Bilayer graphene spectral function in the random phase approximation and self-consistent GW approximation

Andro Sabashvili, Stellan Östlund, Mats GranathPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We calculate the single-particle spectral function for doped bilayer graphene in the low energy limit, described by two parabolic bands with zero band gap and long range Coulomb interaction. Calculations are done using thermal Green's functions in both the random phase approximation (RPA) and the fully self-consistent GW approximation. Consistent with previous studies RPA yields a spectral function which, apart from the Landau quasiparticle peaks, shows additional coherent features interpreted as plasmarons, i.e., composite electron-plasmon excitations. In the GW approximation the plasmaron becomes incoherent and peaks are replaced by much broader features. The deviation of the quasiparticle weight and mass renormalization from their noninteracting values is small which indicates that bilayer graphene is a weakly interacting system. The electron energy loss function, $\mathrm{Im}[\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{q}^{\ensuremath{-}1}(\ensuremath{\omega})]$ shows a sharp plasmon mode in RPA which in the GW approximation becomes less coherent and thus consistent with the weaker plasmaron features in the corresponding single-particle spectral function.

Introduction

In condensed matter physics, the single-particle spectral function serves as a fundamental map of electronic states in terms of energy and momentum. In bilayer graphene, the interplay between parabolic bands and long-range Coulomb interactions leads to complex collective behaviors. Previous theoretical frameworks, specifically the Random Phase Approximation (RPA), predicted the existence of plasmarons—composite quasiparticles formed by the strong coupling of an electron to a plasmon. This study investigates whether these features are physical realities or artifacts of non-self-consistent methods by comparing RPA results with the more rigorous self-consistent GW approximation.

Methods

The authors modeled doped bilayer graphene in the low-energy limit using a two-band model with an effective mass $m \approx 0.054 m_e$. Two primary many-body calculation techniques were employed:

  1. Random Phase Approximation (RPA): A perturbative approach accounting for dynamic screening using non-interacting "bare" Green's functions.
  2. Self-consistent GW Approximation: An iterative method where the Green’s function ($G$) and the screened interaction ($W$) are updated until stability is reached.
Feynman diagrams representing the self-energy $\Sigma$ in the many-body calculation.

To handle the numerical complexity, a periodized Green’s function formalism for finite temperatures was used, with Padé approximants facilitating the analytic continuation from imaginary to real frequencies.

Results and Discussion

The most striking finding is the "disappearance" of coherent plasmaron features when moving from RPA to a self-consistent GW treatment. As shown in the spectral maps and line cuts, the sharp, distinct peaks characteristic of plasmarons in RPA are replaced by broad, indistinct "shoulders" in the GW results. This suggests that self-consistency leads to more effective screening, dampening the interactions that form the plasmaron.

Comparison of spectral functions $A(k, \omega)$ in RPA (a, c) and self-consistent GW (b, d), showing the loss of plasmaron coherence.

Despite these changes in coherence, the system remains remarkably close to the non-interacting limit. The quasiparticle weight ($Z$) remains high (0.851 in GW at $r_s = 3$), and mass renormalization ($m^*/m$) deviates by less than 7% from the bare mass. This indicates that bilayer graphene behaves largely as a system of independent particles, even at relatively high coupling strengths ($r_s = 7$).

Conclusion

While the self-consistent GW approximation suggests that plasmarons in bilayer graphene are incoherent features, the authors note that this method may underestimate the coherence of collective excitations. Future work incorporating vertex corrections to the polarization will be necessary to definitively determine if the plasmaron is a truly stable quasiparticle or if the simpler RPA model overestimates its stability.

Summary updated

Abstract

We calculate the single-particle spectral function for doped bilayer graphene in the low energy limit, described by two parabolic bands with zero band gap and long range Coulomb interaction. Calculations are done using thermal Green's functions in both the random phase approximation (RPA) and the fully self-consistent GW approximation. Consistent with previous studies RPA yields a spectral function which, apart from the Landau quasiparticle peaks, shows additional coherent features interpreted as plasmarons, i.e., composite electron-plasmon excitations. In the GW approximation the plasmaron becomes incoherent and peaks are replaced by much broader features. The deviation of the quasiparticle weight and mass renormalization from their noninteracting values is small which indicates that bilayer graphene is a weakly interacting system. The electron energy loss function, $\mathrm{Im}[\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{q}^{\ensuremath{-}1}(\ensuremath{\omega})]$ shows a sharp plasmon mode in RPA which in the GW approximation becomes less coherent and thus consistent with the weaker plasmaron features in the corresponding single-particle spectral function.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sabashvili2013bilayer,
  author = {Andro Sabashvili and Stellan Östlund and Mats Granath},
  title = {{Bilayer graphene spectral function in the random phase approximation and self-consistent GW approximation}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.88.085439},
}
Figure