Bibliometric analysis of the association between drinking water pollution and bladder cancer

Ying Zhang, Mei Liu, Jiajun Wang, Kexin Han, Fuyu Han, Bi‐Cheng Wang, Si Xie, Chunhui Yuan, Mingdeng Zhao, Shuo Li, Jun WangFrontiers in Oncology 2023 · DOI

Abstract

This study is the first systematic bibliometric study of the literature publications on drinking water pollution and bladder cancer. It offers an overall and intuitive understanding of this topic in the past few years, and points out a clear direction for research hotspots and reveals the trends for further in-depth study in the future.

Introduction

Bladder cancer remains a significant global health challenge, with over 500,000 new cases diagnosed annually. While tobacco use is the most recognized risk factor, environmental exposures—particularly through contaminated drinking water—represent a critical area of public health concern. Over the last five decades, researchers have investigated various pollutants, ranging from naturally occurring heavy metals like arsenic to synthetic chemical by-products from water treatment processes.

Despite the volume of research, the field has lacked a comprehensive "birds-eye view" to synthesize these findings. This paper addresses this gap by presenting a systematic bibliometric analysis, mapping the evolution of the research landscape from 1972 to 2023. By identifying key contributors, geographic trends, and emerging hotspots, this study provides a roadmap for future toxicological and epidemiological investigations.

Methodology

The researchers implemented a rigorous bibliometric workflow to ensure data integrity and comprehensive coverage. The primary data source was the Scopus database, selected for its extensive indexing of environmental and medical literature.

Figure 1: Workflow of the bibliometrics analysis.

As illustrated in the workflow, the process involved three main branches of analysis:

  1. Co-authorship Analysis: Mapping collaborations between authors, institutions, and countries.
  2. Publication Analysis: Tracking trends by year, journal contribution, and subject category.
  3. Co-occurrence Analysis: Utilizing text mining of keywords and titles to identify research clusters and thematic shifts.

The software stack included R (specifically the tm and ggplot2 packages) for text mining and VOSviewer for network visualization. A linear regression model ($y = 0.5487x - 1082.2$) was also applied to the publication data to project future research output.

The study analyzed a corpus of 687 peer-reviewed documents. The dataset is characterized by a strong interdisciplinary focus, with the majority of publications falling under the categories of Medicine and Environmental Science.

Figure 2: Basic Information of publishing trends and statistical results. (A) shows the publication trend by year; (B) shows subject categories; (C) shows document types.

The document breakdown includes 491 original research articles and 98 review articles, indicating a field rooted in primary data collection but supported by significant synthesis. As shown in the trend analysis, research output has grown steadily since the early 2000s, reflecting increasing global concern over water quality and long-term health outcomes.

Key Insights and Research Hotspots

The Arsenic Challenge

Arsenic emerged as the most dominant research hotspot, appearing in 365 documents. This highlights a global scientific consensus that inorganic arsenic, often found in groundwater due to geological factors, is the most critical environmental driver for bladder malignancies.

The Disinfection By-Product Dilemma

A significant cluster of research focuses on the "disinfection dilemma." While chlorination is essential for preventing waterborne diseases, it reacts with organic matter to create by-products such as trihalomethanes. The analysis shows that the long-term carcinogenic risk of these by-products remains a central pillar of the field's inquiry.

Geographic and Institutional Leadership

The United States is the undisputed leader in this research domain, contributing approximately 50% of the total publications (345 articles). Seven of the top ten most productive research institutions are based in the U.S., with Environmental Health Perspectives serving as the primary hub journal for high-impact findings.

Key Results and Influential Works

  • Citation Impact: The most cited paper in the field is Richardson et al. (2007), which has garnered over 2,330 citations, emphasizing the foundational role of early 21st-century reviews in shaping current understanding.
  • Leading Researchers: Professor Cantor K.P. is the most prolific author with 35 articles, while Smith A.H. holds the highest citation impact per article (225 citations), indicating high-quality, influential contributions to the field.
  • Growth Projections: Based on the linear fitting curve, the field is expected to maintain its upward trajectory, with an estimated 28-30 high-impact articles projected for the most recent year of the study.

Limitations and Future Directions

While comprehensive, this study relied exclusively on the Scopus database and English-language publications, which may introduce a slight geographic or linguistic bias.

Looking forward, the authors suggest that the field must evolve beyond traditional association studies. The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and big data mining will be crucial for uncovering subtle causal relationships between emerging contaminants—such as microplastics and PFAS—and bladder cancer. Furthermore, there is a pressing need for increased international collaboration to address the regional imbalance in research, particularly in developing nations where water pollution remains a critical, yet under-studied, threat.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study is the first systematic bibliometric study of the literature publications on drinking water pollution and bladder cancer. It offers an overall and intuitive understanding of this topic in the past few years, and points out a clear direction research hotspots and reveals the trends for further in-depth study in future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023bibliometric,
  author = {Ying Zhang and Mei Liu and Jiajun Wang and Kexin Han and Fuyu Han and Bi‐Cheng Wang and Si Xie and Chunhui Yuan and Mingdeng Zhao and Shuo Li and Jun Wang and Jun Wang and Jun Wang},
  title = {{Bibliometric analysis of the association between drinking water pollution and bladder cancer}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Oncology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fonc.2023.1170700},
}
Figure