Berrut Approximated Coded Computing: Straggler Resistance Beyond Polynomial Computing

Tayyebeh Jahani-Nezhad, Mohammad Ali Maddah-AliIEEE TPAMI 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Berrut Approximated Coded Computing (BACC), a novel distributed computing framework designed to overcome the "straggler effect" in large-scale machine learning. BACC offers a numerically stable and efficient way to approximate arbitrary functions, not just polynomials, making it applicable to a wider range of complex tasks like deep learning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Training complex machine learning models, especially deep neural networks, often requires massive datasets and significant computational resources. Distributing this workload across multiple servers is a common solution. However, a major bottleneck arises from "stragglers" – worker nodes that are significantly slower than others. In traditional distributed systems, the entire computation must wait for the slowest node, drastically slowing down the overall process.

Existing solutions, like coded computing, aim to mitigate this by introducing redundancy. These methods allow the final result to be recovered from a subset of worker outputs, even if some are delayed. However, current coded computing approaches have several limitations:

  1. Limited Functionality: They are primarily designed for polynomial functions or matrix operations, excluding many non-linear functions crucial for modern ML.
  2. Scalability Issues: The number of required servers can grow prohibitively with the degree of the polynomial or the complexity of the computation.
  3. Numerical Instability: Many methods rely on techniques that are unstable when working with real numbers, leading to accuracy issues.

This paper tackles these limitations by proposing BACC, a method that is numerically stable, handles arbitrary functions, and is more scalable.

Methods

BACC builds upon the concept of Berrut's Rational Interpolation, a technique known for its numerical stability and ability to approximate functions. The core idea is to encode the input data and distribute it to worker nodes. Each worker node then computes a function of its assigned coded data. The master node, upon receiving results from a subset of the fastest workers, uses Berrut's rational interpolation to approximate the final desired output.

Key aspects of the BACC method include:

  • Encoding: The master node creates coded data by mapping raw inputs (e.g., data samples or model parameters) to a rational function. This function is designed to be evaluated at specific points (Chebyshev points of the first kind are suggested for encoding).
  • Distributed Computation: Worker nodes receive these coded inputs and apply the target function (e.g., computing gradients in deep learning). They are assigned specific evaluation points (Chebyshev points of the second kind are suggested for worker assignments).
  • Decoding: The master node collects results from the non-straggling workers. It then uses Berrut's rational interpolant to reconstruct an approximation of the original function's output. This interpolation is performed on the results from the available workers, effectively bypassing the need to wait for stragglers.
  • Straggler Tolerance: The scheme is designed such that the master node can recover an approximate result even with a variable number of stragglers, as long as a sufficient subset of workers respond. The accuracy of the approximation improves with more results received.
  • Numerical Stability: Berrut's rational interpolation is chosen for its inherent numerical stability, addressing a key weakness of previous coded computing methods.

Datasets

The paper evaluates BACC on standard deep learning datasets:

  • MNIST
  • Fashion-MNIST
  • Cifar-10

These datasets are used to train a LeNet architecture in a distributed setting. No new benchmarks are introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Polynomials: The most significant insight is BACC's ability to handle arbitrary functions, not just polynomials. This dramatically expands the applicability of coded computing to modern, complex ML models.
  • Numerical Stability is Key: By leveraging Berrut's rational interpolation, BACC achieves numerical stability, a critical factor often overlooked in previous methods that struggled with real-number computations.
  • Flexible Straggler Handling: BACC doesn't require a fixed threshold for stragglers. It gracefully handles varying numbers of slow nodes, with accuracy directly correlating to the number of available results.
  • Efficient Approximation: The method provides a bounded approximation error, meaning that while it's not an exact computation, the error is controllable and theoretically bounded, which is often sufficient for ML tasks.

Key Results

  • Improved Convergence: In deep learning experiments, BACC demonstrated faster convergence (in terms of wall-clock time) compared to data replication and uncoded schemes, especially in the presence of stragglers.
  • Comparable Accuracy: While BACC might be slightly slower to reach peak accuracy than a data replication scheme in some cases, it achieves comparable final test accuracies on MNIST, Fashion-MNIST, and Cifar-10.
  • Reduced Error: Simulations showed that using Chebyshev points with BACC significantly reduces the expected relative error compared to using equidistant points for polynomial function approximation.
  • Scalability: BACC's requirement for worker nodes is not strictly tied to the complexity of the function in the same way as some polynomial-based coded computing methods, offering better scalability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximation Error: BACC provides an approximation, not an exact result. While the error is bounded, it's a trade-off for straggler resistance and efficiency. The paper acknowledges that the bounds derived might not be tight and further analysis could yield tighter error bounds.
  • Choice of Points: The performance of BACC is influenced by the choice of interpolation points. While Chebyshev points are suggested and analyzed, exploring other point distributions could be beneficial.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into tighter error bounds and exploring different point distributions for encoding and decoding. The application of BACC to other distributed learning scenarios and complex functions is also a natural extension.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{jahaninezhad2023berrut,
  author = {Tayyebeh Jahani-Nezhad and Mohammad Ali Maddah-Ali},
  title = {{Berrut Approximated Coded Computing: Straggler Resistance Beyond Polynomial Computing}},
  journal = {IEEE TPAMI},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/tpami.2022.3151434},
}
Figure