Beyond the Horizon Distance: LIGO-Virgo can Boost Gravitational-Wave Detection Rates by Exploiting the Mass Distribution of Neutron Stars

I. Bartos, Szabolcs MárkaPhysical 2015 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The masses of neutron stars in neutron star binaries are observed to fall in a narrow mass range around $\sim 1.33 M_{\odot}$. We explore the advantage of focusing on this region of the parameter space in gravitational-wave searches. We find that an all-sky (externally triggered) search with an optimally reduced template bank is expected to detect 14% (61%) more binary mergers than without the reduction. A reduced template bank can also represent significant improvement in technical cost. We also develop a more detailed search method using binary mass distribution, and find a sensitivity increase similar to that due to the reduced template bank.

Introduction: The Statistical Challenge of Gravitational-Wave Detection

Detecting gravitational waves (GWs) from binary neutron star mergers is a formidable "needle-in-a-haystack" challenge. Current detectors like LIGO and Virgo employ "matched filtering," a technique that compares incoming data against a "template bank"—a library containing hundreds of thousands of theoretical waveforms.

A significant hurdle in this process is the trial factor. As the number of templates searched increases, so does the probability that random detector noise will mimic a signal. To maintain a low false-alarm rate, researchers must set a high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) threshold for a definitive discovery. Historically, these template banks covered a broad theoretical mass range (roughly 1 to 3 $M_{\odot}$). However, astronomical observations of galactic pulsars suggest that neutron stars in binaries are not distributed uniformly; they cluster tightly around $1.33 M_{\odot}$. Searching for unlikely mass combinations (e.g., a 2.5 $M_{\odot}$ neutron star) imposes a statistical "noise penalty" that reduces the overall sensitivity of the search.

Methodology: Exploiting Astrophysical Priors

The authors propose two primary strategies to leverage the known mass distribution of neutron stars to improve detection efficiency:

  1. Reduced Template Banks: By constraining the search to templates within specific confidence intervals (e.g., 99%) of the observed mass distribution, the trial factor is significantly reduced.
  2. Weighted Likelihood-Ratio Test: This more sophisticated approach retains the full template bank but assigns higher statistical weights (priors) to signals matching the "likely" mass range in the ranking statistic.

The study utilized an empirical mass distribution modeled as a Gaussian-like curve centered at $1.33 M_{\odot}$ with a narrow spread ($\sigma = 0.11$). These methods were evaluated for both all-sky searches (continuous, blind monitoring) and externally triggered searches (targeted searches following a Gamma-Ray Burst or neutrino detection).

Figure 1: Comparison of the full template bank (grey) with reduced banks optimized for all-sky (orange) and externally triggered (blue) searches based on observed neutron star mass distributions.

Key Results and Statistical Efficiency

The core insight of this research is that reducing the search space enhances statistical power. By checking fewer "wrong" answers, the SNR threshold required for a valid detection can be lowered. For all-sky searches, the SNR threshold drops from 8.0 to 7.6. For triggered searches, where the trial factor is already smaller due to known timing and location, the impact is even more pronounced, with the threshold dropping from 4.7 to 3.9.

Figure 3: Expected detection rate improvement ($R/R_0$) as a function of false alarm probability for different search strategies. The 'weighted' and 'cutoff' methods significantly outperform the baseline, especially for externally triggered (extrig) searches.

The quantitative gains are substantial:

  • Detection Boost: An optimized all-sky search yields a 14% increase in expected detections. For externally triggered searches, the boost reaches 61%.
  • Computational Savings: Beyond sensitivity gains, the reduced bank requires only 3% to 6% of the original computational resources, facilitating faster real-time analysis.

Discussion and Limitations

While focusing on the $1.33 M_{\odot}$ peak maximizes the detection rate for "normal" neutron stars, it introduces a slight risk of missing "black swan" events—rare systems with outlier masses. However, the authors argue that the statistical gain in finding the majority population far outweighs the risk of missing rare exceptions.

Future work could refine these models by accounting for potential mass correlations in binaries. Furthermore, as the catalog of detected Black Hole-Neutron Star (BHNS) and Binary Black Hole (BBH) mergers grows, similar astrophysical priors could be applied to boost detection rates in those sectors as well. This approach demonstrates that "smarter" searching, informed by existing astronomical data, can be as effective as increasing detector hardware sensitivity.

Summary updated

Abstract

The masses of neutron stars in neutron star binaries are observed to fall in a narrow mass range around ∼1.33M_{⊙}. We explore the advantage of focusing on this region of the parameter space in gravitational-wave searches. We find that an all-sky (externally triggered) search with an optimally reduced template bank is expected to detect 14% (61%) more binary mergers than without the reduction. A reduced template bank can also represent significant improvement in technical cost. We also develop a more detailed search method using binary mass distribution, and find a sensitivity increase similar to that due to the reduced template bank.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bartos2015beyond,
  author = {I. Bartos and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{Beyond the Horizon Distance: LIGO-Virgo can Boost Gravitational-Wave Detection Rates by Exploiting the Mass Distribution of Neutron Stars}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.115.231101},
}
Figure