Bias-preserving and error-detectable entangling operations in a superconducting dual-rail system

Nitish Mehta, Teoh, James D., Taewan Noh, Ankur Agrawal, Amos Anderson, Beau Birdsall, Avadh Brahmbhatt, William Byrd, Marc Cacioppo, Anthony Cabrera, L.j. Carroll, Jonathan Chen, Tzu-Chiao Chien, Richard Chamberlain, Jacob C. Curtis, Doreen Danso, Sanjana Renganatha Desigan, Francesco D'Acounto, Bassel Heiba Elfeky, S. M. Farzaneh, C. P. Foley, Benjamin Gudlewski, Hannah Hastings, Robert L. Johnson, Nishaad Khedkar, Trevor Keen, Anup Kumar, Cihan Kurter, Kamila Krawczuk, Eric Langstengel, Richard D. Li, G. Liu, Hanyi Lu, Pinlei Lu, Luke Mastalli-Kelly, Adam Maines, Michael Maxwell, Heather McCarrick, M. Saeed Mirzaei, A. Narla, Omar Rashad, Erik Reikes, Mizanur Rahman, Rurik Primiani, M. Schwaller, A. Sabbah, Tali Shemma, Aoshuang Shi, Sikhanda Satapathy, Dean Stolpe, Jonathan Strenczewilk, Doug Szperka, Iu-Wei Sze, David Sweeney, Preetham Tikkireddi, Chin-Lun Tsung, Daren Vet Sam, D. Weiß, Zhibo Yang, Liuqi Yu, Teng Zhang, Olivier Boireau, Sophie L. Horton, S. Matthew Weinberg, José Aumentado, B. Cord, Chan U Lei, Joseph Yuan, Shantanu Mundhada, Kevin Chou, Jr. Moseleley, Robert SchoelkopfarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

For useful quantum computation, error-corrected machines are required that can dramatically reduce the inevitable errors experienced by physical qubits. While significant progress has been made in approaching and exceeding the surface-code threshold in superconducting platforms, large gains in the logical error rate with increasing system size remain out of reach. This is due both to the large number of required physical qubits and the need to operate far below threshold. Importantly, by exploiting the biases and structure of the physical errors, this threshold can be raised. Erasure qubits achieve this by detecting certain errors at the hardware level. Dual-rail qubits encoded in superconducting cavities are a promising erasure qubit wherein the dominant error, photon loss, can be detected and converted to an erasure. In these approaches, the complete set of operations, including two qubit gates, must be high performance and preserve as much of the desirable hierarchy or bias in the errors as possible. Here, we design and realize a novel two-qubit gate for dual-rail erasure qubits based on superconducting microwave cavities. The gate is high-speed ($\sim$500 ns duration), and yields a residual gate infidelity after error detection below 0.1%. Moreover, we experimentally demonstrate that this gate largely preserves the favorable error structure of idling dual-rail qubits, making it ideal for error correction. We measure low erasure rates of $\sim$0.5% per gate, as well as low and asymmetric dephasing errors that occur at least three times more frequently on control qubits compared to target qubits. Bit-flip errors are practically nonexistent, bounded at the few parts per million level. This error asymmetry has not been well explored but is extremely useful in quantum error correction and flag-qubit contexts, where it can create a faster path to effective error-corrected systems.

Introduction

The quest for fault-tolerant quantum computing is primarily a battle against decoherence and noise. In standard superconducting architectures, errors like bit-flips and phase-flips occur with similar frequencies and are difficult to distinguish from valid computational steps. This symmetry necessitates massive overhead in quantum error correction (QEC), requiring thousands of physical qubits to form a single stable logical qubit.

A more efficient path involves erasure qubits. In this paradigm, the most frequent physical errors—such as photon loss in a cavity—are converted into detectable "erasures." By flagging exactly when and where an error occurs, the QEC threshold can be significantly raised. Dual-rail qubits, which encode information in the single-excitation manifold of two microwave cavities, are particularly well-suited for this. However, a critical challenge remains: implementing two-qubit entangling gates that are fast and high-fidelity without destroying this advantageous error structure.

The SWAP-Wait-SWAP (SWS) Gate

To address this, researchers at Quantum Circuits, Inc. developed a novel SWAP-Wait-SWAP (SWS) protocol for a Controlled-Z (CZ) gate. The architecture consists of two dual-rail qubits (control and target) coupled via a central transmon coupler.

The SWAP-Wait-SWAP (SWS) gate sequence for dual-rail qubits.

The gate sequence operates in three stages:

  1. SWAP: A parametric drive moves the photon from one of the control qubit's cavities into the central transmon coupler.
  2. WAIT: While the photon is in the coupler, it interacts dispersively with the target qubit, causing the system to accumulate a phase shift only if both qubits are in specific states.
  3. SWAP: The photon is returned from the coupler to its original cavity.

