Bioluminescent Ratiometric Indicator for Analysis of Water Hardness in Household Water

Md. Nadim Hossain, Ryuichi Ishida, Mitsuru Hattori, Tomoki Matsuda, Takeharu NagaiSensors 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces LOTUS-W, a novel genetically encoded bioluminescent indicator for rapidly and affordably measuring water hardness (WH) in household water. By leveraging bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) and a smartphone camera, LOTUS-W offers a user-friendly alternative to expensive and complex traditional methods, with potential applications beyond household water.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Water hardness (WH), primarily determined by the concentration of calcium (Ca²⁺) and magnesium (Mg²⁺) ions, is a crucial parameter for assessing water quality. Hard water can negatively impact household appliances, reduce the effectiveness of detergents, and even affect skin health. Current methods for measuring WH often rely on chemical dye-based indicators or sophisticated analytical equipment, making them expensive, time-consuming, and requiring trained personnel. This creates a need for a low-cost, simple, and rapid method for WH determination, especially for household use and in regions where water quality monitoring is challenging.

Methods

The researchers developed a genetically encoded bioluminescent indicator called LOTUS-W. This indicator is based on a Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) system, specifically utilizing bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET). The core components are:

  • NanoLuc (Nluc): A highly efficient luciferase that acts as the bioluminescent donor.
  • Circularly permuted Venus (cpVenus): A yellow fluorescent protein that serves as the acceptor.
  • Human Centrin 3 (HsCen3): A Ca²⁺/Mg²⁺ binding domain that links Nluc and cpVenus.

The mechanism relies on the binding of Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ ions to the HsCen3 domain. This binding induces a conformational change in HsCen3, altering the spatial proximity between Nluc and cpVenus. This change modulates the efficiency of BRET, leading to a measurable change in the ratio of emitted light from Nluc and cpVenus. The researchers engineered and optimized variants of this construct, ultimately selecting cpV229N_HsCen3△C7-NL (named LOTUS-W) for its optimal dynamic range and affinity for Ca²⁺/Mg²⁺.

To enable on-site measurement, the researchers integrated LOTUS-W with a smartphone camera. The bioluminescence signal from the reaction mixture (LOTUS-W, substrate, and water sample) was captured by the smartphone. By analyzing the ratio of green to blue light intensities in the captured images, the water hardness could be determined. This approach bypasses the need for external excitation light sources and interference filters, simplifying the measurement setup.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention training datasets in the traditional machine learning sense. Instead, the evaluation of LOTUS-W involved:

  • Synthetically prepared water samples: Solutions with known concentrations of Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ were prepared to characterize the indicator's performance, including its dynamic range, dissociation constants, and selectivity.
  • Commercially available bottled waters: Samples with varying WH levels were used to validate the indicator's performance in real-world scenarios.
  • Tap water from Osaka, Japan: This served as a representative household water sample for assessment.

The study also references existing WH scales from USGS/WHO (Table S2) for classification.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Genetically encoded BRET for WH sensing: The development of a genetically encoded indicator that directly translates Ca²⁺/Mg²⁺ binding into a BRET signal is a significant advancement. This allows for the production of the sensor protein through biological expression systems.
  • Smartphone integration for accessibility: Combining a bioluminescent indicator with a smartphone camera democratizes WH measurement, making it accessible to a wider audience without requiring specialized laboratory equipment.
  • High selectivity for Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺: The engineered LOTUS-W demonstrated high selectivity for Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ over other common metal ions, ensuring accurate WH measurements.
  • Robustness to environmental factors: LOTUS-W showed stability across a reasonable pH range (3.5-11.0) and temperature range (20-45 °C), and maintained stability for at least one hour at room temperature, making it suitable for various environmental conditions.
  • Potential for broader applications: The authors suggest that LOTUS-W could be adapted for measuring WH in other contexts, such as the food industry or natural water sources.

Key Results

  • High Dynamic Range: The optimized LOTUS-W (cpV229N_HsCen3△C7-NL) exhibited a significant dynamic range of 140-145% in its emission ratio, indicating a substantial signal change with varying WH.
  • Dissociation Constants: The dissociation constants (Ka) for Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ were determined to be approximately 2.1 mM and 4.7 mM, respectively. These values are within a suitable range for measuring WH in household water.
  • Rapid Measurement: The entire process from sample preparation to image acquisition using the smartphone was estimated to take only 1-2 minutes, highlighting its suitability for on-site and rapid assessments.
  • Successful Categorization: The study successfully categorized commercially available bottled waters and tap water into different WH levels (soft, hard, very hard) using the smartphone-based system.
  • Cost-Effectiveness (Potential): While the initial cost per measurement was estimated to be about 10 times higher than current commercial kits, the authors believe this cost can be reduced in the future, making it a more competitive option.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cost: The authors acknowledge that the current cost per measurement is higher than existing commercial kits, which needs to be addressed for widespread adoption.
  • Optimization of Indicator Domain: For practical applications in diverse water sources (ponds, rivers, groundwater), further engineering of the indicator domain might be necessary to optimize sensitivity and specificity for specific ion concentrations.
  • Interference from Other Ions: While selectivity for Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ was demonstrated, the potential for interference from other ions in complex water matrices warrants further investigation.
  • Quantitative Accuracy: The current smartphone-based method primarily categorizes WH levels. Further refinement might be needed for highly precise quantitative measurements across all WH ranges.

Future work could focus on reducing the cost of the assay, developing variants with tailored affinities for specific ions or broader WH ranges, and exploring its application in diverse environmental water samples.

Summary updated

Abstract

Water hardness (WH) is a useful parameter for testing household water, such as drinking, cooking, and washing water. Many countries around the world use pipeline water in their houses, but there is a need to monitor the WH because hard water has a negative impact on appliances. Currently, WH is often measured using chemical dye-based WH indicators, and these techniques require expensive equipment, and trained personnel. Therefore, a low-cost and simple measurement method has been desired. Here, we report LOTUS-W, which consists of a luciferase, Nanoluc, a yellow fluorescent protein Venus, and a Ca<sup>2+</sup>/Mg<sup>2+</sup> detection domain of human centrin 3. The binding of Ca<sup>2+</sup>/Mg<sup>2+</sup> to this indicator changes the conformation of human centrin 3, and induces bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) from Nanoluc to Venus, which changes its emission spectrum about 140%. The dissociation constants of LOTUS-W for Ca<sup>2+</sup>/Mg<sup>2+</sup> are approximately several mM, making it suitable for measuring WH in the household water. With this indicator in combination with a smartphone, we have demonstrated that it is possible to evaluate WH easily and quickly. This novel indicator has the potential to be used for measuring not only household water but also water used in the food industry, etc.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hossain2020bioluminescent,
  author = {Md. Nadim Hossain and Ryuichi Ishida and Mitsuru Hattori and Tomoki Matsuda and Takeharu Nagai},
  title = {{Bioluminescent Ratiometric Indicator for Analysis of Water Hardness in Household Water}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20113164},
}
Figure