Beyond Mechanical Tension: A Review of Resistance Exercise-Induced Lactate Responses & Muscle Hypertrophy

Daniel J. Lawson, Christopher G. Vann, Brad J. Schöenfeld, Cody T. HaunJournal of Functional Morphology and Kinesiology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This review challenges the long-held view of lactate as a mere metabolic waste product, presenting evidence that it may play a crucial role in signaling for skeletal muscle hypertrophy. By synthesizing current research, the authors propose that lactate, beyond its role as an energy substrate, can act as an anabolic agent, influencing key signaling pathways that promote muscle growth.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, lactate has been primarily associated with muscle fatigue and "the burn" during intense exercise, often viewed as a byproduct of anaerobic metabolism. This perspective has largely overshadowed any potential beneficial roles it might play. This review addresses the gap in understanding lactate's function beyond its role as a metabolic fuel, specifically investigating its potential contribution to skeletal muscle hypertrophy, a key adaptation to resistance training. The authors aim to consolidate emerging research that suggests lactate might actively participate in anabolic signaling pathways, challenging the traditional view and opening new avenues for exercise science research and application.

Methods

This paper is a comprehensive review of existing literature, not an experimental study. The authors synthesized findings from a wide range of research, including:

  • In vitro studies: Experiments using cell cultures (e.g., C2C12 myoblasts) to investigate the direct effects of lactate on cellular processes related to muscle growth.
  • In vivo animal studies: Research involving animal models (e.g., mice, rats) where lactate was administered to assess its impact on muscle mass, regeneration, and signaling pathways.
  • Human studies: Investigations examining blood lactate levels in response to various resistance training protocols and, in some cases, assessing the effects of exogenous lactate administration on signaling pathways.
  • Literature synthesis and analysis: The core methodology involves critically evaluating and integrating findings from numerous peer-reviewed articles to build a cohesive narrative and identify trends, contradictions, and areas for future research.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Lactate as a Signaling Molecule: The most significant insight is the shift in perspective from lactate as a waste product to a signaling molecule that can influence cellular processes related to muscle growth.
  • Anabolic Pathways Activated by Lactate: Lactate appears to activate key anabolic signaling pathways, including the Akt/mTOR pathway and MAPK/ERK signaling, which are known to promote muscle protein synthesis.
  • Satellite Cell Modulation: Lactate may influence satellite cell activity, which is crucial for muscle repair, maintenance, and growth.
  • Epigenetic Modifications: Emerging evidence suggests lactate can induce epigenetic modifications, such as histone lactylation, which can alter gene expression related to muscle adaptation.
  • Resistance Training Protocols and Lactate: Certain resistance training protocols, particularly those involving higher repetitions and shorter rest periods, are more effective at eliciting significant blood lactate accumulation, potentially enhancing these anabolic signaling effects.
  • Historical Misconception: The review highlights how historical misunderstandings about lactic acid versus lactate have contributed to its negative perception.

Key Results

The review synthesizes findings from numerous studies, indicating that:

  • In vitro: Lactate exposure in cell cultures has been shown to increase markers of muscle protein synthesis (e.g., myogenin, Fst), activate signaling pathways (e.g., Akt, mTOR), and influence satellite cell proliferation and differentiation.
  • In vivo (animal studies): Lactate administration in animals has led to increased muscle mass, enhanced muscle regeneration after injury, and modulated anabolic signaling pathways.
  • Human studies: Resistance training protocols that elicit higher blood lactate levels (often exceeding 10 mmol/L) are associated with greater anabolic signaling responses. However, direct evidence of lactate-induced hypertrophy in humans is still limited, with some studies showing no additional benefit from exogenous lactate infusion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Translational Gap: A significant limitation is the difficulty in directly translating findings from in vitro and animal studies to human physiology. The concentrations and durations of lactate exposure in some experimental settings are not easily achievable or sustainable during typical human exercise.
  • Conflicting Findings: The review acknowledges conflicting results across studies, particularly regarding the precise mechanisms and the extent to which lactate influences hypertrophy in humans.
  • Measurement Challenges: While blood lactate is commonly measured, understanding intramuscular lactate dynamics and its direct correlation with signaling responses remains an area needing further investigation.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors emphasize the need for more human studies to:
  • Clarify the exact mechanisms by which lactate influences muscle hypertrophy.
  • Determine optimal resistance training protocols for maximizing lactate accumulation and subsequent anabolic signaling.
  • Investigate the role of endogenous lactate production versus exogenous administration.
  • Explore the interplay between mechanical tension and lactate-induced signaling for synergistic hypertrophy effects.
  • Further investigate the role of lactate in epigenetic modifications related to muscle adaptation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The present review aims to explore and discuss recent research relating to the lactate response to resistance training and the potential mechanisms by which lactate may contribute to skeletal muscle hypertrophy or help to prevent muscle atrophy. First, we will discuss foundational information pertaining to lactate including metabolism, measurement, shuttling, and potential (although seemingly elusive) mechanisms for hypertrophy. We will then provide a brief analysis of resistance training protocols and the associated lactate response. Lastly, we will discuss potential shortcomings, resistance training considerations, and future research directions regarding lactate's role as a potential anabolic agent for skeletal muscle hypertrophy.
BibTeX
@article{lawson2022beyond,
  author = {Daniel J. Lawson and Christopher G. Vann and Brad J. Schöenfeld and Cody T. Haun},
  title = {{Beyond Mechanical Tension: A Review of Resistance Exercise-Induced Lactate Responses \& Muscle Hypertrophy}},
  journal = {Journal of Functional Morphology and Kinesiology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jfmk7040081},
}
Figure