Biomechanical analysis of the patient-specific appropriate correction angle for cervical kyphosis in multilevel anterior cervical discectomy and fusion: a finite element analysis

Ru-Yuan Lv, Xu Ma, Hongyu Chen, Zuming Mao, Rongkang Li, Yiling Zheng, Feifei Zhou, Feng ZhaoJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers used patient-specific finite element (FE) modeling to discover that there is a "sweet spot" for correcting neck curvature during spinal surgery. By analyzing three clinical cases, they found that moderate correction angles—rather than extreme or "perfect" anatomical ones—significantly reduce mechanical stress on implants and adjacent discs, potentially lowering the risk of long-term complications like implant subsidence and adjacent segment disease.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cervical kyphosis is a condition where the natural forward curve of the neck is lost, often leading to pain and neurological issues. The standard surgical fix is Multilevel Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion (ACDF), where surgeons remove damaged discs, insert "cages," and fix them with plates and screws.

However, there is a major clinical debate: How much should the curve be corrected? * Too little correction might fail to relieve pressure on the spinal cord. * Too much correction (over-lordosis) can put massive mechanical stress on the vertebrae and the segments of the spine directly above and below the surgery site.

Currently, surgeons often rely on intuition or "theoretical ideals" rather than personalized biomechanical data. This paper seeks to provide a quantitative method for determining the optimal, patient-specific correction angle.

Methods

The authors employed Finite Element Analysis (FEA), a computational technique used to simulate how complex structures (like the human spine) respond to physical loads.

  1. Model Construction: Using CT scans from three patients with severe kyphosis (Cobb angles > 40°), they built high-fidelity 3D models of the C1-C7 cervical spine.
  2. Virtual Surgery: For each patient, they created six different versions of the model, each with a different "correction angle" ranging from the patient's original deformed state to a corrected state (e.g., from 40° down to -10°).
  3. Simulation: They applied standard physiological loads (73.6 N axial load combined with 1 Nm moments) to simulate movements like flexion, extension, and rotation.
  4. Weighted Evaluation Scheme: This is the study's novel contribution. Rather than looking at just one metric, they created a composite score based on:
  5. Cage-vertebra interface stress (25%): Predicts if the implant will sink into the bone (subsidence).
  6. Adjacent segment disc stress (25%): Predicts future degeneration of nearby discs.
  7. Adjacent segment Range of Motion (20%): Measures how much the rest of the neck has to "overwork."
    • Other factors (30%): Including stress on facet joints, plates, and screws.

Datasets

The study used patient-specific clinical data rather than a large-scale public dataset:

  • Primary Data: High-resolution CT imaging from three specific patients (Patient A: 18yo male; Patient B: 52yo female; Patient C: 74yo female) representing different types of kyphosis (idiopathic, iatrogenic, and degenerative).
  • Validation Data: A "healthy" model was built from a 46-year-old male with normal cervical curvature to ensure the FEA results matched established biomechanical benchmarks in existing literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "U-Shaped" Stress Trend: The most critical finding was that mechanical stress does not change linearly with the correction angle. Instead, it follows a U-shaped curve. Both the original deformed state and the "over-corrected" state showed high stress. The "bottom" of the U represents the biomechanical sweet spot.
  • Anatomical vs. Biomechanical Ideal: Interestingly, the "perfect" anatomical curve (usually around -10° to -20°) wasn't always the best for the patient. For Patient A, a moderate 10° angle was superior to a "normal" -10° angle because the latter caused a massive spike in implant stress.
  • Adjacent Segment Compensation: The models showed that if the correction angle is too low, the segments above the surgery (C2-C3) become hyper-mobile in flexion. If the angle is too high, they become hyper-mobile in extension. Moderate angles balance this mobility, likely slowing down the "wear and tear" that leads to secondary surgeries.

Key Results

  • Optimal Angles Identified: Based on the weighted scores, the recommended correction angles were 10° for Patient A, 17° for Patient B, and 0° for Patient C.
  • Stress Reduction: At these optimal moderate angles, Von Mises stress (a measure used to predict material failure) on the implants was 60–80% lower than at the extreme angles.
  • Interface Stability: Stress at the cage-vertebra interface—the primary site of surgical failure—was reduced by 70–80% when choosing the moderate angle over the extreme correction.
  • Clinical Guidance: The study suggests that for patients with severe kyphosis, aiming for a "modest" correction rather than a "complete" one significantly improves the mechanical environment of the spine.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study only analyzed three patients. While these represented different clinical archetypes, a larger cohort is needed to create generalized guidelines.
  • Simplified Loading: The simulation used static loads. It did not account for dynamic, repetitive "fatigue" loading or the complex pull of neck muscles, which were excluded from the model for computational simplicity.
  • Scope: The findings specifically apply to patients with a preoperative Cobb angle above 40°. The authors note that patients with milder deformities might respond differently.
  • Future Direction: The researchers suggest that this FEA workflow could eventually be integrated into preoperative surgical planning software, allowing surgeons to "test-drive" different correction angles on a computer before the first incision is made.

Summary updated

Abstract

The results indicated that moderate correction angles could reduce mechanical stress and lower the risk of postoperative complications. The link between biomechanical data and complications after cervical kyphosis correction supported the existence of an appropriate correction range. It helped to guide the personalized surgical planning from implant selection to the specific intraoperative operations performed by the surgeon and implant design optimization.
BibTeX
@article{lv2025biomechanical,
  author = {Ru-Yuan Lv and Xu Ma and Hongyu Chen and Zuming Mao and Rongkang Li and Yiling Zheng and Feifei Zhou and Feng Zhao},
  title = {{Biomechanical analysis of the patient-specific appropriate correction angle for cervical kyphosis in multilevel anterior cervical discectomy and fusion: a finite element analysis}},
  journal = {Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1186/s13018-025-06368-w},
}
Figure