HTMM), superior leaf partial meniscectomy (SLPM), inferior leaf partial meniscectomy (ILPM), double-leaf partial meniscectomy (DLPM), subtotal meniscectomy (STM), and total meniscectomy (TTM). The axial load transmitted from femoral cartilage to menisci and tibial cartilage, the maximum von Mises stress and the maximum contact pressure on the menisci and cartilages, the contact area between cartilage to menisci and cartilage to cartilage, and absolute value of the meniscal displacement were analyzed and evaluated. The results showed that the HTMM had little effect on the medial tibial cartilage. After the HTMM, the axial load, maximum von Mises stress and maximum contact pressure on the medial tibial cartilage increased 1.6%, 1.2%, and 1.4%, compared with the IMM. Among different meniscectomy strategies, the axial load and the maximum von Mises stress on the medial menisci varied greatly. After the HTMM, SLPM, ILPM, DLPM, and STM, the axial load on medial menisci decreased 11.4%, 42.2%, 35.4% 48.7%, and 97.0%, respectively; the maximum von Mises stress on medial menisci increased 53.9%, 62.6%, 156.5%, and 65.5%, respectively, and the STM decreased 57.8%, compared to IMM. The radial displacement of the middle body of the medial meniscal was larger than any other part in all the models. The HTMM led to few biomechanical changes in the rabbit knee joint. The SLPM showed minimal effect on joint stress among all resection strategies. It is recommended to preserve the posterior root and the remaining peripheral edge of the meniscus during surgery for an HTMM.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xue2023biomechanical,
  author = {An‐qi Xue and Zuming Mao and Xiaoyu Zhu and Qiang Yang and Peichen Wang and Zimu Mao and Mingze Du and Xu Ma and Dong Jiang and Yubo Fan and Feng Zhao},
  title = {{Biomechanical effects of the medial meniscus horizontal tear and the resection strategy on the rabbit knee joint under resting state: finite element analysis}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fbioe.2023.1164922},
}
Figure