Bias-modulated dynamics of a strongly driven two-level system

Zhiguo Lü, Yiying Yan, Hsi‐Sheng Goan, Hang ZhengPhysical 2016 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We investigate the bias-modulated dynamics of a strongly driven two-level system using the counterrotating-hybridized rotating-wave (CHRW) method. This approach treats the driving field and the bias on equal footing through a unitary transformation defined by two parameters, $\xi$ and $\zeta$. The CHRW method is nonperturbative in driving strength, tunneling amplitude, and bias, extending beyond the traditional rotating-wave approximation (Rabi-RWA). By properly choosing $\xi$ and $\zeta$, the transformed Hamiltonian adopts an RWA-like form with renormalized energy splitting and driving strength. This mathematical simplicity allows for the analytical calculation of dynamics and an explicit exploration of bias effects. We demonstrate that the CHRW method provides accurate driven dynamics across a wide parameter range compared to numerically exact results, particularly where ordinary perturbation approaches fail. We also derive analytical expressions for the generalized Rabi frequency and bias-modulated Bloch-Siegert shift, showing excellent agreement with experimental data from superconducting flux qubits.

Introduction

The Rabi model, which describes a two-level system (TLS) interacting with an oscillating field, is a foundational concept in quantum optics and quantum information science. Despite its importance, obtaining analytical solutions for the model remains a significant challenge, especially when the system is subjected to strong driving or static bias.

The standard analytical tool, the Rotating Wave Approximation (Rabi-RWA), simplifies the problem by neglecting "counter-rotating" terms that oscillate rapidly. While effective for weak driving, the Rabi-RWA breaks down as the driving strength increases or when the system moves off-resonance. In these regimes, the neglected terms cause significant shifts in resonance and dynamics. Furthermore, the introduction of a static bias—an energy offset between the two states—complicates the mathematics further. While numerical methods like Floquet theory can solve these problems, they lack the physical transparency and predictive simplicity of analytical formulas.

The Counter-Rotating-Hybridized Rotating-Wave (CHRW) Method

To address these limitations, this research introduces the Counter-Rotating-Hybridized Rotating-Wave (CHRW) method. The core innovation of the CHRW approach is its ability to treat the driving field and the static bias on "equal footing."

1. Unitary Transformation and Renormalization

The method employs a unitary transformation to the system's Hamiltonian using two tunable parameters, $\xi$ and $\zeta$. This transformation effectively "absorbs" the complex counter-rotating interactions into the core parameters of the system. This process, known as renormalization, results in a new energy splitting and a modified driving strength that account for the influence of the counter-rotating terms from the outset.

2. Self-Consistency

The parameters $\xi$ and $\zeta$ are not arbitrary; they are determined by solving two self-consistent equations. These equations are designed to force the transformed Hamiltonian into a mathematically simple form identical to the standard RWA. This allows researchers to use the familiar tools of the Rabi-RWA while benefiting from the accuracy of a much more sophisticated model.

3. Non-Perturbative Nature

Unlike standard perturbation theories, which assume that certain parameters (like driving strength) are small, the CHRW method is non-perturbative. It remains valid even when the driving strength, tunneling amplitude, and bias are of the same order of magnitude, making it uniquely suited for the "strong-driving" regime.

Key Insights and Analytical Results

A significant achievement of this work is the derivation of the bias-modulated Bloch-Siegert shift. This shift represents the change in resonance frequency caused by the counter-rotating terms, and it is notoriously difficult to calculate analytically in the presence of bias.

The authors derived a second-order expression for the modulated Rabi frequency ($\Omega_R$): $$\Omega_{R-2nd}^2 = [\omega - \Xi_0]^2 + \frac{A^2\Delta^2}{2\Xi_0(\omega + \Xi_0)}$$ This formula allows experimentalists to calculate frequency shifts directly from system parameters without the need for computationally intensive simulations.

Furthermore, the inclusion of the second parameter ($\zeta$) is what allows the CHRW method to handle biased systems. Previous iterations of hybridized RWA methods often relied on a single parameter, which limited their applicability to unbiased (symmetric) systems. By treating the bias and drive together, the CHRW method provides a physically clear picture of how static offsets influence quantum dynamics.

Validation and Experimental Agreement

The validity of the CHRW method was tested against two benchmarks:

  1. Numerical Exactness: The analytical results were compared against numerically exact solutions calculated via Floquet theory. In regimes ranging from resonance to far off-resonance, the CHRW method's predictions for occupation probability ($P_{up}$) matched numerical results almost perfectly, even where the standard Rabi-RWA failed.
  2. Experimental Data: The method was validated against experimental data from superconducting flux qubits. The CHRW results showed excellent agreement with the observed minimum Rabi frequencies and the specific frequency shifts reported in laboratory settings.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The CHRW approach offers a mathematically simple yet physically robust framework for understanding strongly driven two-level systems. It bridges the gap between simple but inaccurate approximations and accurate but opaque numerical simulations.

Future work may extend this method to handle ultra-strong driving, where higher-order harmonics and multi-photon processes become dominant. Additionally, adapting the CHRW framework for dissipative (open) quantum systems—where the TLS interacts with a noisy environment—remains a vital next step for its application in real-world quantum computing and decoherence studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the bias-modulated dynamics of a strongly driven two-level system using the counterrotating-hybridized rotating-wave (CHRW) method. This CHRW method treats the driving field and the bias on equal footing by a unitary transformation with two parameters $\ensuremath{\xi}$ and $\ensuremath{\zeta}$, and is nonperturbative in driving strength, tunneling amplitude, or bias. In addition, this CHRW method is beyond the traditional rotating-wave approximation (Rabi-RWA) and yet by properly choosing the two parameters $\ensuremath{\xi}$ and $\ensuremath{\zeta}$, the transformed Hamiltonian takes the RWA form with a renormalized energy splitting and a renormalized driving strength. The reformulated CHRW method possesses the same mathematical simplicity as the Rabi-RWA approach and thus allows us to calculate analytically the dynamics and explore explicitly the effect of the bias. We show that the CHRW method gives the accurate driven dynamics for a wide range of parameters as compared to the numerically exact results. When energy scales of the driving are comparable to the intrinsic energy scale of the two-level systems, the counterrotating interactions and static bias profoundly influence the generalized Rabi frequency. In this regime, where ordinary perturbation approaches fail, the CHRW works very well and efficiently. We also demonstrate the dynamics of the system in the strong-driving and off-resonance cases for which the Rabi-RWA method breaks down but the CHRW method remains valid. We obtain analytical expressions for the generalized Rabi frequency and bias-modulated Bloch-Siegert shift as functions of the bias, tunneling, and driving field parameters. The CHRW approach is a mathematically simple and physically clear method. It can be applied to treat some complicated problems for which a numerical study is difficult to perform.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2016bias,
  author = {Zhiguo Lü and Yiying Yan and Hsi‐Sheng Goan and Hang Zheng},
  title = {{Bias-modulated dynamics of a strongly driven two-level system}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1103/physreva.93.033803},
}
Figure