Abstract
Online communities have a love-hate relationship with membership growth: new members bring fresh perspectives, but old-timers worry that growth interrupts the community’s social dynamic and lowers content quality. To arbitrate these two theories, we analyze over 45 million comments from 10 Reddit subcommunities following an exogenous shock when each subcommunity was added to the default set for all Reddit users. Capitalizing on these natural experiments, we test for changes to the content vote patterns, linguistic patterns, and community network patterns before and after being defaulted. Results support a narrative that the communities remain high-quality and similar to their previous selves even post-growth. There is a temporary dip in upvote scores right after the communities were defaulted, but the communities quickly recover to pre-default or even higher levels. Likewise, complaints about low-quality posts do not rise in frequency after getting defaulted. Strong moderation also helps keep upvotes common and complaint levels low. Communities’ language use does not become more like the rest of Reddit after getting defaulted. However, growth does have some impact on attention: community members cluster their activity around a smaller proportion of posts after the community is defaulted.
Introduction
In internet lore, the "Eternal September" refers to the moment in 1993 when America Online (AOL) opened the floodgates to Usenet, permanently diluting the community's established norms with a never-ending wave of "clueless" newcomers. This highlights a classic tension in social computing: while growth brings vitality, it also threatens the "MTV Effect"—the idea that to grow, a community must become more generic and mainstream, alienating the "old-timers" who built it. This paper investigates whether massive, sudden growth inevitably ruins an online community’s culture by analyzing the impact of Reddit's "defaulting" process.
Methods and Datasets
The researchers treated Reddit’s "defaulting" process as a natural experiment. Until 2017, Reddit admins selected specific subreddits to be "defaults," meaning every new user was automatically subscribed to them. This created a sudden, massive "exogenous shock" of new members.
The study utilized the Reddit comment dataset via Google BigQuery, focusing on 10 subreddits defaulted in 2013 and 2014 (including r/ExplainLikeImFive, r/ShowerThoughts, and r/EarthPorn). The dataset comprised approximately 45.7 million comments spanning six years (January 2011 to September 2016). Non-defaulted subreddits, such as r/Facepalm, were used as a comparison group to control for site-wide shifts.
To analyze the impact, the team used:
- Regression Analysis: To track changes in average comment scores and "complaint rates" (identified via the Empath lexicon tool) before, during, and after the growth spurt.
- Linguistic Modeling: Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) was used to create topic distributions, comparing subreddits to the rest of Reddit to detect "genericization."
- Network Analysis: Co-comment graphs were constructed to calculate the power-law exponent ($\alpha$) of the degree distribution, measuring how users cluster around content.
Key Insights
The "Dip and Recover" Pattern
Communities demonstrated remarkable resilience. While they experienced a temporary "shock" where upvote scores dropped by an average of 0.34 points during the defaulting phase, they typically recovered to—or even exceeded—pre-growth quality levels within months, rising 0.30 points above baseline in the "after" phase. Surprisingly, the percentage of complaint comments actually decreased significantly after the growth shock.
Identity Stickiness and the Role of Moderation
Contrary to the "MTV Effect" theory, subreddits did not become more like "generic Reddit." They maintained their specific linguistic fingerprints, suggesting that newcomers acculturate to the community rather than the community diluting for the newcomers. A critical factor in this stability was moderation. Subreddits with high moderation activity (measured by the proportion of deleted comments) saw significantly higher average scores and lower complaint levels.
The Attention Squeeze
The most significant change was structural rather than content-based. As communities grow, the "interaction exponent" ($\alpha$) decreases as a power function of Monthly Active Users (MAU). This indicates that users cluster more densely around a smaller proportion of posts—likely a survival mechanism for dealing with information overload in a much larger community.
Discussion and Limitations
While the results suggest that communities can survive massive growth, several caveats remain. The subreddits studied were already high-quality and broad-interest; niche communities might react differently. Additionally, the results are tied to Reddit’s specific voting and ranking algorithms, which might buffer communities in ways that other platforms do not. Future research should employ cohort analysis to determine if original members eventually leave or change their behavior, even if aggregate metrics remain healthy. Finally, it remains unclear if the recovery in scores is due to actual content improvement or simply new users outvoting disgruntled old-timers.
Summary updated