TL;DR
This paper introduces "best-effort" policies for stochastic planning problems, extending the concept of "strong-cyclic" policies. These new policies are designed to maximize the probability of achieving a goal, even when guaranteed success is impossible, and are shown to be robust to changes in underlying probabilities as long as the possible outcomes remain the same.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Planning in environments where outcomes are not fully predictable (nondeterministic or stochastic) is a fundamental challenge in AI. Traditional approaches like "strong plans" aim for guaranteed goal achievement, but these often don't exist. "Strong-cyclic policies" offer a weaker guarantee, allowing for trial-and-error strategies that eventually succeed. However, even these can fail if the goal is fundamentally unreachable with certainty. This paper addresses the scenario where goals might not be achievable with probability 1, but we still want to perform "as well as possible." They introduce "best-effort" policies that aim to maximize the chance of success, or at least ensure a non-zero probability of success, by leveraging the stochastic nature of the environment. This is particularly relevant for temporally extended goals (like those expressed in Linear Temporal Logic - LTL) where simple fairness assumptions are insufficient.
Methods
The core contribution is the formalization of "stochastic best-effort" (SBE) policies. These policies are defined by comparing their performance against all possible alternative policies from any given state. An SBE policy achieves the highest possible value, where "value" is defined as:
- +1 if the policy almost surely achieves the goal from that state.
- -1 if the policy almost surely fails to achieve the goal from that state.
- 0 otherwise (i.e., the probability of achieving the goal is between 0 and 1, exclusive).
The paper proves that SBE policies always exist. They also establish that optimal policies (those maximizing goal achievement probability) are a subset of SBE policies, but the converse is not true. A key insight is that SBE policies are robust: a policy that is SBE for one stochastic realization of a nondeterministic domain is also SBE for other realizations with the same possible outcomes (support), even if the probabilities differ. This leads to a method for "generalized planning" where a single SBE policy can work across a family of similar stochastic domains. The proposed algorithm involves constructing a simple, bounded, Markovian stochastic domain (like an MDP) from the common support of the family of domains and then finding an optimal policy for this constructed domain, which is guaranteed to be an SBE policy for all domains in the family.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical formalisms and algorithms rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- "Doing your best" is a well-defined concept: Even when guaranteed success is impossible, we can formally define and find policies that maximize the probability of success or at least keep the possibility open.
- SBE policies are robust: The core idea is that SBE policies are resilient to changes in the exact probabilities of stochastic outcomes, as long as the set of possible outcomes (the "support") remains the same. This is crucial for real-world applications where probability estimates might be imprecise.
- Generalized planning via abstraction: The paper shows how to solve generalized planning problems (finding a single policy for a family of similar stochastic domains) by abstracting to a simple, representative domain (like an MDP) and solving for optimality there.
- SBE policies always exist: Unlike optimal policies, which may not exist, SBE policies are guaranteed to be found, offering a practical fallback.
Key Results
- Theorem 1: Stochastic best-effort (SBE) policies always exist for any planning problem (stochastic domain + goal).
- Theorem 2: Optimal policies are always SBE policies.
- Theorem 3: If a policy almost-surely enforces a goal in a stochastic domain, then it is an SBE policy if and only if it almost-surely enforces the goal.
- Theorem 4: For generalized planning problems (a family of similar stochastic domains), there exists a finite-state SBE policy that can be computed from the common support and the goal specification. This policy is SBE for all domains in the family.
- Algorithm: A concrete algorithm is provided to compute such a generalized SBE policy by constructing a representative MDP and finding its optimal policy.
Limitations and Future Work
- Bounded Domains and Markovian Support: The generalized planning results (Theorem 4) rely on the assumption that the stochastic domains are bounded and have Markovian support. The paper notes that removing these assumptions can lead to scenarios where generalized policies do not exist or are not finite-state (Remark 2).
- Computational Complexity: While the paper provides an algorithm, the computational complexity of finding optimal policies in the constructed MDPs is not explicitly detailed, which could be a practical consideration.
- Future Work: The paper suggests that the framework can be extended to more complex scenarios, and the robustness of SBE policies could be further explored in settings with imprecise probability information. The connection to reactive synthesis and games on graphs is also highlighted as an area for further research.
Summary updated