Bewegungsversorgung im deutschen Gesundheitssystem: gesundheitspolitische Relevanz und notwendige Rahmenbedingungen – ein Positionspapier der AG Bewegungsbezogene Versorgungsforschung des DNVF

Andrea Schaller, Christian Thiel, Stefan Peters, Wolfgang Geidl, Klamroth Sarah, Martin Lange, Sabrina Kastaun, Sonja Krupp, Heike Spaderna, Katharina Eckert, Marion Grafe, Claudia Voelcker‐Rehage, Gisela Nellessen-Martens, Klaus Pfeifer, Gorden Sudeck, Joachim Wiskemann, Bettina Wollesen, Lars GabrysDas 2024 · DOI

Despite overwhelming evidence that physical activity is a "best buy" for public health, the German healthcare system currently fails to systematically integrate it into routine patient care. This position paper, developed by the DNVF (German Network for Health Services Research) Working Group on Physical Activity-Related Health Services Research, outlines a strategic roadmap to bridge this gap. By professionalizing exercise services, fostering interprofessional collaboration, and embedding exercise expertise directly into clinical guidelines, the authors argue that the German system can move from generic advice to evidence-based, high-quality care.

The "Prevention Paradox" and the Care Gap

The German healthcare landscape is currently characterized by a "prevention paradox." While there is a broad consensus that "exercise is medicine," the actual delivery of physical activity-related health services remains fragmented, underfunded, and largely confined to the inpatient sector. In the outpatient sector, exercise recommendations are often vague—generic suggestions to "move more" rather than specific, evidence-based prescriptions with defined dosages (intensity, frequency, and duration).

This "care gap" is exacerbated by a lack of structural "plumbing." There is significant ambiguity regarding which professional groups—physicians, physiotherapists, or sports scientists—should deliver these services, how they should interact, and how they should be reimbursed.

A Biopsychosocial Framework for Exercise Therapy

To address these structural issues, the DNVF working group utilizes the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) and biopsychosocial models to define a multi-dimensional framework for exercise therapy.

The biopsychosocial model of exercise therapy, emphasizing the interplay between training, learning, and experiencing for the participant.

As shown in Figure 4, exercise therapy is not merely about physical fitness. It is a holistic intervention that addresses:

  • Training/Exercising: The physical and motor components of health.
  • Learning: The cognitive and motor skills required for long-term behavior change.
  • Experiencing: The affective-emotional and cognitive responses to movement.

This approach aims to improve a participant's "coping competence" and overall functional health, moving beyond a purely biomedical view of disease.

Strategic Positions for Systemic Reform

The position paper culminates in three central strategic pillars designed to improve healthcare delivery through physical activity.

The three pillars of the DNVF strategy: interdisciplinary dissemination, strengthening exercise professions, and systematic guideline integration.

1. Interprofessional Integration and "Movement Literacy"

The authors advocate for the "Make Every Contact Count" principle. Every healthcare professional—including nurses, psychotherapists, and physicians—should possess "basic movement literacy." Every patient interaction represents an opportunity to screen for physical inactivity and provide brief, motivational counseling. This requires integrating basic exercise competencies into the standard training and continuing education of all health professions.

2. Strengthening Exercise-Specific Professions

There is a critical need to clarify the roles and legal frameworks for exercise-specific professions, such as sports scientists and academicized physiotherapists. The paper highlights an "academicization gap" in Germany; while most of Europe requires university-level training for physiotherapists (EQR Level 6), Germany still relies heavily on vocational training (EQR Level 4). Higher-level clinical reasoning is essential for managing complex chronic diseases. Furthermore, the authors call for "direct access" models and robust reimbursement for both individual and group-based interventions.

3. Systematic Integration into Clinical Guidelines

Clinical guidelines (MLL) must move beyond peripheral mentions of exercise. They should include specific quality criteria, evidence-based "dosages," and clear referral pathways. Exercise expertise must be systematically represented in the development of these guidelines to ensure that physical activity is treated as a core therapeutic pillar rather than an optional add-on.

Implementation Barriers and Future Directions

The transition to a movement-oriented healthcare system faces several systemic hurdles. Germany currently suffers from a skilled labor shortage, meaning that even with perfect policy, there may not be enough trained professionals to implement these services nationwide. Additionally, current reimbursement codes (such as §20 SGB V) are often too rigid for the continuous, long-term care required by geriatric or multi-morbid patients.

Future research must shift from "what works" to "how do we make it work here?" Implementation science is needed to develop effective "exercise referral schemes" tailored to the specificities of the German outpatient sector.

Conclusion

While the clinical evidence for exercise is undeniable, its integration into the German healthcare system requires a goal-oriented process involving politicians, insurers, and practitioners. By adopting the strategic pillars outlined by the DNVF, Germany can transform physical activity-related health services into a cost-effective, high-quality component of modern medicine.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on the relevance of an established and broad foundation of physical activity in healthcare, this position paper of the DNVF working group Physical Activity-Related Health Services research presents current conceptual approaches to physical activity-related health services in Germany and highlights the need for interprofessional and interdisciplinary approaches. Three central positions are outlined and elaborated in order to integrate the evidence on health benefits of physical activity and exercise more strongly into healthcare and to show that, against the background of the challenges in the German healthcare system, physical activity-related health services can make a cost-effective and high-quality contribution to improve healthcare. These three positions include 1) the integration of all professional groups involved in healthcare into physical activity-related health services, 2) the greater integration of physical activity professions and physical activity interventions into all healthcare contexts and 3) the systematic consideration of physical activity- and exercise-related expertise in clinical guidelines.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schaller2024bewegungsversorgung,
  author = {Andrea Schaller and Christian Thiel and Stefan Peters and Wolfgang Geidl and Klamroth Sarah and Martin Lange and Sabrina Kastaun and Sonja Krupp and Heike Spaderna and Katharina Eckert and Marion Grafe and Claudia Voelcker‐Rehage and Gisela Nellessen-Martens and Klaus Pfeifer and Gorden Sudeck and Joachim Wiskemann and Bettina Wollesen and Lars Gabrys},
  title = {{Bewegungsversorgung im deutschen Gesundheitssystem: gesundheitspolitische Relevanz und notwendige Rahmenbedingungen – ein Positionspapier der AG Bewegungsbezogene Versorgungsforschung des DNVF}},
  booktitle = {Das},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1055/a-2420-8793},
}
Figure