Beyond the Low Frequency Fluctuations: Morning and Evening Differences in Human Brain

Magdalena Fąfrowicz, Bartosz Bohaterewicz, Anna Ceglarek, Monika Cichocka, Koryna Lewandowska, Barbara Sikora-Wachowicz, Halszka Ogińska, Anna Bereś, Justyna Olszewska, Tadeusz MarekFrontiers in Human Neuroscience 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how the time of day and individual chronotype (morning vs. evening person) affect resting-state brain connectivity using fMRI. Surprisingly, the researchers found that the time of day significantly altered brain connectivity patterns, but individual chronotype had no discernible effect, suggesting a universal influence of circadian and homeostatic processes on brain function.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Our daily lives are governed by a 24-hour cycle, influencing everything from our alertness to our cognitive performance. This rhythm is driven by two main forces: the circadian rhythm (our internal biological clock) and homeostatic sleep-wake regulation (the build-up of sleep pressure the longer we are awake). While it's well-established that these processes affect behavior and brain activity, the precise mechanisms and how they interact, especially in terms of resting-state brain networks, are still being explored. Previous research has hinted at time-of-day variations in brain activity, but the role of individual differences in chronotype (whether someone is naturally a "morning lark" or a "night owl") in these variations has been less clear. This paper aims to disentangle the effects of time of day and chronotype on functional brain connectivity during rest.

Methods

The researchers employed functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) to examine resting-state functional connectivity. Specifically, they used resting-state fMRI (rs-fMRI), which measures spontaneous brain activity when a person is not performing a task. To analyze the connectivity, they utilized an ALFF-based FC analysis. ALFF (Amplitude of Low-Frequency Fluctuations) measures the intensity of spontaneous brain activity within a specific frequency range, and this was used as a basis for calculating functional connectivity between different brain regions.

The analysis involved:

  • Seed-to-voxel analysis: This method uses a specific brain region (the "seed") and calculates its functional connectivity with all other voxels (3D pixels) in the brain.
  • Paired t-tests: Used to compare connectivity between morning and evening sessions within the same individuals.
  • Two-sample t-tests: Used to compare connectivity between morning-type and evening-type individuals.
  • ANOVA: A statistical test to examine the interaction effect between time of day and chronotype.

Data preprocessing included standard steps like slice-timing correction, realignment, normalization to a standard brain space (MNI), and smoothing.

Datasets

The study used data from 63 healthy young participants (29 extreme morning-types and 34 extreme evening-types). These participants underwent two fMRI sessions: one in the morning (about 1 hour after waking) and one in the evening (about 10 hours after waking), scheduled according to their habitual sleep-wake patterns. No new benchmarks or datasets were introduced; the study relied on existing participant recruitment and established fMRI analysis pipelines.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Time of Day Dominates Chronotype: The most striking finding is that the time of day had a significant impact on resting-state functional connectivity, while individual chronotype did not. This suggests that the fundamental biological rhythms of sleep and wakefulness exert a more universal influence on brain network organization than individual preferences for morning or evening activity.
  • Universal Nature of Circadian/Homeostatic Influences: The results imply that the way our brains organize their resting-state networks in response to circadian and homeostatic pressures is largely consistent across individuals, regardless of whether they are morning or evening people.
  • Morning vs. Evening Brain Connectivity Differs: The study identified distinct patterns of functional connectivity in the morning compared to the evening. This highlights that even when the brain is at rest, its network dynamics are modulated by the time of day.

Key Results

  • Significant Time-of-Day Effects: The analysis revealed significant differences in functional connectivity between the morning (MS) and evening (ES) sessions. Specifically, the MS showed increased connectivity in several brain regions compared to the ES (Figure 1). Conversely, the ES showed increased connectivity in other regions compared to the MS (Figure 2).
  • No Chronotype Differences: No significant differences in seed-to-voxel connectivity were found between the extreme morning-type and evening-type individuals.
  • No Time-of-Day x Chronotype Interaction: The study found no significant interaction effects between time of day and chronotype on functional connectivity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Extreme Chronotypes: The study focused on "extreme" morning and evening chronotypes. It's possible that individuals with intermediate chronotypes might show different patterns, or that the extreme selection might have masked subtler effects.
  • Sample Size: While 63 participants is a reasonable sample size for fMRI, larger and more diverse samples could provide even more robust findings.
  • ALFF-Based FC: The study used ALFF for FC analysis. Future research could explore other connectivity measures (e.g., ReHo, ICA) to provide a more comprehensive picture.

The authors suggest that future research could investigate the specific mechanisms by which circadian and homeostatic processes influence these connectivity patterns and explore how these patterns relate to specific cognitive functions or behaviors. They also highlight the need for further research into the stability of resting-state networks across longer periods and different physiological states.

Summary updated

Abstract

Human performance, alertness, and most biological functions express rhythmic fluctuations across a 24-h-period. This phenomenon is believed to originate from differences in both circadian and homeostatic sleep-wake regulatory processes. Interactions between these processes result in time-of-day modulations of behavioral performance as well as brain activity patterns. Although the basic mechanism of the 24-h clock is conserved across evolution, there are interindividual differences in the timing of sleep-wake cycles, subjective alertness and functioning throughout the day. The study of circadian typology differences has increased during the last few years, especially research on extreme chronotypes, which provide a unique way to investigate the effects of sleep-wake regulation on cerebral mechanisms. Using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), we assessed the influence of chronotype and time-of-day on resting-state functional connectivity. Twenty-nine extreme morning- and 34 evening-type participants underwent two fMRI sessions: about 1 h after wake-up time (morning) and about 10 h after wake-up time (evening), scheduled according to their declared habitual sleep-wake pattern on a regular working day. Analysis of obtained neuroimaging data disclosed only an effect of time of day on resting-state functional connectivity; there were different patterns of functional connectivity between morning (MS) and evening (ES) sessions. The results of our study showed no differences between extreme morning-type and evening-type individuals. We demonstrate that circadian and homeostatic influences on the resting-state functional connectivity have a universal character, unaffected by circadian typology.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fafrowicz2019beyond,
  author = {Magdalena Fąfrowicz and Bartosz Bohaterewicz and Anna Ceglarek and Monika Cichocka and Koryna Lewandowska and Barbara Sikora-Wachowicz and Halszka Ogińska and Anna Bereś and Justyna Olszewska and Tadeusz Marek},
  title = {{Beyond the Low Frequency Fluctuations: Morning and Evening Differences in Human Brain}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Neuroscience},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fnhum.2019.00288},
}
Figure