Bending and Compressive Strength Properties of Larix kaempferi According to Thinning Intensity

Song-Ho Chong, Kyung-Rok Won, Nam-Euy Hong, Byung-Su Park, Kyungjae Lee, Hee-Seop ByeonJournal of the Korean Wood Science and Technology 2014 · DOI

Abstract

This study evaluates the impact of plantation thinning on the physical and mechanical properties of Japanese Larch (Larix kaempferi). Samples were collected from unthinned, moderately thinned, and heavily thinned stands in the Kwangryung forest research area. Results indicate that while thinning increases the latewood ratio and annual ring width, it significantly reduces the average bending and parallel-to-grain compressive strengths. These findings suggest a critical trade-off between growth volume and structural timber quality.

Introduction

South Korea’s reforestation efforts have successfully increased land cover over recent decades. As these forests reach maturity, the focus is shifting from quantity to the production of high-quality timber. Thinning is a standard silvicultural practice used to improve the growth of remaining trees by reducing competition for light, water, and nutrients. While thinning is known to increase wood volume and diameter, its impact on mechanical strength—critical for construction and engineering—remains a subject of investigation. This study explores whether the rapid growth spurred by thinning compromises the wood's density and structural integrity.

Methods and Materials

The researchers studied a 46-year-old stand of Japanese Larch in the Kwangryung forest research area, comparing three management scenarios:

  1. Unthinned (Control): No trees removed.
  2. Moderate Thinning: 47% thinning intensity.
  3. Heavy Thinning: 74% thinning intensity.

Primary data was collected from 15 sample trees (5 per treatment group). Standardized specimens were prepared to test physical properties (annual ring width, latewood ratio, and air-dried density) and mechanical properties (Modulus of Rupture [MOR] and Modulus of Elasticity [MOE]) according to Korean Standard (KS) protocols. Statistical significance was determined using t-tests and Duncan’s multiple range tests.

Key Results

The Growth-Density Paradox

Thinning successfully increased the annual ring width (from 2.25 mm to 2.86 mm) and the latewood ratio. However, despite the higher proportion of latewood, the overall air-dried density decreased as thinning intensity increased, dropping from 0.65 g/cm³ in unthinned stands to 0.62 g/cm³ in heavily thinned stands.

Mechanical Performance

The study found a clear inverse relationship between thinning intensity and mechanical strength. As density dropped due to rapid growth, the structural properties followed suit:

  • Bending Properties: Bending strength (MOR) decreased from 107.35 MPa to 95.32 MPa (an 11% reduction), while stiffness (MOE) dropped from 10.67 GPa to 9.27 GPa.
Bending strength (MOR) and stiffness (MOE) decrease as thinning intensity increases.
  • Compressive Properties: Parallel-to-grain compressive strength decreased from 51.93 MPa to 45.12 MPa (a 13% reduction).
Compressive strength (MOR) and stiffness (MOE) show a similar downward trend with higher thinning intensity.

Discussion and Conclusion

The results suggest a "speed limit" for tree growth; forcing rapid development through aggressive thinning leads to a degradation of fiber quality. While thinning produces larger trees faster, the resulting timber may be less suitable for high-load structural applications.

Future research should investigate the economic balance between increased wood volume and decreased unit strength, particularly for industrial applications like Cross-Laminated Timber (CLT). Additionally, microscopic analysis of anatomical changes, such as tracheid length and cell wall thickness, is needed to fully explain why increased latewood ratios did not translate to higher strength in this species.

Summary updated

Abstract

우리나라의 중요한 조림 수종 중에서 낙엽송을 대상으로 하여, 간벌실시에 따른 물리 역학적 성질을 비교 평가함으로써 간벌 실시가 목재의 재질에 미치는 영향과 양질재 생산 및 목재의 효율적 이용을 위한 연구결과는 다음과 같다. 간벌정도에 따른 시료는 무간벌, 약도간벌, 강도간벌을 실시한 광릉시험림에서 벌채하여 사용하였다. 간벌 정도에 따른 평균 만재율은 무간벌 < 약도간벌 < 강도간벌의 경향이었고 평균 연륜폭은 무간벌 < 약도간벌 또는 강도간벌의 경향이었다. 간벌 정도에 따른 평균 휨강도는 무간벌 > 약도간벌 >강도간벌의 경향이었고 간벌 정도에 따른 평균 압축강도는 무간벌 > 약도간벌 >강도간벌의 경향이었다. 이러한 결과로 낙엽송은 간벌에 의하여 휨 및 종압축강도가 감소하는 경향이었다. The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of plantation thinning on physical and mechanical properties of Larix kaempferi. Tree samples were obtained from unthinned, moderately, heavily thinned plantations where located in Kwangryung forest research stand. The effects of different thinning methods on the bending and parallel to grain compressive strengths of Larix kaempferi were explored. Average latewood ratio with various thinning treatments revealed the trend of unthinning < moderate thinning < heavy thinning treatment. Average annual ring width with various thinning treatments showed the trend of unthinning < moderate thinning or heavy thinning treatment. Average bending and parallel to grain compressive strengths with various thinning treatments revealed the trend of unthinning > moderate thinning > heavy thinning treatment. This indicates that thinning treatment reduces average bending and parallel to grain compressive strength properties.
BibTeX
@article{chong2014bending,
  author = {Song-Ho Chong and Kyung-Rok Won and Nam-Euy Hong and Byung-Su Park and Kyungjae Lee and Hee-Seop Byeon},
  title = {{Bending and Compressive Strength Properties of Larix kaempferi According to Thinning Intensity}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korean Wood Science and Technology},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.5658/wood.2014.42.4.385},
}
Figure