Best-Effort Synthesis: Doing Your Best Is Not Harder Than Giving Up

Benjamin Aminof, Giuseppe De Giacomo, Sasha RubinIJCAI 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the problem of "best-effort synthesis" for agents interacting with environments, where the agent must perform optimally even if it cannot guarantee success. The key finding is that this "best-effort" synthesis problem has the same computational complexity (2EXPTIME-complete) as standard synthesis, meaning agents can be designed to do their best without a significant performance penalty.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the field of reactive synthesis, we aim to automatically generate strategies (decision-making policies) for an agent that interacts with an environment to achieve a specific goal. Traditionally, if an agent cannot guarantee achieving its goal under all possible environment behaviors (even considering known environment assumptions), synthesis algorithms simply "give up," declaring the task impossible. This paper addresses the scenario where the agent can't guarantee success but still needs to perform as well as possible. This "best-effort" approach is crucial when environments aren't purely adversarial, or when environment assumptions are over-approximations of reality. The authors want to know if synthesizing such "best-effort" strategies is computationally harder than standard synthesis.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in developing algorithms for best-effort synthesis. The authors leverage a strategy-based approach, which is contrasted with traditional trace-based methods. Their key technique involves constructing and solving games on automata, specifically Deterministic Parity Automata (DPAs) for Linear-time Temporal Logic (LTL) and Deterministic Finite Automata (DFAs) for LTL on finite traces (LTLf).

The algorithm for LTL (Algorithm A) involves:

  1. Translating specifications into automata: The goal and environment assumptions are converted into DPAs.
  2. Constructing a product automaton: A combined automaton representing the interaction of the goal and assumption is created.
  3. Solving multiple games on the product automaton:
    • A game is played to find a winning agent strategy for the goal under the assumption.
  4. Another game determines the environment's winning region (where it can enforce its assumptions).
  5. A third game, using a restricted environment, is solved for co-operatively winning strategies.
  6. Combining strategies: The strategies from these games are combined to form the final best-effort agent strategy.

For LTLf, a similar algorithm (Algorithm B) is presented, but it uses DFAs instead of DPAs, leading to simpler, linear-time building blocks for game solving.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Doing your best is not harder than giving up": The most significant insight is that the computational complexity of best-effort synthesis under environment assumptions is the same as standard synthesis (2EXPTIME-complete). This is a surprising and important result, as one might expect the added complexity of "doing your best" to increase the difficulty.
  • Strategy-based vs. Trace-based: The paper highlights the limitations of traditional trace-based synthesis when dealing with best-effort scenarios. A strategy-based approach, which considers how strategies dominate each other, is more appropriate.
  • Novel Game-Solving Technique: The algorithm's reliance on simultaneously playing multiple games on a product automaton, and then combining their results, is a novel technique for achieving best-effort synthesis.
  • LTLf Suitability: The LTLf version of the problem is particularly well-suited for implementation due to its reliance on simpler automata (DFAs) and more straightforward game-solving techniques.

Key Results

  • Complexity Result: Best-effort synthesis under environment assumptions for both LTL and LTLf is 2EXPTIME-complete. This establishes the tightest possible upper and lower bounds for this problem.
  • Optimal Algorithms: The paper provides algorithms for computing best-effort strategies for both LTL and LTLf. The LTLf algorithm is noted for its use of simpler graph-algorithm building blocks, making it more amenable to implementation.
  • Existence of Best-Effort Strategies: The paper confirms that best-effort strategies always exist, even if enforcing strategies do not.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Environment Assumption: The current framework focuses on a single environment assumption. Future work could explore scenarios with multiple, potentially conflicting, environment assumptions.
  • LTLf Implementation: While the LTLf algorithm is described as well-suited for implementation, the paper does not present an actual implementation or empirical evaluation.
  • Comparison to Existing Work: The paper acknowledges that its work is closely related to prior research on best-effort synthesis and synthesis under assumptions, but it aims to unify these concepts and establish their exact complexity. Further exploration of the nuances between their approach and existing ones, particularly in multi-agent settings, could be beneficial.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{aminof2021best,
  author = {Benjamin Aminof and Giuseppe De Giacomo and Sasha Rubin},
  title = {{Best-Effort Synthesis: Doing Your Best Is Not Harder Than Giving Up}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2021/243},
}
Figure