TL;DR
This study uses bibliometric analysis to map the research landscape of cognitive function in Developmental Coordination Disorder (DCD) from 2010-2022. It reveals a growing interest in the field, identifies key countries, institutions, and researchers, and highlights emerging research themes, suggesting future directions for understanding and intervening in DCD.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Developmental Coordination Disorder (DCD) is a neurodevelopmental disorder affecting 5-6% of children, characterized by significant difficulties in performing everyday motor tasks. While traditionally viewed as a motor disorder, emerging evidence suggests a strong link between motor impairments and cognitive deficits. However, the precise nature of these cognitive deficits, their underlying mechanisms, and how they interact with motor skills remain complex and not fully understood. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the research on cognitive function in DCD over the past decade, identifying key trends, hotspots, and future research avenues to better understand this population.
Methods
The researchers employed a bibliometric analysis approach, utilizing two primary software tools: CiteSpace and VOSviewer. They collected data from the Web of Science Core Collection database, focusing on literature published between 2010 and August 2022. The search strategy combined terms related to DCD (e.g., "developmental coordination disorder," "poor motor coordination") with terms related to cognitive function (e.g., "cognitive," "executive function," "motor control") and specified "children" as the population.
The analysis involved:
- Publication Trend Analysis: Examining the number of publications per year to identify growth trends.
- Country and Institution Analysis: Mapping the geographical distribution and institutional contributions to the field, identifying leading countries and institutions.
- Author Co-citation Analysis: Identifying influential researchers and their collaborative networks.
- Keyword Analysis: Identifying prominent themes and research hotspots by analyzing keyword co-occurrence and citation bursts.
- Reference Co-citation Analysis: Mapping the foundational literature and key research clusters within the field.
VOSviewer was used for generating network visualizations (cooperation networks, density maps, average annual publication year maps), while CiteSpace was used for citation burst detection and timeline visualization.
Datasets
The study utilized data from the Web of Science Core Collection database. The specific indices included were: Science Citation Index Expanded (SCI-E), Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI), Arts & Humanities Citation Index (A&HCI), Conference Proceedings Citation Index-Science (CPCI-S), Conference Proceedings Citation Index-Social Sciences and Humanities (CPCI-SSH), Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI), Current Chemical Reactions (CCR-EXPANDED), and Index Chemicus (IC).
The initial search yielded 1,885 records. After applying inclusion and exclusion criteria (peer-reviewed original articles, English language, published 2010-2022, excluding animal experiments, non-official publications, etc.), a final dataset of 1,082 articles was analyzed. No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced by this study.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Growing Research Interest: The number of publications on cognitive function in DCD has steadily increased, particularly in the last five years, indicating a rising global research focus on this area.
- US Dominance, but Global Collaboration: The United States leads in publications and citations, but over 40 countries and numerous institutions are involved, suggesting a growing international effort. However, the paper notes that cooperation between many countries remains weak, highlighting an opportunity for enhanced collaboration.
- Key Players Identified: Specific institutions (e.g., Australian Catholic University, University of Groningen) and researchers (e.g., P.H. Wilson) have been highly influential, contributing significantly to the field.
- Emerging Keyword Themes: Beyond core terms like "DCD" and "children," keywords like "attention," "working memory," "performance," and "ADHD" are prominent. More recent research (post-2017) shows a burst in terms like "neurodevelopmental disorder," "occupational therapy," "preschool children," "motor competence," "model," and "online control," pointing to evolving research directions.
- Three Core Research Domains: The past decade's research can be broadly categorized into: (i) understanding poor cognitive performance in DCD, (ii) exploring the underlying cognitive mechanisms, and (iii) developing interventions to improve performance.
Key Results
- Publication Volume: 1,082 articles were analyzed from 2010 to 2022.
- Country Contributions: The United States (17.76%), Australia (12.02%), and England (9.69%) were the top publishing countries.
- Institutional Contributions: 117 institutions contributed, with Australian Catholic University being the most active.
- Journal Impact: "Research in Developmental Disabilities" was the most significant journal in terms of publications and citations.
- Key Research Hotspots: Keywords indicate a focus on "DCD," "children," "attention," "working memory," "performance," and "ADHD." Hot topics include "functional performance," "population," and "cognitive psychology."
- Research Directions: Emerging research directions include "Asperger syndrome," "memory," "infant," "clumsiness," "neurodevelopmental disorder," "occupational therapy," "preschool children," "motor competence," "model," and "online control."
Limitations and Future Work
Limitations: * The study's search algorithm was based on keywords and did not include full-text analysis, potentially missing some relevant articles. * The categorical search for cognitive function was not performed, limiting the scope of discussions to articles that explicitly used the chosen keywords.
Future Work: * Neurophysiological Techniques: Future research should increasingly employ neurophysiological methods to gain deeper insights into the cognitive characteristics of children with DCD. * Motor Imagery and Intrinsic Models: Focus should be placed on investigating motor imagery and intrinsic models to better understand DCD. * Intervention Development: Continued development and refinement of intervention programs are crucial. * Meta-analysis: The authors suggest that meta-analysis could provide more comprehensive information in future research. * Cognitive Function as Outcome: Future studies could use cognitive function as an outcome measure to analyze and improve the current definition, diagnosis, and intervention strategies for DCD.
Summary updated