This design is "erasure-friendly" because it operates within a single-excitation manifold. If a photon is lost at any point during the sequence, the system ends up in the vacuum state ($|00\rangle$), which is easily detected and flagged as an erasure rather than a logic error.

Experimental Results and Error Bias

The team evaluated the gate's performance using interleaved randomized benchmarking (IRB) and quantum state tomography. The gate is remarkably fast, completing in approximately 500 ns, which is fast enough to outrun the decoherence of the cavities.

Gate performance metrics including fidelity and randomized benchmarking.

Key performance metrics include:

  • High Post-Selected Fidelity: After removing detected erasure events, the residual gate infidelity is below 0.1%, matching the state-of-the-art for any superconducting platform.
  • Extreme Noise Bias: Bit-flip errors (transitions between logical $|0\rangle$ and $|1\rangle$) are suppressed to the parts-per-million level. This is because the "outer" cavities of the dual-rail system are largely isolated from the coupler's noise.
  • Useful Asymmetry: The researchers observed that dephasing errors are 3-4 times more likely on the control qubit than the target. While asymmetric, this property is highly beneficial for specific QEC codes, such as flag-qubit circuits, which can leverage this knowledge for more efficient recovery.

Conclusion and Outlook

The SWS gate for dual-rail qubits represents a significant step toward practical fault tolerance. By achieving high speeds and high fidelities while maintaining a massive bias against bit-flips and preserving the erasure property, this architecture offers a streamlined path to error correction. Future work will focus on reducing the erasure rate—currently $\sim$0.5% per gate, primarily limited by the transmon coupler's lifetime—and scaling the system to larger grids for logical qubit demonstrations.

Summary updated

Abstract

For useful quantum computation, error-corrected machines are required that can dramatically reduce the inevitable errors experienced by physical qubits. While significant progress has been made in approaching and exceeding the surface-code threshold in superconducting platforms, large gains in the logical error rate with increasing system size remain out of reach. This is due both to the large number of required physical qubits and the need to operate far below threshold. Importantly, by exploiting the biases and structure of the physical errors, this threshold can be raised. Erasure qubits achieve this by detecting certain errors at the hardware level. Dual-rail qubits encoded in superconducting cavities are a promising erasure qubit wherein the dominant error, photon loss, can be detected and converted to an erasure. In these approaches, the complete set of operations, including two qubit gates, must be high performance and preserve as much of the desirable hierarchy or bias in the errors as possible. Here, we design and realize a novel two-qubit gate for dual-rail erasure qubits based on superconducting microwave cavities. The gate is high-speed ($\sim$500 ns duration), and yields a residual gate infidelity after error detection below 0.1%. Moreover, we experimentally demonstrate that this gate largely preserves the favorable error structure of idling dual-rail qubits, making it ideal for error correction. We measure low erasure rates of $\sim$0.5% per gate, as well as low and asymmetric dephasing errors that occur at least three times more frequently on control qubits compared to target qubits. Bit-flip errors are practically nonexistent, bounded at the few parts per million level. This error asymmetry has not been well explored but is extremely useful in quantum error correction and flag-qubit contexts, where it can create a faster path to effective error-corrected systems.
BibTeX
@misc{mehta2025bias,
  author = {Nitish Mehta and Teoh, James D. and Taewan Noh and Ankur Agrawal and Amos Anderson and Beau Birdsall and Avadh Brahmbhatt and William Byrd and Marc Cacioppo and Anthony Cabrera and L.J. Carroll and Jonathan Chen and Tzu-Chiao Chien and Richard Chamberlain and Jacob C. Curtis and Doreen Danso and Sanjana Renganatha Desigan and Francesco D'Acounto and Bassel Heiba Elfeky and S. M. Farzaneh and C. P. Foley and Benjamin Gudlewski and Hannah Hastings and Robert L. Johnson and Nishaad Khedkar and Trevor Keen and Anup Kumar and Cihan Kurter and Kamila Krawczuk and Eric Langstengel and Richard D. Li and G. Liu and Hanyi Lu and Pinlei Lu and Luke Mastalli-Kelly and Adam Maines and Michael Maxwell and Heather McCarrick and M. Saeed Mirzaei and A. Narla and Omar Rashad and Erik Reikes and Mizanur Rahman and Rurik Primiani and M. Schwaller and A. Sabbah and Tali Shemma and Aoshuang Shi and Sikhanda Satapathy and Dean Stolpe and Jonathan Strenczewilk and Doug Szperka and Iu-Wei Sze and David Sweeney and Preetham Tikkireddi and Chin-Lun Tsung and Daren Vet Sam and D. Weiß and Zhibo Yang and Liuqi Yu and Teng Zhang and Olivier Boireau and Sophie L. Horton and S. Matthew Weinberg and José Aumentado and B. Cord and Chan U Lei and Joseph Yuan and Shantanu Mundhada and Kevin Chou and Jr. Moseleley and Robert Schoelkopf},
  title = {{Bias-preserving and error-detectable entangling operations in a superconducting dual-rail system}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2503.10935},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.10935},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure