TL;DR
This paper critiques the traditional, often exploitative concept of "service" and proposes a reimagined framework based on care, autonomy, and mutual exchange. Through a curation of global artistic projects, the authors demonstrate how art can act as a "solvent" for normative power structures, fostering a collective consciousness that transcends capitalistic and colonial hierarchies.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The authors tackle the inherent "unequal power structure" in the concept of service, which is etymologically rooted in subjugation (servitium or slavery). In modern contexts, they argue that "service" has been co-opted by a capitalistic model that quantifies everything—from natural environments (ecosystem services) to human health (patients as "customers").
This commodification leads to several issues:
- Paternalism: Humanitarian efforts often risk being one-sided rather than grounded in reciprocity.
- Alienation: Hyper-individualism and market-driven interactions erode genuine community bonds.
- Epistemic Injustice: Marginalized voices and "more-than-human" species are often silenced or ignored in traditional service frameworks.
The paper seeks to move "beyond service" toward an ethics of care that distributes agency and acknowledges the interdependency of all living things.
Methods
This is a theoretical and curatorial essay rather than a traditional experimental study. The authors employ a multidisciplinary framework that synthesizes:
- Philosophical Analysis: Drawing on Hegel’s Master-Slave dialectic, Gramsci’s "organic intellectuals," and Paul B. Preciado’s concept of art as a "solvent" for normative frameworks.
- Posthumanist Theory: Utilizing the work of Donna Haraway, Anna Tsing, and María Puig de la Bellacasa to decenter the human subject.
- Case Study Curation: Analyzing specific artistic projects through a taxonomy of "keywords": Community, Collectivity, Exchange, Guardianship, Ownership, Accountability, and Advocacy.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper (as this is a qualitative, theoretical work). The "data" consists of the documented outcomes and methodologies of the featured artistic projects.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Service vs. Care: While "service" often reinforces a hierarchy between provider and recipient, "care" requires reciprocity, trust, and the reinstatement of autonomy for the marginalized.
- Architecture as Process: Projects like Structures of Mutual Support (Furunes & Khadka) redefine architecture not as the delivery of a finished building, but as a participatory exercise in communal labor (drawing on traditions like the Filipino bayanihan or Norwegian dugnad).
- Art as Legal Evidence: In The Sovereign Forest, Amar Kanwar uses poetry, seeds, and films as "evidence" in a public trial against environmental crimes, challenging the narrow definitions of what constitutes valid testimony in legal systems.
- Decolonizing the "Table": Artist Yee I-Lann juxtaposes the meja (the administrative table of colonial power) with the tikar (the egalitarian woven mat), suggesting that to decolonize is to reclaim communal, ground-level spaces of interaction.
- Biocultural Paradigms: Ursula Biemann’s work with the Inga people in the Amazon highlights the "biocultural paradigm," where biological and epistemic diversity are seen as inseparable, leading to the co-creation of an Indigenous University.
Key Results
The paper presents qualitative evidence of art’s ability to effectuate social and political change:
- Policy Impact: Martha Atienza’s collaboration with fisherfolk in the Philippines led to the establishment of a Marine Protected Area and the official declaration of "Fisherfolks’ Day."
- Knowledge Platforms: Ahmet Öğüt’s The Silent University successfully created a solidarity-based exchange for displaced people, operating outside the restrictions of migration laws and bureaucratic hurdles.
- Visualizing the Invisible: The INTERPRT project used 3D modeling to visualize the potential devastation of deep-sea mining, providing a tool for environmental accountability that counters industry "greenwashing."
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that these artistic interventions often operate within privatized cultural or academic institutions, which can present their own structural challenges.
Future directions include: * Continuing to refine a language that engenders a "constellation of care" beyond traditional service. * Further exploring how "shared responsibility can galvanize and translate into agency" across different spatial and social dimensions. * Expanding the "more-than-human" perspective to ensure that environmental stewardship is not just another form of human-centric management.
Summary updated