Beyond Elevation: New Metrics to Quantify the Relief of Mountains and Surfaces of Any Terrestrial Body

Kai XuarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper proposes a new framework for quantifying topographic relief using "datumless measures"—metrics that rely on local gravity and surface geometry rather than arbitrary sea-level references. By introducing four key metrics—dominance, jut, submission, and rut—the author provides a universal language to objectively compare the "impressiveness" and scale of landforms across Earth, the Moon, Mars, and asteroids.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For centuries, "elevation" has been our primary yardstick for mountains. However, elevation is fundamentally flawed as a measure of relief. On Earth, it depends on a "vertical datum" (sea level) that is subject to shifting conventions. On planets like Mars or asteroids like Vesta, there is no sea level, leading scientists to define "zero" arbitrarily.

Furthermore, elevation fails to describe a landform's relationship with its surroundings. A peak at 4,000m elevation might be a massive wall rising from the sea, or it might be a small hill sitting on a 3,900m plateau. Existing alternatives, like "topographic prominence," help but still rely on the existence of higher peaks to define a mountain's stature. The author seeks a physics-based, "datumless" approach that works anywhere in the universe.

Methods

The author treats a planet as a manifold-with-boundary and defines the planetary surface ($S$) based on gravity. Instead of measuring height from an imaginary ellipsoid, the paper uses:

  1. Equipotential Surfaces & Plumblines: Using the local direction of gravity to define "up" and "horizontal" at every specific point.
  2. Angle-Reduced Height ($z'$): A novel formula ($z' = z \cdot |\sin \theta|$) that combines vertical height ($z$) with the angle of elevation ($\theta$). This captures "visual impressiveness"—a cliff is more impressive than a gentle slope of the same height.
  3. The Four Metrics:
    • Dominance: The maximum height a point rises above the horizontal plane of any other point in its vicinity. It measures "base-to-peak" stature.
  4. Jut: The maximum angle-reduced height. It quantifies how sharply a peak rises (e.g., a steep 1,000m face vs. a gentle 1,000m slope).
  5. Submission: The inverse of dominance; how much the surroundings rise above a point (e.g., the depth of a canyon).
  6. Rut: The inverse of jut; how sharply the surroundings tower over a location (e.g., the "backdrop" effect in a mountain valley).

Datasets

The study validates these metrics using high-resolution Digital Elevation Models (DEMs) from several planetary bodies:

  • Earth: ALOS World 3D (30m resolution) and GEBCO bathymetry.
  • Moon: LRO LOLA (118m resolution).
  • Mars: MOLA-HRSC Blended (200m resolution).
  • Vesta: Dawn FC HAMO (93m resolution).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Base" is Found, Not Defined: Unlike prominence, which requires identifying a "key col," dominance automatically finds a mountain's "base"—the point in the surroundings that makes the peak look the tallest.
  • Visual Impressiveness as Math: The "Jut" metric provides a simpler, more geometrically intuitive alternative to the "Omnidirectional Relief and Steepness" (ORS) index. It effectively identifies the "steepest, tallest" part of a mountain.
  • Planetary Scaling: The paper confirms that smaller planetary bodies (like Vesta) support much higher relief than Earth because their lower gravity allows massive structures to exist without collapsing under their own weight.
  • Symmetry of Relief: The relationship between dominance/submission and jut/rut creates a complete toolkit for describing any point on a surface, whether it's a summit, a valley floor, or a city in the foothills.

Key Results

  • Earth's Champions: Mount Everest holds the highest dominance (8,081m), but the highest "Jut" (visual impressiveness) belongs to Annapurna Fang (~3,400m), thanks to its massive, steep Southwest Face.
  • The "Dry" Perspective: When removing Earth's oceans, an unnamed seamount near Guam has a "dry dominance" of 10,284m—taller than Everest's base-to-peak height.
  • Mars vs. Earth: While Olympus Mons has a staggering dominance of 14,175m, its "Jut" is relatively low (947m) because it is a very gently sloping shield volcano. It is huge, but not "sharp."
  • Vesta's Ruggedness: The asteroid Vesta is the most rugged body studied. Its central peak in the Rheasilvia crater has a dominance of over 16,000m, dwarfing anything on Earth or Mars.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Intensity: Calculating these metrics for every point on a global DEM is computationally expensive, though the author suggests optimizations by limiting the search radius.
  • Gravity Modeling: The accuracy of the metrics depends on high-quality geoid/areoid models (gravity maps). For bodies like the Moon, where a geoid isn't always used, the author had to approximate gravity as pointing toward the center of mass.
  • Ruggedness Indices: The author suggests that future work could involve averaging these measures over entire regions to create a standardized "Ruggedness Index" for planetary surfaces.

Summary updated

Abstract

Elevation has long been the standard for quantifying the relief of mountains and other landforms on Earth and beyond. Nevertheless, elevation has its limitations. By itself, a location's elevation reveals little about its vertical position relative to its surroundings, especially for seabed and extraterrestrial features. Furthermore, on planets and asteroids without a sea level, the zero-elevation datum is defined rather arbitrarily, making elevation values rather meaningless without also considering relative elevation differences. In light of these factors, this paper introduces new topographic measures based purely on gravity and the actual planetary surface, rather than on an arbitrary datum. Unlike elevation, the so-called datumless measures -- with the names of dominance, jut, submission, and rut -- each describe a different aspect about a location's vertical position relative to its surroundings. They can be used to objectively compare the relief of mountains and other landforms, including across different planets. The datumless measures may be of interest to planetary scientists seeking universally standardized measures of relief, Earth scientists seeking to correlate geomorphological properties with natural phenomena, as well as mountaineers and hobbyists seeking new ways to describe the wondrous landscapes of this universe.
BibTeX
@misc{xu2022beyond,
  author = {Kai Xu},
  title = {{Beyond Elevation: New Metrics to Quantify the Relief of Mountains and Surfaces of Any Terrestrial Body}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2208.01600},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.01600},
}

Loading related content...

Figure