Better together: Integrating biomedical informatics and healthcare <scp>IT</scp> operations to create a learning health system during the <scp>COVID</scp>‐19 pandemic

Philip Payne, Adam Wilcox, Peter J. Embí, Chris LonghurstLearning 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues that integrating Biomedical Informatics (BMI) and Healthcare Information Technology (HIT) is crucial for creating effective "learning health systems." The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted how this synergy allows for rapid, data-driven responses to public health crises, ultimately improving patient care and outcomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses a growing disconnect between academic Biomedical Informatics (BMI) and operational Healthcare Information Technology (HIT) within academic health systems. While historically intertwined, these fields have become increasingly siloed, with BMI often seen as purely academic and HIT as a service function. This separation hinders the efficient translation of research findings into actionable clinical practice and limits the system's ability to leverage its vast data resources for continuous improvement. The COVID-19 pandemic exposed the critical need for better integration to enable rapid responses to emergent health challenges.

Methods

This paper is a position paper, not a traditional empirical study. The authors' "method" involves:

  • Conceptual Framework Development: Proposing three core axioms for integrating BMI and HIT:
  • Treating data as a renewable resource with responsible access.
  • Enabling agile and timely translation of multi-scale data into actionable knowledge.
  • Establishing processes for rapid return of emergent knowledge to clinicians and patients.
  • Literature Review and Analysis: Examining existing literature and publications related to informatics and leadership prior to and during the COVID-19 pandemic to identify trends and evidence supporting their arguments.
  • Case Study Synthesis: Analyzing examples of successful BMI and HIT collaboration during the COVID-19 pandemic (presented in Table 1) to illustrate the benefits of integration.
  • Conceptual Model Design: Presenting a model (Figure 2) for a "rapid learning" healthcare system where BMI and HIT work synergistically across four key stages: Basic/Pre-Clinical Research, Optimization/Measurement, Verification/Validation, and Scaling/Delivery.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on analysis of existing literature and case examples rather than specific datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Data Age" Demands Integration: The explosion of biomedical data necessitates a unified approach to harness its potential for both research and operational improvement.
  • COVID-19 as a Catalyst: The pandemic served as a critical stress test, demonstrating that integrated BMI and HIT efforts lead to faster, more effective responses to public health emergencies.
  • Three Axioms for Success: The proposed axioms (data as a renewable resource, agile knowledge translation, and rapid knowledge dissemination) provide a roadmap for building learning health systems.
  • Synergy Over Silos: The paper strongly advocates that BMI and HIT are not competing but complementary fields that are "better together."
  • Beyond EHRs: Integration moves the Electronic Health Record (EHR) from a documentation tool to a platform that actively enhances care quality and stakeholder engagement.

Key Results

The paper presents qualitative findings and insights rather than quantitative results. Key outcomes highlighted include:

  • Demonstrable Positive Impact: Successful collaborations during COVID-19 led to rapid development and deployment of solutions for data capture, management, analysis, and healthcare delivery, filling critical data gaps.
  • Improved Responsiveness: Integrated teams were able to respond more effectively and efficiently to pandemic-related changes.
  • Evidence of Pre-existing Pathways: Successes were often linked to institutions with established communication and collaboration pathways between BMI and HIT, and sometimes shared leadership.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The authors acknowledge that the presented examples are from the "crucible" of the COVID-19 pandemic and that achieving this integration requires a fundamental shift in understanding and practice. The paper is a position piece, not an empirical validation of a specific intervention.
  • Future Work: The authors call for a community-wide dialogue to define and implement transformative changes in BMI and HIT leadership, thinking, and practice. They emphasize the need to realign organizational structures, incentives, funding models, and professional identities to realize the vision of a "rapid learning" health system. They also suggest efforts to raise this issue and its merits within broader clinical and health policy leadership settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

The growing availability of multi-scale biomedical data sources that can be used to enable research and improve healthcare delivery has brought about what can be described as a healthcare "data age." This new era is defined by the explosive growth in bio-molecular, clinical, and population-level data that can be readily accessed by researchers, clinicians, and decision-makers, and utilized for systems-level approaches to hypothesis generation and testing as well as operational decision-making. However, taking full advantage of these unprecedented opportunities presents an opportunity to revisit the alignment between traditionally academic biomedical informatics (BMI) and operational healthcare information technology (HIT) personnel and activities in academic health systems. While the history of the academic field of BMI includes active engagement in the delivery of operational HIT platforms, in many contemporary settings these efforts have grown distinct. Recent experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic have demonstrated greater coordination of BMI and HIT activities that have allowed organizations to respond to pandemic-related changes more effectively, with demonstrable and positive impact as a result. In this position paper, we discuss the challenges and opportunities associated with driving alignment between BMI and HIT, as viewed from the perspective of a learning healthcare system. In doing so, we hope to illustrate the benefits of coordination between BMI and HIT in terms of the quality, safety, and outcomes of care provided to patients and populations, demonstrating that these two groups can be "better together."
BibTeX
@inproceedings{payne2022better,
  author = {Philip Payne and Adam Wilcox and Peter J. Embí and Chris Longhurst},
  title = {{Better together: Integrating biomedical informatics and healthcare <scp>IT</scp> operations to create a learning health system during the <scp>COVID</scp>‐19 pandemic}},
  booktitle = {Learning},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1002/lrh2.10309},
}
Figure